Rule 5 Scouting
AI-powered analysis of Rule 5 draft eligible players
Freddie Freeman
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 player at 1B, making this a clear positional need. Freeman would immediately become your best 1B option and provide elite production at a thin position.
- Consistent 576-601 FPTS in 2024-2025, elite floor for fantasy production
- Career .295+ hitter with excellent OBP (.367-.378 recent years)
- 147 games played in each of last two seasons shows durability
- Still producing 22-24 HR with 35+ doubles annually
- Elite contact skills with manageable strikeout rates (100-128 K)
- Age 36 entering 2026 season - decline phase is inevitable
- FPTS dropped significantly from 916 (2023) to ~590 (2024-2025) - 35% decline
- Power and speed metrics trending down (29 HR/23 SB in 2023 to 24 HR/6 SB in 2025)
- OPS dropped from .976 to .869 over two years - concerning trajectory
- Rule 5 eligible suggests previous owner saw declining value
Suggested Action
Add Freeman immediately to fill your 1B hole - even in decline, his floor is higher than most available options, and he provides 2026 starting value while you develop long-term solutions.
Christian Yelich
Roster Fit
Your roster lacks a true DH-only slot filler, and Yelich could provide solid OF/DH flexibility. However, you already have 6 RF and multiple OF options, creating some redundancy.
- 2025 bounce-back: 553.5 FPTS with 29 HR, 16 SB in 150 games shows he can still produce
- Career-high strikeout rate (29%) in 2025 is concerning but power returned
- Elite peak (2018-2019 MVP caliber) is long gone but remains a viable fantasy contributor
- Walk rate remains solid (10%+), maintaining OBP floor
- Age 34 entering 2026 with significant injury history (only 73 games in 2024, 117 in 2021)
- Now DH-only, limiting roster flexibility and positional value
- 2025 batting average (.264) and OPS (.795) are well below his peak years
- Strikeout rate trending upward (29% in 2025) suggests declining bat speed
- Contract likely expensive for declining production curve
Suggested Action
Monitor Yelich's spring training health and role clarity before committing a roster spot; he's a depth add only if available cheaply, not a priority target.
Aroldis Chapman
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a clear contributor (338.9 FPTS). Chapman's elite 548.8 FPTS in 2025 would immediately become your best reliever and fill a significant roster gap.
- Elite 2025 production: 548.8 FPTS, 32 saves, 85 K in 61.1 IP
- Dominant ratios: 1.17 ERA, 0.70 WHIP - elite even by closer standards
- Consistent closer role with Boston, 67 appearances shows durability
- K rate remains elite (12.5 K/9) despite age
- Age 37 - significant decline risk, could fall off a cliff any season
- Reliever volatility - saves can disappear with role changes or injuries
- 2024 FPTS (369.7) was significantly lower, 2025 may be an outlier bounce-back
- No long-term dynasty value - this is a win-now play only
Suggested Action
Add Chapman immediately if competing in 2026; his elite closer production fills your biggest roster weakness, but be prepared to cut bait if he shows decline.
Taylor Ward
Roster Fit
LF is a position of need with only 2 players (Langford being the primary). Ward provides proven MLB production and power upside, but at 31 with a declining batting average, he's more of a complementary piece than a cornerstone.
- Career-high 36 HR in 2025 with 537.5 FPTS - significant power breakout at age 31
- 157 games played in 2025 shows durability and everyday role
- Consistent walk rate (75 BB in 2025) provides OBP floor around .315-.320
- Move to Baltimore (better lineup protection, hitter-friendly park) could sustain power gains
- Age 31 entering 2026 - limited upside window, decline phase likely within 2-3 years
- Batting average dropped to .228 in 2025 despite power surge - concerning swing-and-miss (175 K)
- OPS of .792 in 2025 is solid but not elite - relies heavily on HR for value
- Minimal speed contribution (4 SB) limits category flexibility
Suggested Action
Monitor Ward's availability but don't prioritize over younger upside plays; he's a solid floor option if Langford struggles or you need immediate OF production.
Seiya Suzuki
Roster Fit
Suzuki is DH-only which limits roster flexibility, but your roster lacks a true DH slot filler and could use another power bat. However, you're already deep at RF/OF corners where he'd compete for playing time.
- Consistent 475-522 FPTS over last 3 seasons - reliable floor
- Career-high 32 HR in 2025 with 151 games played shows durability
- 71 BB in 2025 demonstrates plate discipline that supports OBP
- 31 doubles + 3 triples provide extra-base hit upside beyond HR
- Age 31 entering 2026 - declining phase likely within keeper window
- Strikeout rate increased to 164 K in 2025 (career high)
- Batting average dropped to .245 in 2025 from .283-.285 range
- DH-only designation limits positional flexibility
- Stolen base contribution dropped from 16 (2024) to 5 (2025)
Suggested Action
Monitor his spring training role and early 2026 performance before committing a roster spot - he's a solid producer but not elite enough to prioritize over younger upside plays given your current OF depth.
Trevor Story
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS rostered (Bichette, Swanson, Tovar, Holliday, Lombard) making Story completely redundant. There is zero positional need here.
- 2025 bounce-back: 521 FPTS with 25 HR, 31 SB in 157 games shows he can still produce when healthy
- Power-speed combo remains intact: 25/31 is elite category contribution at SS
- High strikeout rate (176 K in 612 AB) limits batting average upside (.263)
- Age 33 entering 2026 with extensive injury history (missed most of 2023-2024)
- 2023-2024 combined just 69 games and 78.7 FPTS - durability is a major concern
- Low OBP (.308) and high K-rate suggest declining plate discipline
- Boston's roster construction may limit playing time if younger options emerge
Suggested Action
Pass on Story given your SS depth; if you need a power-speed SS, you already have better options in Bichette and Swanson.
Jorge Polanco
Roster Fit
Your roster lacks DH-only players and has limited 1B depth (only 1 player). Polanco could fill a utility/DH slot, but at 32 with positional limitations, he doesn't address your core needs at C, 1B, or corner outfield.
- Strong 2025 bounce-back: 499.3 FPTS, 26 HR, .821 OPS after dismal 2024
- Career-high 30 doubles in 2025 shows bat-to-ball improvement
- Reduced strikeouts significantly (82 K in 2025 vs 137 K in 2024)
- Solid power floor: 14-26 HR range over past 4 healthy seasons
- Age 32 DH-only profile limits positional flexibility and long-term value
- 2024 was a disaster (.213 AVG, .651 OPS) - 2025 could be outlier rebound
- Injury history: missed significant time in 2022, 2023, 2024
- No stolen base upside (6 SB in 2025, declining speed)
- Seattle's lineup context may not sustain counting stats
Suggested Action
Monitor Polanco's spring training role and health; only add if a clear everyday DH path emerges and you need a cheap power bat for depth.
Trent Grisham
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, so Grisham would be redundant depth rather than filling a need. His value is as a potential upgrade over Cowser's disappointing 154.9 FPTS, but not a clear starter.
- 2025 breakout: 34 HR, 87 R, 82 BB in 143 games (493.8 FPTS) - career-best power surge
- Strong OBP (.348) driven by elite walk rate despite .235 AVG
- 143 games played shows durability after injury-plagued 2024 (76 G)
- Yankees lineup provides favorable run-scoring environment
- Age 29 with volatile track record - 2022-2024 were brutal (.184-.199 AVG, sub-.700 OPS)
- 2025 power spike (34 HR) is a massive outlier vs career norms (10-17 HR range) - regression likely
- Minimal stolen base contribution (3 SB) limits category value
- High strikeout rate (137 K, 27.7%) remains a concern
- Free agent status uncertain - could land in worse lineup/park
Suggested Action
Monitor his free agency destination and spring training performance before committing a roster spot; his 2025 looks like an outlier rather than a new baseline.
Edwin Diaz
Roster Fit
Your roster has only Matt Strahm as a notable RP keeper, leaving significant closer/high-leverage reliever need. Diaz would immediately become your top reliever and provide elite saves production.
- 28 saves in 62 games with elite 1.63 ERA and 0.87 WHIP in 2025
- 98 strikeouts in 66.1 IP (13.3 K/9) demonstrates elite swing-and-miss stuff
- 492.4 FPTS in 2025 is exceptional for a reliever - among the best at the position
- Significant bounceback from 316.2 FPTS in 2024, showing return to form
- Age 31 - relievers can decline quickly, especially power arms
- History of injury concerns (missed 2023 entirely based on missing stats)
- Mets bullpen situation could change with free agency/trades affecting save opportunities
- Relievers inherently volatile year-to-year compared to starters
Suggested Action
Prioritize adding Diaz as he fills a clear roster weakness at RP and his 2025 production was elite; target him early in your Rule 5 draft.
Jose Altuve
Roster Fit
You already have 3 second basemen (Stott, Holliday, Albies) with significant salary commitments. Altuve would create redundancy at a position you're already deep at, though he could provide veteran stability if injuries occur.
- Consistent 490-524 FPTS over last two full seasons - reliable floor
- Still producing 20+ HR power at age 35 (26 HR in 2025)
- 155 games played in 2025 shows durability concerns may be overstated
- Career-long track record of elite contact skills (.265-.311 BA range recent years)
- Age 35 entering 2026 - decline phase is imminent or already underway
- OPS dropped from .915 (2023) to .771 (2025) - significant power/patience erosion
- Stolen base production declining (22 in 2024 to 10 in 2025)
- Walk rate and OBP trending down (.393 in 2023 to .329 in 2025)
- Houston's competitive window may be closing, affecting lineup protection
Suggested Action
Monitor Altuve's spring training performance and any contract/role changes, but don't prioritize given your existing 2B depth with younger, cheaper options.
Ryne Nelson
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Nelson would be redundant depth rather than filling a need, though he outproduced several of your current arms.
- 481.8 FPTS in 2025 represents significant jump from 366.2 in 2024 - clear positive trajectory
- 3.39 ERA and 1.07 WHIP in 154 IP shows he's a legitimate MLB starter
- 11 quality starts in 23 starts (48% QS rate) indicates reliability
- 132 K in 154 IP (7.7 K/9) is serviceable but not elite strikeout upside
- Age 27 limits long-term dynasty ceiling - this is likely close to his peak
- Arizona's hitter-friendly park inflates ERA risk
- Modest strikeout rate caps fantasy upside compared to elite arms
- Only 1 save/1 hold suggests limited multi-category flexibility
Suggested Action
Monitor Nelson's spring role and early 2026 performance, but don't prioritize over younger upside arms given your already deep SP corps.
Zack Littell
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Littell would be a back-end rotation option but creates redundancy rather than filling a need.
- 480.6 FPTS in 2025 represents solid SP4/SP5 production
- 32 starts with 17 quality starts shows durability and consistency
- Excellent control with only 32 walks in 186.2 IP (1.54 BB/9)
- 3.81 ERA and 1.10 WHIP are serviceable but not elite
- Clear upward trajectory: 183.6 → 387.4 → 480.6 FPTS over three seasons
- Age 30 limits long-term upside in dynasty format
- Modest strikeout rate (130 K in 186.2 IP = 6.27 K/9) caps ceiling
- Contact-heavy approach vulnerable to regression with BABIP luck
- Cincinnati's hitter-friendly park could inflate ERA
- No elite pitch or swing-and-miss stuff to project improvement
Suggested Action
Monitor Littell as a potential streaming option or injury replacement, but don't prioritize adding given your existing SP depth and his limited upside.
Ramon Laureano
Roster Fit
Your LF depth is thin with only Wyatt Langford as a clear starter. Laureano could provide backup OF value, but at 31 with inconsistent production history, he's not a priority add over younger options.
- 2025 breakout: 467.5 FPTS with 24 HR, .855 OPS in 132 games - career-best full season
- Power/speed combo: 24 HR and 7 SB provides dual category value
- Improved contact: .281 AVG in 2025 vs career .250 range
- Petco Park move to San Diego could suppress power slightly but lineup protection helps
- Age 31 entering 2026 - likely at or past peak, regression candidate
- 2024 showed only 176 FPTS in 98 games - 2025 could be outlier
- Volatile history: OPS ranged from .663 to .860 over past 5 seasons
- High strikeout rate (27% K rate in 2025) limits floor
- Playing time not guaranteed - could lose at-bats to younger players
Suggested Action
Monitor Laureano's spring training role and opening day roster status before committing a roster spot; he's a solid backup plan if a younger OF target falls through.
Carlos Estevez
Roster Fit
Your roster has only 6 RPs with Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS) as your top reliever. Estevez's 467.3 FPTS would immediately become your best reliever and fill a clear need for elite saves production.
- 42 saves in 2025 - elite closer role locked in with KC
- 467.3 FPTS in 2025 - massive jump from prior years (347-350 range)
- 2.45 ERA and 1.06 WHIP demonstrate quality ratios for a high-leverage arm
- 67 games pitched shows durability and manager trust
- Age 32 - reliever decline can be sudden, limited long-term upside
- K rate modest (54 K in 66 IP = 7.4 K/9) - not elite swing-and-miss stuff
- Closer role dependent on team context - KC may not contend, limiting save opps
- 2025 may be career year outlier - prior seasons were 100+ FPTS lower
Suggested Action
Add Estevez to secure elite saves production for 2026; his 467 FPTS output would be a significant upgrade over your current RP corps, but don't overpay given age-related decline risk.
Ronny Henriquez
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a clear high-value reliever. Henriquez's elite 2025 production (463.8 FPTS) would immediately become your best reliever and fill a clear roster need.
- Elite K rate: 98 strikeouts in 73 IP (12.1 K/9)
- Strong ratios: 2.22 ERA, 1.10 WHIP in high-leverage role
- Versatile value: 7 saves + 26 holds shows multi-category contribution
- Heavy workload: 69 games indicates manager trust and durability
- Massive FPTS jump from 53.1 (2024) to 463.8 (2025) shows breakout
- Small frame (5'10", 155 lbs) raises durability concerns long-term
- No 2023 stats available - limited track record before 2024
- Miami organization may have volatile bullpen roles year-to-year
- Age 25 with only one elite season - could be outlier performance
- High walk rate (27 BB in 73 IP) could regress ratios
Suggested Action
Add Henriquez immediately - his 2025 production was elite for a reliever and your RP corps desperately needs a high-end arm beyond Strahm.
Jung Hoo Lee
Roster Fit
You have CF depth with Simpson (294.3 FPTS) and Cowser (154.9 FPTS), but Lee's 456.3 FPTS significantly outproduces both. He would immediately become your best CF option and provide a clear upgrade.
- 456.3 FPTS in 2025 - elite production for a CF, top-tier fantasy contributor
- 150 games played demonstrates durability after injury-shortened 2024
- Strong contact profile: .266 AVG with only 71 strikeouts in 560 ABs (12.7% K rate)
- 12 triples provide rare category value, plus 31 doubles for solid extra-base production
- Balanced 10 SB adds speed element to high-contact approach
- Limited power ceiling - only 8 HR despite 560 ABs, caps upside in points leagues
- 2024 shoulder injury limited him to 37 games - durability concerns linger
- .734 OPS is solid but not elite; relies on volume and contact over impact
- Age 27 means you're buying the peak years, not growth potential
Suggested Action
Add Lee immediately - his 456 FPTS production is a significant upgrade over your current CF options and he's a proven everyday starter entering his prime.
Kyle Stowers
Roster Fit
You have Wyatt Langford and Colton Cowser as your primary LF/CF options, with Cowser underperforming (154.9 FPTS). Stowers could provide corner OF depth but creates some redundancy given your RF-heavy roster.
- Massive 2025 breakout: 453 FPTS with .288/.368/.544 slash line and 25 HR in 117 games
- Strong power profile with 21 2B, 3 3B, 25 HR showing legitimate 30+ HR upside
- Improved plate discipline: 48 BB vs 125 K (12% walk rate) shows maturation
- OPS jumped from .601 in 2024 to .912 in 2025 - legitimate breakout candidate
- Age 27 - this is likely his peak, not a developing asset with upside
- 2023-2024 were disasters (.208 BA, 74 K in 192 AB in 2024) - 2025 could be outlier
- 125 strikeouts in 399 AB (31% K rate) still concerning for batting average sustainability
- Miami's lineup provides limited protection and run-scoring opportunities
- Limited defensive value - corner OF only, no positional flexibility
Suggested Action
Monitor Stowers through spring training to confirm 2025 wasn't a fluke; if Cowser continues to struggle, Stowers becomes a viable replacement target at lower cost.
Brady Singer
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Singer would be redundant depth rather than an upgrade to your rotation core.
- Consistent 440 FPTS production in both 2024 and 2025 - reliable mid-rotation arm
- 32 starts and 169.2 IP shows durability and guaranteed workload
- 15 quality starts in 2025 indicates solid floor
- 163 strikeouts provides acceptable K production for fantasy
- 4.03 ERA and 1.24 WHIP are mediocre - not an ace profile
- Age 29 entering 2026 - no upside trajectory, this is his ceiling
- Now with CIN after trade - Great American Ballpark is hitter-friendly
- 60 walks in 169 IP shows command issues that inflate WHIP
- Your roster already has higher-upside SP options (Greene, Leiter, Misiorowski)
Suggested Action
Monitor Singer's spring role and early 2026 performance, but prioritize other Rule 5 targets given your existing SP depth.
Emilio Pagan
Roster Fit
Your roster has only Matt Strahm as a notable RP keeper, so adding a proven closer would fill a clear gap. However, at age 34, Pagan's elite 2025 may not be sustainable long-term in a dynasty format.
- 32 saves in 2025 - elite closer workload and opportunity
- 2.88 ERA and 0.92 WHIP in 68.2 IP - strong ratios for a high-leverage arm
- 81 strikeouts in 68.2 IP (10.6 K/9) - excellent swing-and-miss stuff
- 438.9 FPTS in 2025 - top-tier RP production, significantly above his 2023-2024 output
- Age 34 entering 2026 - reliever decline can be sudden and unpredictable
- Volatile recent history: 115.7 FPTS in 2024 suggests inconsistency year-to-year
- Closer roles are fragile - one bad stretch could cost him the job
- 22 walks in 68.2 IP (2.9 BB/9) - command not elite, could regress
Suggested Action
Monitor Pagan's spring training role and Cincinnati's bullpen depth; if he retains the closer job, consider adding mid-draft or via trade rather than burning a top Rule 5 pick on a 34-year-old reliever.
Josh Hader
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a notable reliever. Hader is an elite closer who would immediately become your best reliever and provide consistent saves production.
- Elite closer with 28 saves in 48 games (2025), on pace for 35+ full season
- Dominant ratios: 2.05 ERA and 0.85 WHIP in 2025
- Outstanding K rate: 76 strikeouts in 52.2 IP (13.0 K/9)
- Consistent fantasy production: 433-456 FPTS each of last 3 seasons
- Locked into high-leverage role with Houston
- Age 31 - entering decline phase for relievers, though elite ones often age well
- Reliever volatility - even elite closers can have rough stretches
- Salary likely to be expensive if this is an auction/salary league
- Slight FPTS decline trend (456→454→433) over 3 years
Suggested Action
Prioritize adding Hader immediately - he fills your biggest roster weakness and provides elite, reliable fantasy production at a scarce position.
Mickey Moniak
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu, Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Moniak would create significant redundancy at a position you're already deep at.
- 2025 breakout: 24 HR, 8 triples, .824 OPS across 135 games - career-best production
- 425.2 FPTS in 2025 doubled his previous season output
- Power/speed combo: 24 HR + 9 SB provides multi-category value
- Coors Field home games boost offensive ceiling
- Age 27 with inconsistent track record - 2024 was a .646 OPS disaster
- High strikeout rate (25%+ K%) limits batting average floor
- Poor plate discipline (22 BB in 434 AB) makes him volatile
- 2025 could be a Coors-inflated outlier rather than true breakout
- Former #1 overall pick who took 7 years to produce - late bloomer or fluky?
Suggested Action
Monitor Moniak's spring training role and early 2026 performance before adding, as your RF depth makes him a luxury rather than a need.
Bryan Abreu
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a clear high-value reliever. Abreu would immediately become your best reliever and provide elite ratios plus strikeout upside in a high-leverage role.
- Elite strikeout rate: 105 K in 71 IP (13.3 K/9) in 2025
- Strong ratios: 2.28 ERA and 1.15 WHIP across 70 appearances
- Consistent fantasy production: 414-450 FPTS each of last 3 seasons
- High-leverage role: 7 saves + 25 holds indicates closer-adjacent usage
- Workhorse usage: 70 games shows manager trust and durability
- Walk rate is elevated (31 BB in 71 IP = 3.9 BB/9) which could spike ERA
- Age 28 means you're buying peak years, not upside
- Not the primary closer (only 7 saves) limits ceiling in saves-only leagues
- Houston bullpen depth could see role fluctuation
Suggested Action
Prioritize adding Abreu as he fills a clear roster need at RP with proven, consistent production and elite strikeout upside.
Kris Bubic
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on roster including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Bubic would be depth at best, not a rotation upgrade.
- Strong 2025 breakout: 416.9 FPTS across 20 starts with 2.55 ERA
- 11 quality starts in 20 games shows consistency
- 116 K in 116.1 IP (9.0 K/9) is solid but not elite
- WHIP of 1.18 is respectable for a back-end starter
- Age 28 limits upside - this may be his ceiling, not a growth trajectory
- Prior seasons were poor: 145.6 FPTS in 2024, 28.2 in 2023 - one-year wonder risk
- 39 walks in 116 IP (3.0 BB/9) shows command concerns
- Kansas City's offense limits win opportunities
- No draft/prospect pedigree data available - harder to project sustainability
Suggested Action
Monitor Bubic's spring training role and early 2026 performance before committing a roster spot given your SP depth.
Dennis Santana
Roster Fit
Your RP depth shows 6 relievers but only Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS) is a clear contributor. Santana's 415.4 FPTS in 2025 would be your best reliever by a significant margin, filling a clear need.
- Elite 2025 ratios: 2.18 ERA, 0.87 WHIP across 70.1 IP
- 16 saves + 13 holds = high-leverage role secured in Pittsburgh
- 70 games pitched shows durability and manager trust
- Massive FPTS jump from 277.1 (2024) to 415.4 (2025) indicates breakout
- Age 29 - limited upside growth, closer to decline phase
- Pittsburgh's bullpen hierarchy could shift with acquisitions
- 2023 stats (23.8 FPTS) suggest volatility in role/performance
- Strikeout rate (60 K in 70.1 IP = 7.7 K/9) is below elite closer territory
Suggested Action
Monitor Pittsburgh's offseason moves; if Santana retains closer role, prioritize adding him as your RP1 upgrade over Strahm.
Lourdes Gurriel
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford (408.7 FPTS) at LF with similar production, plus depth at corner OF with Cowser, Caissie, and Kayfus. Gurriel would be redundant and offers no upside advantage.
- Consistent 400+ FPTS producer over past 3 seasons (407-461 range)
- Solid contact hitter with low strikeout rate (76 K in 500 AB in 2025)
- Modest power (18-24 HR range) with some stolen base contribution (7-10 SB)
- Everyday player getting 500+ AB annually
- Age 32 entering 2026 - declining phase likely, already seeing OPS drop from .772 (2023) to .713 (2025)
- FPTS trending downward each of last 3 seasons (461 → 421 → 408)
- No elite skill - just a compiler with limited upside
- Walk rate declining, OBP dropped to .295 in 2025
- Salary cost unknown but veteran likely expensive for marginal return
Suggested Action
Pass on Gurriel - he's a replacement-level OF in dynasty formats with declining production, and you have younger options at LF already.
Teoscar Hernandez
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu, Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Adding a 33-year-old declining outfielder creates significant redundancy at a position you're already overstocked.
- 25 HR in 2025 shows remaining power, but down from 33 HR in 2024
- FPTS dropped significantly from 562.6 (2024) to 406.6 (2025) - a 28% decline
- OPS crashed from .840 to .738 - concerning age-related decline
- Walk rate plummeted (26 BB in 511 AB vs 53 BB in 589 AB prior year)
- Age 33 entering 2026 - prime years clearly behind him
- Clear downward trajectory across all offensive metrics in 2025
- High strikeout rate (134 K) with declining contact quality
- No positional flexibility - RF only limits roster utility
- Likely expensive salary for declining production
Suggested Action
Pass on Hernandez - your RF depth is already excessive, and his declining production at age 33 doesn't warrant a roster spot over your younger, cheaper options like Abreu and Caglianone.
Willson Contreras
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 player at 1B, so there is positional need. However, Contreras at age 33 with declining catcher eligibility and now playing 1B offers limited upside compared to younger options.
- Consistent 20 HR power over multiple seasons (20 HR in 2023, 15 in 84 games 2024, 20 in 2025)
- Solid OBP (.344 in 2025) driven by decent walk rates
- 405.8 FPTS in 2025 represents a bounce-back from injury-shortened 2024 (260.9 FPTS)
- Durable when healthy - 135 games in 2025
- Age 33 entering 2026 - declining phase for a player who relied on athleticism behind the plate
- Lost catcher eligibility, now 1B-only which significantly reduces positional value
- Strikeout rate remains elevated (142 K in 490 AB in 2025 = 29%)
- OPS trending down from peak years (.888 in 2019 to .791 in 2025)
- 1B-only players need elite production to justify roster spots; Contreras is merely average
Suggested Action
Pass on Contreras and target younger 1B options with more upside; his production is replaceable via free agency or waiver wire.
Brad Keller
Roster Fit
You only have Matt Strahm as a quality RP keeper, and your RP depth is thin. Keller's elite 2025 production (405.7 FPTS, 25 holds, 2.07 ERA) fills a clear roster need at a position you've underinvested in.
- 405.7 FPTS in 2025 - elite reliever production, top-tier for the position
- 2.07 ERA with 0.96 WHIP across 69.2 IP - dominant ratios
- 75 K in 69.2 IP (9.7 K/9) shows swing-and-miss stuff
- 25 holds + 3 saves indicates high-leverage role locked in
- 68 appearances shows durability and manager trust
- Age 30 - limited upside window, likely 2-3 years of peak production remaining
- 2023-2024 FPTS of 15.4 and 7.6 suggest 2025 could be an outlier/career year
- No closing role - holds-dependent value caps fantasy ceiling
- Reliever volatility - role could change with Cubs bullpen moves
Suggested Action
Add Keller as a high-floor RP2 option; his 2025 breakout at age 29 in a stable Cubs bullpen role makes him a reliable contributor, but don't overpay given age and prior mediocre seasons.
Kenley Jansen
Roster Fit
Your RP depth shows 6 relievers but only Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS) is identified as a keeper. Jansen's 402.9 FPTS would be your top reliever, filling a clear need for elite saves production.
- 29 saves in 2025 - elite closer role secured with LAA
- 402.9 FPTS in 2025 - significant jump from 351.3 (2024) and 284.9 (2023)
- 2.59 ERA and 0.95 WHIP in 59 IP - still performing at high level
- 57 K in 59 IP - maintains strikeout ability despite age
- Age 38 heading into 2026 - significant decline risk at any moment
- LAA organizational instability - closer role could shift with trades or team direction
- Only 1 year of strong production after two declining seasons - could be outlier
- Velocity and durability concerns typical for late-30s relievers
- Rule 5 eligible suggests other owners passed - market has concerns
Suggested Action
Monitor Jansen's spring training and early 2026 role security before committing a roster spot; his age makes him a volatile asset despite strong 2025 numbers.
David Peterson
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Greene (452 FPTS), and Imanaga (416 FPTS). Peterson would be redundant depth at best.
- Consistent ~395-400 FPTS production in 2024-2025 indicates reliable backend starter
- 30 starts and 168.2 IP shows durability and rotation lock
- 15 quality starts in 2025 demonstrates ability to go deep in games
- 150 K in 168.2 IP (8.0 K/9) is serviceable but not elite
- 4.22 ERA and 1.37 WHIP are below-average ratios that limit upside
- Age 30 with no projection for improvement - this is his ceiling
- 65 walks in 168.2 IP (3.5 BB/9) indicates command issues
- Mets rotation depth could push him to bullpen or trade block
Suggested Action
Pass on Peterson - your SP corps is already loaded with higher-upside arms, and his ~400 FPTS production doesn't move the needle for a roster already carrying Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter.
Otto Lopez
Roster Fit
Creates significant redundancy at SS where you already have 5 players including Bo Bichette (570.8 FPTS), Dansby Swanson (421.2 FPTS), and Ezequiel Tovar. Lopez offers no positional upgrade or depth need.
- 399 FPTS in 2025 with 143 games played shows everyday role
- 15 HR/15 SB combo provides modest category balance
- Improved power from 6 HR in 2024 to 15 HR in 2025
- Contact-oriented approach with only 82 K in 544 AB
- Sub-.250 BA (.246) and weak OBP (.305) limit overall value
- .672 OPS indicates below-average offensive production
- Age 27 with limited upside - this is likely his ceiling
- Miami's rebuilding status could lead to reduced playing time if they acquire younger options
- No 2023 stats available creates uncertainty about development trajectory
Suggested Action
Pass on Lopez - your SS depth is already elite with Bichette and Swanson, and Lopez's 399 FPTS ceiling doesn't move the needle for your roster.
Raisel Iglesias
Roster Fit
Your roster has Matt Strahm as the only notable RP keeper, so adding a proven closer would address a clear positional need. However, at age 35, Iglesias carries age-related decline risk that limits long-term dynasty value.
- Elite closer role with 29 saves in 2025, providing scarce category value
- Strong ratios: 3.21 ERA and 0.995 WHIP demonstrate continued effectiveness
- 73 K in 67.1 IP (9.8 K/9) shows strikeout upside remains intact
- 523.3 FPTS in 2024 was elite RP production; 398.8 in 2025 still solid
- Age 35 entering 2026 - significant decline risk in the near term
- FPTS dropped ~24% from 2024 to 2025, suggesting possible regression trend
- Closer roles are volatile; any injury or performance dip could cost saves
- Contract status unknown - could change teams or lose role in offseason
Suggested Action
Monitor Iglesias's offseason situation; if he secures a closer role on a competitive team, prioritize adding him to fill your RP gap, but don't overpay given age concerns.
Miguel Vargas
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with only 248.8 FPTS in 2025, creating potential competition. Vargas could serve as 3B depth or CI flex, but doesn't address your bigger needs at 1B or C.
- 2025 breakout: 398.5 FPTS across 138 games shows everyday player capability
- Solid power/speed combo: 16 HR, 6 SB, 32 doubles in 2025
- Strong walk rate (56 BB) provides OBP floor around .316
- Age 26 entering prime years with established MLB role
- Batting average liability: .234 in 2025, career .195 hitter before that
- Playing for rebuilding CHW limits RBI/run opportunities
- 2024 was disastrous (.150 AVG, 0.506 OPS) - 2025 could be outlier
- Strikeout concerns persist (100 K in 504 AB)
- Positional value limited to 3B only
Suggested Action
Monitor Vargas through spring training to confirm everyday role, but prioritize addressing your 1B hole before adding 3B depth behind Riley.
Chris Bassitt
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including high-upside arms like Hunter Greene, Jack Leiter, and Jacob Misiorowski. Bassitt would be redundant depth at a position of strength, not filling any roster gap.
- Durable innings eater: 170.1 IP in 2025 with 31 starts
- Solid strikeout rate: 166 K in 2025 (8.8 K/9)
- 11 quality starts provides baseline floor value
- Consistent mid-rotation production when healthy
- Age 36 heading into 2026 - declining phase of career
- 2025 FPTS (397.8) down significantly from 2023 peak (618.0)
- ERA trending wrong direction (3.96 in 2025)
- WHIP of 1.33 indicates regression from prior elite seasons
- You previously let him go - suggests you already evaluated and passed
- Limited upside ceiling compared to younger SP options on your roster
Suggested Action
Pass on Bassitt - your SP depth is already strong with higher-upside options, and his declining production at age 36 doesn't warrant a roster spot over your current arms.
Michael Wacha
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Greene, Leiter, and Misiorowski. Wacha would be redundant depth at best, not an upgrade over your current options.
- Consistent innings eater: 172.2 IP in 2025 with 31 starts
- Solid but unspectacular ratios: 3.86 ERA, 1.22 WHIP
- 13 quality starts shows reliability for streaming value
- Fantasy production declining: 501 FPTS (2024) → 395 FPTS (2025)
- Age 34 entering 2026 - declining phase of career
- Strikeout rate mediocre (6.6 K/9) limits upside
- FPTS dropped 21% year-over-year, concerning trend
- No elite skill - replacement-level SP4/SP5 profile
- Injury history throughout career adds durability concerns
Suggested Action
Pass on Wacha - your rotation is stacked with younger, higher-upside arms; use roster spot on a prospect or position of need instead.
Jeffrey Springs
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including high-end arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Greene (452 FPTS), and Imanaga (416 FPTS). Springs would be redundant depth at a position of strength.
- 394.9 FPTS in 2025 represents a solid bounce-back after injury-plagued 2023-24
- 30 starts and 171 IP shows durability when healthy
- 14 quality starts indicates mid-rotation reliability
- 138 K in 171 IP (7.3 K/9) is below-average strikeout production
- Age 33 entering 2026 - declining phase of career
- 4.10 ERA and 1.21 WHIP are mediocre ratios for fantasy
- History of significant injury (missed most of 2023-24 with only 86 and 111 FPTS)
- Now with Oakland - poor team context for wins and run support
- K rate trending down limits upside in points leagues
Suggested Action
Pass on Springs - your SP depth is already elite, and his mediocre ratios, age, and poor team context make him a low-priority add even if he were a roster need.
Jason Adam
Roster Fit
Your RP depth shows 6 relievers but only Matt Strahm is identified as a keeper. Adam would provide elite setup man production but at age 35 in 2026, his value window is narrow and he lacks saves upside.
- Elite ERA (1.93) and solid WHIP (1.15) in 65.1 IP in 2025
- 29 holds indicate high-leverage role but no closer path
- 486.8 FPTS in 2024 shows peak production ceiling
- Consistent workload (65 games) demonstrates durability
- Age 34 now, will be 35 during 2026 season - reliever decline risk
- Zero saves - purely a holds/ratios contributor with limited category upside
- FPTS declined from 486.8 (2024) to 390.9 (2025) - trending down
- Traded to SD - new team/role uncertainty for 2026
Suggested Action
Monitor Adam's spring role in San Diego; only add if he secures closer job or your league heavily rewards holds.
Luis Garcia
Roster Fit
Creates significant redundancy at 2B where you already roster Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists for another middle infielder.
- Consistent 400+ FPTS producer in 2024-2025 (421.2 and 389.6)
- Solid power/speed combo: 16-18 HR and 14-22 SB over last two seasons
- Everyday starter getting 140 games and 500 AB annually
- Career-high doubles (28) in 2025 shows gap power development
- FPTS declined from 421.2 (2024) to 389.6 (2025) - trending wrong direction
- Poor plate discipline: only 27 BB in 488 AB (5.5% walk rate) caps OBP ceiling
- Batting average dropped from .282 to .252 year-over-year
- Washington's rebuilding status may limit RBI/run opportunities
- Age 25 with established ceiling - limited upside remaining
Suggested Action
Pass on Garcia given your 2B depth is elite; use roster spot on a position of need like 1B or high-upside pitching.
Jeremiah Estrada
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a clear high-value reliever. Estrada would immediately become your best setup man and provides elite strikeout upside from the bullpen.
- 108 K in 73 IP (13.3 K/9) - elite strikeout rate for fantasy points
- 388.1 FPTS in 2025 - outproduced several of your rostered starters
- 30 holds indicates high-leverage role locked in with San Diego
- 77 games shows durability and manager trust
- 3.45 ERA/1.16 WHIP - solid ratios for a high-volume reliever
- Age 27 - limited upside growth, this is likely his ceiling
- Only 3 saves - not a closer, limits fantasy ceiling in traditional formats
- 27 walks in 73 IP (3.3 BB/9) - command is average, not elite
- Reliever volatility - role could change with bullpen shuffles or trade
Suggested Action
Add Estrada to fill your RP gap - he's a proven high-leverage arm with elite strikeouts who will contribute immediately in 2026.
Clay Holmes
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Holmes would be redundant depth rather than filling a need, though he offers a different profile as a groundball-heavy innings eater.
- 386.9 FPTS in 2025 represents his best fantasy season, showing viability as a starter
- 165.2 IP across 31 starts demonstrates durability in his first full year as a starter
- 3.53 ERA is serviceable but not elite - mid-rotation ceiling
- 12 wins provide category value in traditional leagues
- Age 32 entering 2026 - limited upside trajectory, likely at or near peak
- 1.30 WHIP and 66 walks in 165 IP indicate command issues that could regress
- Only 129 strikeouts (7.0 K/9) limits fantasy upside compared to elite arms
- First full season as starter after reliever conversion - sustainability uncertain
- Mets rotation has competition; role could fluctuate
Suggested Action
Monitor Holmes through spring training to confirm rotation spot, but prioritize younger upside arms or position needs over adding another mid-tier SP to an already deep staff.
Jose Berrios
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Greene, Leiter, and Misiorowski. Berrios would be redundant and not an upgrade over your current options.
- Consistent innings eater: 166 IP in 2025 with 30 starts
- 14 quality starts shows reliability for counting stats
- 138 strikeouts provides moderate K upside
- 561 FPTS in 2024 was his peak recent value
- Age 31 with declining trajectory: FPTS dropped from 561 (2024) to 386 (2025)
- 4.17 ERA and 1.30 WHIP are below-average ratios that hurt in most formats
- K rate declining (138 K in 166 IP = 7.5 K/9 is pedestrian)
- No upside ceiling - this is who he is at this point in his career
Suggested Action
Pass on Berrios; your SP core is already strong and younger arms like Leiter and Misiorowski offer more upside at lower cost.
Addison Barger
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with 248.8 FPTS (injury-impacted) plus multiple SS-eligible players who could slide over. Barger would be redundant depth at a position you're already covered.
- 2025 breakout: 382.1 FPTS across 135 games shows everyday role
- 21 HR with 32 doubles provides solid power production
- .755 OPS is league-average but playable for fantasy
- 135 games played demonstrates durability and trust from Toronto
- Low batting average (.243) and OBP (.301) limit ceiling in points leagues
- 121 strikeouts in 460 ABs (26.3% K rate) is concerning
- 2024 was brutal (.197/.250/.351) - 2025 could be outlier
- Only 4 SBs means limited category contribution
- Toronto's roster flux could impact playing time in 2026
Suggested Action
Pass on Barger - your 3B/corner infield depth with Riley, Albies, and SS flexibility makes this a redundant add for a player with a low floor.
Hunter Gaddis
Roster Fit
You have 6 RPs including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS), so reliever depth exists but Gaddis would be an upgrade over lower-end options. His 468.2 FPTS in 2024 and 377.0 in 2025 show consistent middle-relief value.
- 35 holds in 2025 indicates high-leverage role and consistent usage
- 73 games pitched shows durability and manager trust
- 3.10 ERA and 1.185 WHIP are solid for a setup man
- 73 K in 66.2 IP (9.9 K/9) demonstrates swing-and-miss stuff
- 468.2 FPTS in 2024 was elite RP production
- Age 27 with declining FPTS (468→377) suggests possible regression or reduced role
- Only 3 saves limits upside in standard formats without holds scoring
- Cleveland bullpen is crowded - Emmanuel Clase locks down closer role
- No path to closing means capped fantasy ceiling
- RP value is volatile year-to-year based on team context
Suggested Action
Monitor Gaddis as a mid-tier RP option but don't prioritize unless your league heavily rewards holds or you lose Strahm.
Lawrence Butler
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Butler would be a clear upgrade over your depth pieces but creates significant redundancy at a position you're already stacked.
- Consistent 20+ HR power with 21-22 homers in back-to-back full seasons
- Solid speed component with 18-22 SB annually, rare power/speed combo
- Full-time everyday player: 152 games in 2025, locked into lineup
- 376-396 FPTS range over two seasons shows reliable fantasy floor
- Significant regression in 2025: AVG dropped from .262 to .234, OPS fell from .807 to .710
- Strikeout rate remains elevated (179 K in 569 AB = 31.5% K rate)
- Oakland's rebuilding status limits lineup protection and run production upside
- Walk rate modest (10.4% in 2025) - OBP ceiling is capped
Suggested Action
Monitor Butler's price in your league but don't prioritize given your RF depth - only pursue if you can move Caissie/Kayfus first or if he falls significantly in value.
Zach McKinstry
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B plus multiple middle infield options (Stott, Holliday, Albies, Bichette, Swanson, Tovar). McKinstry would be redundant depth at best with no clear path to your starting lineup.
- 2025 breakout: 375.7 FPTS with career-highs in HR (12), SB (19), and triples (11)
- Solid OBP improvement to .333 in 2025 after sub-.280 marks in 2022-2024
- Multi-position eligibility provides roster flexibility
- 144 games played in 2025 shows durability and everyday role
- Age 30 - no upside trajectory, this is likely his ceiling
- Career .230 hitter with inconsistent production year-to-year
- 2025 appears to be an outlier season; 2024 was just 137.9 FPTS
- 11 triples is unsustainable and inflated his 2025 value
- Utility player profile limits ceiling even in best-case scenario
Suggested Action
Pass on McKinstry - his 2025 spike is likely an outlier, and at 30 years old with your deep infield, he offers no meaningful upgrade or prospect value.
Christian Walker
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 player at 1B, indicating a clear positional need. However, Walker's declining production and age (35 in 2026) make him a poor dynasty investment despite the roster gap.
- Consistent 25-30 HR power over career when healthy
- 154 games played in 2025 shows durability
- Career-worst 2025 slash line (.238/.297/.421) signals decline
- FPTS dropped from 631 (2023) to 447 (2024) to 376 (2025) - 40% decline in 2 years
- Age 34 entering 2026 with clear statistical decline trajectory
- OBP dropped below .300 in 2025 (.297) - worst since 2018 cup of coffee
- Strikeout rate spiked to 177 K in 2025 (career high in full season)
- Limited positional flexibility - 1B only with no stolen base value
- Houston move may not reverse decline - still facing age-related regression
Suggested Action
Pass on Walker and target younger 1B options in the Rule 5 pool or via trade; his declining production makes him a poor dynasty asset despite your 1B need.
Gavin Sheets
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford at LF with superior production (408.7 FPTS) and upside. Sheets would be redundant depth at a position you don't need to address.
- Career-best 2025 season: 374.7 FPTS, 19 HR, .746 OPS across 145 games
- Showed improved power output with 28 doubles and 19 HR in 2025
- Consistent everyday playing time (492 AB) suggests established role
- Walk rate improved to 8.2% in 2025, showing better plate discipline
- Age 29 with limited upside - this is likely his ceiling, not a breakout
- Below-average OBP (.317) and OPS (.746) for a corner outfielder
- Zero speed contribution (2 SB) limits fantasy category value
- You previously let him go, suggesting you already evaluated and passed
- New team (SD) - role uncertainty after offseason move
Suggested Action
Pass on Sheets - he's a replacement-level corner bat with a low ceiling, and you have better options at LF already.
Jeff Hoffman
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a notable reliever. Hoffman would provide elite saves volume and immediate fantasy value, filling a clear roster need.
- 33 saves in 2025 - elite closer volume in a scarce category
- 425.7 FPTS in 2024, 373.1 FPTS in 2025 - consistent high-end RP production
- 84 strikeouts in 68 IP (11.1 K/9) - strong strikeout upside
- Locked into closer role with Toronto through 2025 performance
- Age 32 - limited long-term dynasty value, peak years likely behind him
- 4.37 ERA in 2025 shows regression from elite 2024 - underlying skills may be declining
- 1.19 WHIP and 27 walks in 68 IP indicate some control concerns
- Reliever volatility - role could change with poor performance or team direction
Suggested Action
Monitor Hoffman's spring training role and early 2026 usage; if he retains the closer job and your league values saves heavily, he's worth acquiring at a reasonable cost.
Xavier Edwards
Roster Fit
Creates significant redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists for Edwards.
- Strong stolen base contributor: 27 SB in 2025, 31 SB in 70 games in 2024
- High contact rate with .283-.328 BA range across MLB seasons
- Everyday playing time secured: 139 games, 561 AB in 2025
- Solid OBP (.342 in 2025) driven by walks and contact
- Severe power regression: only 3 HR in 561 AB (2025), OPS dropped from .820 to .695
- Fantasy value ceiling is capped by lack of power (.353 SLG in 2025)
- 372 FPTS in full season is below your three current 2B options
- Age 26 with declining production trajectory suggests this is his ceiling
Suggested Action
Pass on Edwards as your 2B depth is elite and his power-deficient profile produces fewer fantasy points than your existing options.
Colin Rea
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Greene, Leiter, and Misiorowski. Rea would be redundant depth at best and blocks younger development options.
- Consistent 362-372 FPTS over 2024-2025 indicates reliable backend starter production
- 159.1 IP with 27 starts shows durability and rotation security
- 3.95 ERA and 1.25 WHIP are serviceable but unexciting ratios
- 127 K in 159 IP (7.2 K/9) limits upside in strikeout-heavy formats
- Age 35 entering 2026 season - decline phase is imminent
- Only 7 quality starts in 27 starts indicates inconsistency
- No elite skill - replacement-level production available on waivers
- Cubs rotation has younger options competing for innings in 2026
Suggested Action
Pass on Rea entirely - your rotation is stacked with higher-upside arms, and a 35-year-old backend starter with declining skills doesn't warrant a roster spot over your existing depth.
Jared Koenig
Roster Fit
You only have Matt Strahm as a dedicated RP keeper, so Koenig could provide bullpen depth. However, at 31 years old with a middle-relief profile, he's not a high-priority add over younger upside plays.
- 370 FPTS in 2025 is solid for a reliever - 72 appearances, 27 holds, 2 saves
- Strong ratios: 2.86 ERA, 1.17 WHIP in 66 IP
- K/BB ratio of 3.4 (68 K / 20 BB) shows good command
- Year-over-year improvement from 272.9 FPTS (2024) to 370 FPTS (2025)
- Age 31 - limited upside and declining years ahead
- No closing experience - only 2 saves despite 72 appearances
- Setup role dependent on team context - could lose holds if traded or demoted
- You previously let him go, suggesting you've already evaluated and passed
- No 2023 stats available - unclear track record before 2024
Suggested Action
Monitor Koenig's role in Milwaukee's bullpen but don't prioritize adding him unless he moves into a closer role or your RP depth becomes critical.
Dean Kremer
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extensive with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Greene (452 FPTS), and Imanaga (416 FPTS). Kremer would be redundant depth at best, not an upgrade.
- Durable innings eater: 171.2 IP in 2025 with 29 starts
- Modest strikeout rate: 142 K in 171.2 IP (7.4 K/9)
- Inconsistent fantasy production: 369.7 FPTS in 2025, down from 433.2 in 2023
- Secured rotation spot in competitive Baltimore staff
- Age 29 with limited upside - this is likely his ceiling
- 4.19 ERA and 1.21 WHIP are below-average ratios for fantasy
- Quality start rate (9 in 29 starts) is mediocre
- No elite skill - average K rate, average control, average results
Suggested Action
Pass on Kremer - your SP core is already strong and he offers no meaningful upgrade over your existing depth pieces like Chad Patrick (296.7 FPTS) or Jack Leiter (367.5 FPTS).
Brendon Little
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 total RP slots filled. Little would add depth but doesn't address a pressing need given your thin 1B/C situation.
- Strong 2025 workload: 79 games, 68.1 IP with 30 holds indicates trusted high-leverage role
- Solid K rate: 91 strikeouts in 68.1 IP (12.0 K/9) drives fantasy value
- 366.5 FPTS in 2025 is elite for a non-closer reliever
- 3.03 ERA is quality, though 1.36 WHIP shows some control issues
- Age 29 with no closer role - limited upside ceiling without saves
- 45 walks in 68.1 IP (5.9 BB/9) is concerning and could lead to regression
- Only 1 save despite heavy usage - may never get closer opportunity in Toronto
- No 2023 data available - unclear track record before 2024 breakout
- Reliever volatility - role could change with any bullpen shuffle
Suggested Action
Monitor Little's spring training role and Toronto's closer situation; only add if he's in line for saves or your RP depth takes a hit.
Yusei Kikuchi
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Bichette-level production from Greene, and upside plays in Leiter/Misiorowski. Kikuchi would be redundant depth at best.
- 365.5 FPTS in 2025 represents a significant decline from 476.9 in 2024 (-23%)
- 33 starts and 178.1 IP shows durability/workload reliability
- 174 strikeouts provides some counting stat value
- 11 quality starts in 33 games (33% QS rate) is below average
- Age 34 entering 2026 season - declining phase of career
- 1.424 WHIP and 74 walks indicate poor command/ratios liability
- 3.99 ERA is serviceable but not difference-making
- FPTS trending downward: 441→477→366 over three years
- Angels likely to be non-competitive, limiting win opportunities
Suggested Action
Pass on Kikuchi - your rotation is already stacked with younger, higher-upside arms, and his declining production at age 34 doesn't warrant a roster spot over your existing depth.
Mike Yastrzemski
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu, Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Adding a 35-year-old declining outfielder creates significant redundancy at an already overcrowded position.
- Consistent 15-20 HR power with 17 HR in 2025
- Strong walk rate (72 BB in 2025) supporting OBP floor
- 364 FPTS in 2025 represents his ceiling at this stage
- Durable - played 140+ games in 3 of last 4 full seasons
- Age 35 entering 2026 - decline phase is imminent or already underway
- Batting average has been stuck in .230s for 4 consecutive seasons
- Power trending down from 25 HR (2021) to 17 HR (2025)
- Moved from SF to KC - unclear playing time path with Royals outfield
- OPS has declined from .968 (2020) to .735 (2025) over 5 years
Suggested Action
Pass on Yastrzemski - your RF depth is already excessive, and a 35-year-old with declining production offers no upside worth a roster spot over your younger options.
Mike Trout
Roster Fit
Roster lacks a true DH slot filler and has no elite power bat. Trout would provide power upside but creates no positional flexibility given DH-only status at age 34.
- 2025 showed 130 games played - best health since 2019, producing 364 FPTS
- 26 HR in 2025 demonstrates remaining power, though down from peak 40+ HR seasons
- Elite walk rate (87 BB in 2025) sustains OBP value even with declining batting average (.232)
- Career track record: 3-time MVP, historically elite producer when healthy
- Age 34 with extensive injury history - played only 29 games in 2024, 82 in 2023, 36 in 2021
- 2025 slash line (.232/.359/.439) represents significant decline from prime years
- DH-only limits roster flexibility and lineup construction options
- 178 strikeouts in 2025 is a career-high rate, suggesting bat speed decline
- Angels unlikely to contend, reducing late-season motivation/opportunity
Suggested Action
Monitor spring training health reports and early 2026 performance before committing a roster spot; only add if available at minimal cost and DH slot is needed.
Jose Soriano
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on roster including high-end arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Greene (452 FPTS), and Imanaga (416 FPTS). Soriano would be redundant depth rather than filling a need.
- 359.5 FPTS in 2025 shows solid full-season workload (31 GS, 169 IP)
- Consistent year-over-year improvement: 168.5 → 304.3 → 359.5 FPTS
- 15 quality starts in 2025 indicates durability and reliability
- 152 strikeouts shows adequate swing-and-miss stuff
- 4.26 ERA and 1.40 WHIP are below-average ratios for fantasy SP
- 78 walks in 169 IP (4.15 BB/9) is a significant command concern
- Age 27 limits upside - this is likely close to his ceiling
- Angels organization unlikely to contend, limiting win opportunities
- FPTS total (359.5) ranks below your top 5 SP already rostered
Suggested Action
Pass on adding Soriano given your deep SP rotation; only revisit if you lose a starter to injury or trade.
J.P. Crawford
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS rostered including Bo Bichette (570.8 FPTS), Dansby Swanson (421.2 FPTS), and Ezequiel Tovar. Crawford would be redundant depth at a position you're already stacked at.
- Strong plate discipline with 74 BB in 2025 (career-high walk rates)
- Durable - played 157 games in 2025 after injury-shortened 2024
- Consistent contact hitter with .265 AVG in 2025, rebounding from .201 in 2024
- 359.2 FPTS in 2025 represents solid but unspectacular SS production
- Age 30 with declining power trajectory (12 HR in 2025 vs 19 HR in 2023)
- Minimal stolen base contribution (8 SB in 2025)
- 2024 injury-shortened season (105 games, 197.3 FPTS) raises durability concerns
- OPS dropped from .818 in 2023 to .722 in 2025 - trending wrong direction
- Ceiling appears capped - unlikely to return to 509 FPTS (2023) level
Suggested Action
Pass on Crawford - your SS depth is already elite with Bichette and Swanson, and Crawford's declining production at age 30 doesn't warrant a roster spot over your existing options.
JoJo Romero
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 total RP on roster. Romero would add depth but creates some redundancy in a non-premium position.
- Strong 2025 campaign: 357.9 FPTS across 65 games with 2.07 ERA
- Versatile reliever role: 8 saves + 24 holds indicates high-leverage usage
- Consistent workload: 61 IP shows durability and manager trust
- Clear upward trajectory: FPTS jumped from 149.6 (2023) to 293.2 (2024) to 357.9 (2025)
- Age 29 - limited upside growth, likely at or near peak value
- Walk rate concerning: 29 BB in 61 IP (4.3 BB/9) creates volatility
- Not a closer - 8 saves suggests committee or setup role, capping fantasy ceiling
- RP value is volatile year-to-year; 2025 may represent career-best
- No draft/prospect pedigree data available
Suggested Action
Add to watchlist and monitor if saves role expands in STL, but don't prioritize over higher-impact adds given existing RP depth.
Nathan Lukes
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Lukes creates complete redundancy at an already overcrowded position.
- 2025 breakout with 355 FPTS across 135 games shows he can produce when given playing time
- Solid contact skills with only 60 strikeouts in 388 ABs (15.5% K rate)
- 12 HR with modest power upside, .407 SLG is league average
- Low walk rate (9.8%) and minimal speed (2 SB, 4 CS) limit ceiling
- Age 31 - no dynasty upside, this is likely his peak or decline phase
- Career journeyman who didn't establish MLB role until age 30
- 2025 was first extended MLB opportunity - regression likely
- Toronto's outfield depth could squeeze him out of regular playing time in 2026
- .729 OPS is replacement-level production for a corner outfielder
Suggested Action
Pass on Lukes entirely - he's a 31-year-old with one decent season who doesn't fit your roster needs and offers zero long-term value for a dynasty league.
Bryan King
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 total RP slots filled. King would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap. His 354.8 FPTS would rank as your second-best reliever.
- Elite ratios: 2.78 ERA and 1.04 WHIP across 68 innings in 2025
- Strong K/BB profile: 69 K vs only 11 BB (6.27 K/BB ratio)
- High-leverage role: 27 holds indicates trusted setup man
- Workhorse usage: 68 games shows durability and manager trust
- Age 29 - limited upside trajectory, this is likely his peak
- Only 2 saves - not in closer role, capping fantasy ceiling
- No 2023 data available - unclear track record before breakout
- Relievers are volatile year-to-year; 2024 FPTS was only 104.0
- Houston bullpen is deep - role could shrink with acquisitions
Suggested Action
Monitor King's spring training role; only add if he secures saves or your RP depth thins due to injury.
Shane Smith
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Leiter, and Imanaga. Smith would be redundant depth rather than filling a need, though he could compete for a back-end rotation spot.
- 354.4 FPTS in 2025 is solid but ranks below your top 4 SPs (Castillo 533, Greene 452, Imanaga 416, Leiter 367)
- 29 starts with 146.1 IP shows durability and a guaranteed rotation spot
- 145 K in 146.1 IP (8.9 K/9) is respectable strikeout production
- 3.81 ERA is serviceable but not elite - mid-rotation profile
- No stat history before 2025 - unclear if this is a breakout or his ceiling
- 1.20 WHIP with 58 walks (3.6 BB/9) indicates command issues that could regress
- White Sox organization context - poor team support limits win potential
- 7 QS in 29 starts (24%) is concerning for a full-time starter
- Age 25 with only one MLB season of data is a limited sample
Suggested Action
Monitor Smith's spring training and early 2026 performance before committing a roster spot - your SP depth doesn't require adding marginal arms.
Eric Lauer
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Lauer would be backend rotation depth at best, creating redundancy rather than filling a need.
- Solid 3.18 ERA and 1.11 WHIP in 104.2 IP shows competent mid-rotation production
- 349.7 FPTS in 2025 is respectable but ranks below your top 5 SP options
- 9-2 record with 102 K in 28 appearances (15 starts) indicates swing role versatility
- Only 4 quality starts in 15 GS suggests inconsistent length/dominance
- Age 30 with no 2024 data suggests injury or performance issues that season
- 2023 showed -0.0 FPTS indicating a lost season (likely injury/surgery)
- Toronto rotation has competition; role security is uncertain for 2026
- Low quality start rate (27%) limits upside in formats rewarding deep outings
Suggested Action
Monitor Lauer's spring training role and health updates, but don't prioritize given your existing SP depth—only add if a top-5 SP gets injured.
Marcell Ozuna
Roster Fit
DH-only player offers no positional flexibility for a roster already stacked at OF/utility spots. At 35, he doesn't fit the dynasty timeline of this younger-skewing roster.
- 2024 was a career year (39 HR, .924 OPS, 656 FPTS) but appears to be an outlier
- 2025 shows significant regression: HR dropped from 39 to 21, OPS from .924 to .755, FPTS from 656 to 349
- Still draws walks (94 BB in 2025) which provides floor value
- Zero speed contribution (0 SB in 2025)
- Age 35 entering 2026 - decline phase is real and accelerating
- 2025 production (348.8 FPTS) is barely above replacement level for a DH-only player
- Power numbers cratered in 2025 (.400 SLG vs .546 in 2024) - concerning trend
- DH-only limits roster flexibility significantly
- History of volatile production (2021-2022 were poor seasons before 2023-24 bounce)
Suggested Action
Pass on Ozuna - the 2025 decline is too steep for a 35-year-old DH-only player, and your roster has better options for utility spots.
Josh Bell
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 player at 1B depth, but Bell is primarily a DH with declining production. At 33 years old with no speed and middling power, he doesn't fill a meaningful gap.
- Consistent 19-22 HR output over past 3 seasons, but down from 27-37 HR peak years
- Steady ~350 FPTS annually (2023-2025), providing floor but limited ceiling
- Strong walk rate (57 BB in 2025) supports OBP but doesn't translate to elite fantasy value
- 140+ games played consistently shows durability
- Age 33 with declining power trajectory (peaked at 37 HR in 2019, now 19-22 range)
- Zero stolen bases with negative CS impact - complete liability in SB categories
- DH-only limits roster flexibility and playing time security
- OPS declined from .936 (2019) to .747 (2025) - steady erosion of offensive value
- Batting average trending down (.277 in 2019 to .239 in 2025)
Suggested Action
Pass on Bell - his declining production and DH-only status make him a replacement-level option; use the roster spot on a younger player with upside.
Paul Goldschmidt
Roster Fit
You only have 1 1B rostered, so there is positional need, but Goldschmidt's declining production and age make him a poor fit for a dynasty roster seeking long-term value.
- FPTS declined sharply: 521.4 (2023) → 323.7 (2024) → 340.4 (2025)
- Power cratered: 35 HR in 2022 down to just 10 HR in 2025
- OPS dropped from .981 (2022) to .730 (2025) - a 250-point decline
- Still plays 146+ games, providing counting stat floor
- Age 38 entering 2026 - further decline highly likely
- Contact quality deteriorating: BA dropped from .317 (2022) to .274 (2025)
- Walk rate collapsed: 87 BB (2023) to 36 BB (2025) signals declining plate discipline
- New team (NYY) may reduce playing time if struggles continue
- You previously let him go - your prior evaluation was correct
Suggested Action
Pass on Goldschmidt; use the roster spot on a younger 1B prospect with upside rather than a declining veteran.
Harrison Bader
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall with Abreu, Langford, and Caissie. Bader would be redundant and not an upgrade over your existing options.
- Career-best 2025 season: 339 FPTS, 17 HR, .796 OPS in 146 games
- Solid power/speed combo: 17 HR and 11 SB in 2025
- Improved plate discipline with 39 walks and .347 OBP in 2025
- Everyday playing time secured with Phillies
- Age 31 entering 2026 - declining phase likely imminent
- High strikeout rate (136 K in 448 AB) limits batting average upside
- 2025 appears to be an outlier season; prior 3 years averaged ~250 FPTS
- Caught stealing 7 times in 2025 suggests declining speed efficiency
- No long-term keeper value at this age
Suggested Action
Pass on Bader - your CF depth is adequate with younger, cheaper options, and his 2025 breakout at age 30 is unlikely to sustain through 2026 and beyond.
Phil Maton
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper with similar production (338.9 FPTS). Maton would provide depth but creates redundancy rather than filling a gap at a position of need.
- Strong 2025 campaign: 338.7 FPTS, 2.79 ERA, 1.06 WHIP in 61.1 IP
- Elite K rate: 81 strikeouts in 61.1 innings (11.9 K/9)
- Versatile high-leverage role: 5 saves + 22 holds shows closer-adjacent usage
- Consistent 3-year production: 270-340 FPTS range annually
- Age 32 - limited upside trajectory, likely at or near peak value
- Not a true closer - 5 saves suggests committee or setup role limits ceiling
- Walk rate concerning: 23 BB in 61.1 IP (3.4 BB/9) creates volatility
- RP volatility - role could diminish with Cubs bullpen changes
Suggested Action
Monitor Maton's spring role clarity but prioritize younger upside plays or position-of-need targets over a 32-year-old setup man.
Jeff McNeil
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists.
- Contact-oriented hitter with low strikeout rates (55 K in 399 AB in 2025)
- Modest power uptick in 2025 (12 HR) but still below-average for fantasy
- Walk rate improved in 2025 (49 BB) supporting OBP value
- 2022 batting title season (.326 AVG) appears to be an outlier, not the norm
- Age 33 entering 2026 with clear decline from peak years (2019, 2022)
- FPTS trending down: 444.1 (2023) → 298.6 (2024) → 337.8 (2025)
- Limited speed (3 SB in 2025) and declining counting stats
- OPS has dropped from .916 (2019) to .746 (2025) - significant regression
- Playing time not guaranteed as Mets may prioritize younger options
Suggested Action
Pass on McNeil entirely - your 2B depth is elite and his declining production at age 33 offers no upside worth a roster spot.
Adrian Houser
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Houser would be redundant depth at best and doesn't upgrade any rotation spot.
- Bounced back in 2025 with 336.3 FPTS after injury-plagued 2024 (18.1 FPTS)
- 11 quality starts in 21 starts shows decent reliability when healthy
- 3.31 ERA and 1.28 WHIP are serviceable but not elite
- 92 K in 125 IP (6.6 K/9) is below-average strikeout rate for fantasy
- Age 32 with significant injury history (2024 was essentially lost)
- Low strikeout upside limits fantasy ceiling
- Tampa Bay rotation is crowded - role uncertainty in 2026
- Career journeyman profile - Brewers let him walk for a reason
Suggested Action
Pass on Houser - your rotation is stacked and his low-K, injury-prone profile doesn't warrant a roster spot over your existing SP depth.
Nate Lowe
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 player at 1B (likely Jac Caglianone who is listed as RF but may have 1B eligibility), so there is a positional need. However, Lowe's declining production makes him a poor fit to fill that gap.
- Consistent playing time: 140-161 games each full season
- Solid walk rate provides OBP floor (62-93 BB per season)
- Career peak was 2022 with .302 AVG and 27 HR
- 2025 FPTS (335.9) represents significant decline from 2023 (459.7)
- Clear downward trajectory: FPTS dropped from 459.7 (2023) to 361.4 (2024) to 335.9 (2025)
- 2025 slash line (.228/.307/.381) is well below league average
- Age 30 with declining power (18 HR in 2025 vs 27 in 2022)
- Strikeout rate remains high (159 K in 2025) without corresponding power
- OPS collapsed from .850 (2022) to .689 (2025) - a 160-point drop
Suggested Action
Pass on Lowe and target a younger 1B option with upside, as his declining production at age 30 offers minimal fantasy value even with your positional need.
Luke Weaver
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 total RP slots filled. Weaver would add depth but creates some redundancy in a position that's not a glaring need.
- 452.6 FPTS in 2024 was elite RP production, but 2025 dropped to 335.1 FPTS - significant regression
- Strong ratios: 3.62 ERA, 1.02 WHIP in 64.2 IP shows quality innings
- 72 K in 64.2 IP (10.0 K/9) provides strikeout upside
- 8 saves + 21 holds indicates high-leverage role but not primary closer
- Age 32 - declining phase for relievers, 2025 already showed regression from 2024 peak
- Not the primary closer in NYY - saves upside capped unless role changes
- Relievers are inherently volatile year-to-year; 2023 was only 19.4 FPTS
- Yankees bullpen is crowded; role could diminish further in 2026
Suggested Action
Monitor Weaver's spring training role and Yankees closer situation before committing a roster spot - he's a solid RP2/RP3 but not a must-add given your existing RP depth.
Nick Martinez
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Greene, Leiter, and Misiorowski. Martinez would be redundant depth at best, offering no improvement over your current options.
- Consistent innings eater: 165.2 IP in 2025 with 26 starts
- Moderate strikeout rate (116 K in 165.2 IP = 6.3 K/9)
- Versatility with 5 holds showing swing role capability
- 11 quality starts provides some floor
- Age 35 heading into 2026 - declining phase of career
- 4.45 ERA and 1.21 WHIP are below-average ratios
- Fantasy points declining: 470.5 (2024) → 334.5 (2025) is a 29% drop
- Low strikeout upside limits fantasy ceiling
- No draft pedigree data suggests journeyman profile
Suggested Action
Pass on Martinez entirely - your rotation is stacked with younger, higher-upside arms, and a 35-year-old back-end starter with declining production offers no value to your roster.
Jake Cronenworth
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists for another second baseman.
- Solid OBP (.367 in 2025) driven by strong walk rate (69 BB in 419 AB)
- Consistent playing time when healthy (127-158 games in full seasons)
- Modest power (10-21 HR range) with doubles production
- Low strikeout rate relative to league average
- Age 31 with declining power trajectory (21 HR in 2021 down to 11 HR in 2025)
- Fantasy points dropped significantly from 410.8 (2024) to 333.9 (2025)
- Minimal stolen base contribution (3 SB in 2025)
- Batting average has settled around .240-.245, limiting ceiling
- At-bats dropped from 577 to 419, suggesting reduced role or health concerns
Suggested Action
Pass on Cronenworth as you have three superior 2B options already rostered, and his declining production at age 31 offers no upside worth the roster spot.
Cedric Mullins
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, making Mullins redundant. At 31 with declining production, he doesn't upgrade your outfield depth.
- Consistent 15-20 HR power with 20-30 SB upside provides category balance
- 333 FPTS in 2025 represents solid everyday player value
- Durable - played 133+ games in 3 of last 4 full seasons
- Now with Tampa Bay, may benefit from change of scenery
- Clear decline from 2021 peak (.878 OPS) to 2025 (.690 OPS) - trending wrong direction at age 31
- Batting average has cratered (.216 in 2025) with elevated strikeout rate
- OBP under .300 limits run production upside
- Speed may continue declining with age - SB dropped from 32 to 22 year-over-year
Suggested Action
Pass on Mullins - your CF depth is adequate with Simpson's upside and Cowser's youth, and Mullins' declining profile at 31 doesn't warrant a roster spot over younger options.
Marcus Semien
Roster Fit
You already have 3 second basemen (Stott, Holliday, Albies) who are younger and produced comparable or better fantasy points in 2025. Semien would be redundant depth at a position of strength.
- 2025 FPTS (333.2) represents a 34% decline from 2024 (510.3) and 57% decline from 2023 (771.7)
- Power cratered: 15 HR in 2025 vs 23 in 2024 and 29 in 2023
- OPS collapsed to .669 in 2025, down from .826 in 2023
- Still plays every day (127 games in partial 2025 data) but production no longer justifies roster spot
- Age 35 entering 2026 with clear decline trajectory across all offensive categories
- Batting average (.230), OBP (.305), and SLG (.364) all at career-low levels in 2025
- Stolen bases declining (11 in 2025 vs 25 in 2022 peak)
- No indication the decline will reverse - this looks like typical age-related regression
Suggested Action
Pass on Semien entirely; your existing 2B options (Stott 423.7 FPTS, Albies 425.4 FPTS, Holliday 333.7 FPTS with upside) all outperform or match his declining production at lower cost and younger ages.
Austin Hays
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford and Colton Cowser covering LF/CF, plus 6 RF-eligible players. Hays would be redundant depth at a position you're already stacked at.
- Bounced back in 2025 with 332 FPTS after injury-plagued 2024 (119 FPTS)
- Solid 15 HR, 7 SB in 103 games shows decent power-speed combo
- .768 OPS in 2025 represents his typical ceiling (.769 in 2021, .769 in 2023)
- Career-high 5 triples in 2025 suggests he's still athletic at 30
- Turning 30 with extensive injury history - missed significant time in 2024
- Low walk rate (7.6% in 2025) limits OBP upside, career .311 OBP
- Never played more than 145 games in a season, durability concerns persist
- Fourth outfielder profile on most MLB rosters, playing time not guaranteed
- 2025 was with CIN - may not have everyday role locked down for 2026
Suggested Action
Pass on Hays - your outfield is already deep with younger, higher-upside options like Langford and Cowser, and Hays' injury history and age make him a poor dynasty investment.
Louie Varland
Roster Fit
You have 6 RPs currently rostered with Matt Strahm as your top reliever (338.9 FPTS). Varland's 329.5 FPTS in 2025 suggests he could provide comparable value, but your RP depth appears adequate.
- Strong 2025 bounce-back with 329.5 FPTS after disastrous -45.4 FPTS in 2024
- Now with Toronto organization, potentially in a higher-leverage role
- Age 28 suggests he's in his prime years for a reliever
- Extreme volatility: swung from 166.6 (2023) to -45.4 (2024) to 329.5 (2025) - highly inconsistent
- No detailed stat history available to understand underlying performance drivers
- At 28, limited upside growth - this may be his ceiling
- Reliever value is inherently volatile and role-dependent
Suggested Action
Monitor Varland's spring training role with Toronto before committing a roster spot; only add if he secures a high-leverage or closing opportunity.
Jack Dreyer
Roster Fit
You have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS), so RP depth exists but isn't overwhelming. Dreyer would provide solid middle-relief value but doesn't fill a critical gap.
- 328.3 FPTS in 2025 is strong for a reliever - comparable to your Strahm
- 2.95 ERA and 1.048 WHIP across 76.1 IP shows quality innings
- 67 appearances with 10 holds indicates high-leverage usage
- Only 4 saves limits ceiling in standard formats
- 74 K in 76.1 IP (8.7 K/9) is solid but not elite
- Age 26 with no stats prior to 2025 - unclear track record or late bloomer
- Not a closer - 4 saves with 10 holds suggests setup role
- LAD bullpen is deep - role could fluctuate or diminish
- 5 spot starts suggest swing-man usage which can be volatile
- 24 walks in 76.1 IP (2.8 BB/9) is acceptable but not dominant
Suggested Action
Add to watchlist and monitor if LAD's closer situation changes or if he earns a more defined high-leverage role heading into 2026.
Caleb Thielbar
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 RP slots filled. Thielbar would add depth but creates redundancy rather than filling a gap.
- Elite 2025 ratios: 2.64 ERA, 0.88 WHIP across 58 IP
- Strong 326.8 FPTS in 2025 - best season in sample
- 25 holds indicate consistent high-leverage usage
- K/BB ratio solid at 56/13 (4.3 K/BB)
- Age 38 - significant decline risk for 2026 and beyond
- Zero saves limits upside in most fantasy formats
- 2024 was a down year (132.6 FPTS) - 2025 may be an outlier
- Middle relief role caps fantasy ceiling regardless of performance
- No draft pedigree or prospect status - purely a veteran depth piece
Suggested Action
Monitor Thielbar's spring training role and early 2026 usage, but don't prioritize over younger RP options given his age and your existing RP depth.
Clayton Kershaw
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already elite with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Leiter, and Imanaga. Kershaw would be redundant depth at best and carries significant injury/age risk.
- 2025 showed bounce-back with 326.2 FPTS across 22 starts (11-2, 3.36 ERA)
- Quality start rate remains low (6 QS in 22 starts = 27%)
- Strikeout rate has declined significantly (84 K in 112.2 IP = 6.7 K/9)
- 2024 was essentially a lost season (41.2 FPTS total - injury)
- Age 36+ with extensive injury history including shoulder surgery
- 2024 near-total absence (only 41.2 FPTS) signals durability concerns
- WHIP of 1.22 and declining K rate suggest diminishing stuff
- No draft data/age showing as 0 indicates data quality issues
- Dodgers may limit workload or move to bullpen role
Suggested Action
Pass on Kershaw - your rotation is already stacked with younger, higher-upside arms, and his injury risk makes him a poor dynasty asset at this stage of his career.
Will Warren
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already substantial with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Warren would be redundant depth rather than filling a need.
- 324.4 FPTS in 2025 represents solid mid-rotation value across 33 starts
- 171 K in 162.1 IP shows decent strikeout upside (9.5 K/9)
- Durable workload with 33 GS demonstrates ability to hold rotation spot
- 4.44 ERA and 1.37 WHIP are below-average ratios that hurt in most formats
- 65 BB in 162.1 IP (3.6 BB/9) indicates command issues that cap upside
- Only 6 quality starts in 33 attempts is a major red flag for consistency
- Negative FPTS in 2024 (-55.7) suggests volatility and recent struggles
- Age 26 with mediocre ratios limits long-term upside compared to younger arms
Suggested Action
Pass on adding Warren given your deep SP corps; monitor only if multiple starters get injured or if he shows improved command in spring.
Justin Verlander
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already excellent with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Greene, Leiter, and Misiorowski. Adding a 42-year-old declining veteran creates redundancy without meaningful upside.
- 2025 FPTS (322.4) represents significant decline from 2023 peak (514.3)
- 4-11 record with 3.85 ERA shows diminished effectiveness
- 137 K in 152 IP (8.1 K/9) is serviceable but not elite
- 12 quality starts in 29 games shows inconsistency
- Age 42 entering 2026 - extreme injury and decline risk
- 2024 season (109 FPTS) suggests injury/limited availability concerns
- 1.36 WHIP trending wrong direction for a contact-management pitcher
- No long-term value in dynasty format - could retire any offseason
- Giants rebuilding may limit win opportunities
Suggested Action
Pass on Verlander entirely - your young SP core (Greene, Leiter, Misiorowski, Patrick) offers far more dynasty value than a 42-year-old on the decline.
Adolis Garcia
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu, Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Garcia would create significant redundancy at an already crowded position.
- Consistent everyday playing time (135-156 games annually)
- Power/speed combo: 19-39 HR and 9-25 SB range over career
- 2023 breakout (633 FPTS, 39 HR, .836 OPS) now looks like outlier peak
- Age 32 entering 2026 - declining phase evident in stats
- FPTS dropped from 633 (2023) to 348 (2024) to 320 (2025) - 50% decline in two years
- OPS collapsed from .836 to .684 to .665 - power and plate discipline both regressing
- High strikeout rate (26-33% K%) with declining walk rate
- Home runs dropped from 39 to 25 to 19 over three seasons
Suggested Action
Pass on Garcia - he's a declining 32-year-old who doesn't fit your roster needs and his best days are clearly behind him.
Steven Okert
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as a quality RP and 6 total relievers on roster. Okert would add depth but doesn't fill a critical need given your existing bullpen coverage.
- Strong 2025 season: 319.3 FPTS across 68 appearances with 84 K in 71.2 IP
- Excellent 0.893 WHIP and 3.01 ERA indicate solid ratios
- 10 holds show high-leverage usage but only 1 save limits ceiling
- Age 34 entering 2026 - declining phase likely imminent
- Non-closer role caps fantasy upside significantly
- Volatile year-to-year production (74.9 FPTS in 2024 vs 319.3 in 2025)
- Middle reliever role could evaporate with any performance dip
Suggested Action
Pass on Okert - his age and non-closer role make him a marginal add when you already have adequate RP depth; prioritize younger upside plays in Rule 5.
Josh H. Smith
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS rostered including Bo Bichette (570.8 FPTS), Dansby Swanson (421.2 FPTS), and Ezequiel Tovar. Josh H. Smith would be redundant depth at a position you're already stacked at.
- Consistent but unspectacular production: 369 FPTS (2024), 316.6 FPTS (2025)
- Age 28 - no upside trajectory, this is likely his ceiling
- Part-time player in Texas, not an everyday starter
- No detailed stat history available to assess underlying skills
- Playing time uncertainty - Rangers have other SS options
- At 28, unlikely to develop into more than a utility piece
- FPTS declined from 2024 to 2025, trending wrong direction
Suggested Action
Pass on Josh H. Smith - your SS depth is already elite with Bichette, Swanson, Holliday, and Tovar; adding a 28-year-old utility player with declining production provides no value.
Kodai Senga
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Senga would add depth but creates redundancy rather than filling a gap.
- Strong 2023 debut (591.8 FPTS) showed elite ceiling when healthy
- 2025 bounce-back: 3.02 ERA, 109 K in 113.1 IP across 22 starts
- K rate remains solid but walks elevated (55 BB in 113 IP = 4.4 BB/9)
- Quality start rate (6 QS in 22 GS) is underwhelming for a mid-rotation arm
- Age 32 entering 2026 - declining phase for pitchers
- 2024 was essentially lost (26.6 FPTS) due to injury - durability is a major concern
- 1.31 WHIP and walk rate suggest command issues that could worsen with age
- Only 113 IP in 2025 indicates workload management or lingering health concerns
Suggested Action
Monitor Senga's health through spring training before committing a roster spot; your SP depth is already strong enough to pass unless he falls to you late in Rule 5.
Alec Bohm
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B ($26, 248.8 FPTS in 2025), so Bohm would create redundancy at the position. However, Riley's down year and Bohm's consistent production make this worth monitoring if Riley struggles or you need trade flexibility.
- Consistent 490+ FPTS producer in 2023-2024, projecting as a reliable everyday 3B
- Strong contact hitter with .274-.287 BA over last 4 full seasons
- Doubles machine (44 2B in 2024, 31 in 2023) driving solid counting stats
- Locked into everyday role with Phillies contending roster
- 2025 FPTS (312.1 through 120 games) projects to ~380 full season - notable decline from prior years
- Power regression: only 11 HR in 2025 vs 15-20 in prior seasons
- Limited SB contribution (2-5 per year) in increasingly speed-valued formats
- Age 29 entering 2026 - likely at or past peak value
- OPS dropped from .779 (2024) to .741 (2025) - concerning trend
Suggested Action
Monitor Bohm's second half and offseason moves; only pursue if Riley is traded or you can flip one 3B for pitching depth.
Trevor Larnach
Roster Fit
Listed as DH-only, which provides minimal positional flexibility. Your roster lacks 1B depth (only 1 player), but Larnach doesn't address that need directly and would compete for utility/DH slots against more valuable assets.
- Consistent 300+ FPTS producer in 2024-2025 when healthy (303.5 and 311.4)
- 142 games in 2025 shows improved durability after injury-plagued early career
- Modest power (17 HR in 2025) with acceptable OBP (.323)
- Age 28 entering prime years with established MLB role
- DH-only designation severely limits roster flexibility in fantasy formats
- Mediocre batting average (.250) and declining OPS trend (.771 to .727)
- Zero speed contribution (4 SB, 4 CS in 2025)
- High strikeout rate (24% K%) limits ceiling
- Not a difference-maker - replacement-level production available on waivers
Suggested Action
Pass on Larnach; his DH-only eligibility and middling production (~310 FPTS) doesn't warrant a roster spot when you have multiple OF options and could target higher-upside players or address your 1B/3B depth instead.
Kyle Finnegan
Roster Fit
You have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS), so closer depth isn't a critical need. Finnegan would add saves upside but creates some redundancy in a position you're already covering.
- 24 saves in 2025 demonstrates established closer role
- Consistent fantasy production: 308-363 FPTS over last 3 seasons
- Solid ratios: 3.47 ERA, 1.11 WHIP in 2025
- 57 IP shows durability for a reliever
- Age 34 entering 2026 - declining phase likely
- Moved from WSH to DET - closer role not guaranteed with new team
- K rate declining (55 K in 57 IP = 8.7 K/9, below elite closer threshold)
- Fantasy points trending downward: 363 → 360 → 308 over 3 years
- Relievers are volatile assets with limited innings ceiling
Suggested Action
Monitor Detroit's bullpen situation in spring training; only add if he's confirmed as closer and your RP depth thins out.
Brandon Marsh
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth with Langford, Abreu, and Caglianone. Marsh would be redundant and doesn't upgrade your current options.
- Consistent 300+ FPTS producer over last 3 seasons (305-344 range)
- Improved batting average in 2025 (.280) with solid OBP (.342)
- Modest power/speed combo: 11 HR, 7 SB in 2025
- Everyday starter role locked in with Phillies
- High strikeout rate (110+ K annually) limits ceiling
- FPTS trending slightly down from 2023 peak (344 → 306)
- Age 27 with no breakout trajectory - this is likely his ceiling
- Part-time at-bats (379 AB in 133 games) suggests platoon concerns
Suggested Action
Pass on Marsh - he's a replacement-level OF4/5 who doesn't improve your roster and would block higher-upside options like Caissie or Kayfus from developing.
Lars Nootbaar
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford and depth at OF positions. Nootbaar would be redundant and offers no upgrade over your current LF option.
- Strong walk rate (10-12% BB) provides OBP floor
- 2025 showed 135 games played, demonstrating durability
- Modest power (12-14 HR range) with declining slugging
- 2025 was a career-worst season: .234 AVG, .361 SLG, .686 OPS
- Age 28 with declining trajectory - 2023 appears to be his peak
- Fantasy points dropped from 391 (2023) to 305 (2025) despite more games
- Limited stolen base upside (4 SB, 5 CS in 2025)
- No clear path to increased playing time or role expansion
Suggested Action
Pass on Nootbaar - he's a declining 28-year-old with a poor 2025 season who doesn't upgrade your LF situation over Langford.
Lucas Erceg
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 RP slots filled. Erceg would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap. His role as a middle reliever with limited saves caps his upside.
- Solid 2.64 ERA and 1.17 WHIP in 61.1 IP shows reliability
- 22 holds indicate high-leverage usage but not closer role
- 332 FPTS in 2024 and 300.9 in 2025 shows consistent production
- Only 2 saves limits fantasy ceiling in standard formats
- Age 30 with no clear path to closer role limits upside
- K rate (48 K in 61.1 IP = 7.0 K/9) is below elite reliever threshold
- Middle relief role is volatile and dependent on team context
- Already at peak value - unlikely to improve significantly
Suggested Action
Monitor for potential closer opportunity via trade or injury, but don't prioritize adding given your existing RP depth and his limited saves upside.
Jordan Beck
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford at LF with strong production (408.7 FPTS) and only 2 LF slots filled, so Beck could provide depth but isn't a pressing need. He's a redundant piece rather than filling a gap.
- Full 148-game season in 2025 shows durability and everyday role secured
- 16 HR/19 SB combo provides useful power-speed mix
- 300.9 FPTS in 2025 is solid but unspectacular - roughly replacement-level starter
- Coors Field home games provide batting average and counting stat floor
- High strikeout rate (174 K in 539 AB = 32.3% K rate) limits ceiling
- Mediocre .258/.317/.416 slash line even with Coors boost is concerning
- 2024 debut was rough (.188/.245/.276) - 2025 may be closer to his ceiling than a breakout
- OBP under .320 hurts in most fantasy formats
- Age 24 with limited upside trajectory - what you see is likely what you get
Suggested Action
Monitor Beck's spring training role and early 2026 performance before committing a roster spot; he's a streaming option rather than a must-roster asset given your existing LF depth.
Slade Cecconi
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Cecconi would be backend rotation depth at best, creating redundancy rather than filling a need.
- 2025 breakout: 300 FPTS across 23 starts and 132 IP shows durability
- 11 quality starts in 23 games (48% QS rate) indicates mid-rotation reliability
- 109 K in 132 IP (7.4 K/9) is serviceable but not elite
- 4.30 ERA and 1.19 WHIP are league-average marks
- Age 26 with limited track record - 2023-2024 combined for only 57.5 FPTS
- Cleveland rotation is crowded with Bibee, Williams, and others competing for innings
- Strikeout rate is below-average for fantasy SP value
- 2025 could be a career year rather than a new baseline
Suggested Action
Monitor Cecconi's spring training role and early 2026 usage before committing a roster spot, as your SP depth doesn't require adding a back-end arm.
Aaron Ashby
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and only 6 RP slots total. Ashby would provide quality depth but isn't filling a critical gap given your SP-heavy roster construction.
- Strong 2025 bounceback: 2.16 ERA, 1.17 WHIP across 66.2 IP
- Excellent K rate: 76 K in 66.2 IP (10.3 K/9)
- 295.8 FPTS in 2025 shows legitimate fantasy value in relief role
- Versatility: 43 games with 1 start, 3 saves, 6 holds indicates multi-inning/high-leverage usage
- No 2023 data available - likely missed significant time (TJ surgery history)
- Walk rate concerning: 24 BB in 66.2 IP (3.2 BB/9) limits upside
- Age 27 with injury history caps long-term ceiling
- Unclear path to saves - Milwaukee has established closer options
- Role volatility: Could lose high-leverage work if struggles emerge
Suggested Action
Monitor Ashby's spring role clarity before committing a roster spot; if he secures closer job or multi-inning fireman role, prioritize adding him.
Matthew Liberatore
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Liberatore would be redundant depth at best and doesn't crack your top 5-6 starters.
- 294.3 FPTS in 2025 shows solid volume with 29 starts and 151.2 IP
- 11 quality starts indicates some reliability as a back-end starter
- 122 strikeouts is modest but acceptable for a contact-oriented lefty
- Clear upward trajectory: 58.9 → 197.4 → 294.3 FPTS over three seasons
- 4.21 ERA and 1.31 WHIP are below-average ratios that limit upside
- 158 hits allowed in 151.2 IP suggests hittable stuff
- 8-12 record reflects a pitcher who doesn't dominate
- Age 26 with mediocre ratios suggests this is close to his ceiling
- Cardinals rotation is crowded, role could fluctuate
Suggested Action
Pass on Liberatore—your SP corps is stacked and his SP5/6 profile doesn't move the needle for a roster already carrying Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, Leiter, and Patrick.
Carson Kelly
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher and Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. Carson Kelly would be redundant depth at a position you're already covered at.
- 2025 bounce-back: 294 FPTS, 17 HR, .761 OPS in 111 games - career-best power output at age 30
- Improved walk rate (10.9%) shows plate discipline remains solid
- 111 games played suggests durability, rare for a catcher his age
- Age 31 catcher entering decline phase - 2025 may be peak, not baseline
- Career .233 hitter with inconsistent production year-to-year (31.6 FPTS in 2023)
- Cubs have catching depth; playing time not guaranteed in 2026
- No speed contribution (2 SB in 2025, career 5 SB total)
- 2025 power spike (17 HR) is outlier vs career norms (7-13 HR range)
Suggested Action
Pass on Kelly - your catcher situation is set with Diaz and Jensen; use roster spot on higher-upside position of need like 1B where you only have 1 player.
Jesus Sanchez
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at RF where you already have 6 players including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. No positional need exists.
- Consistent MLB playing time (134-149 games in 2024-2025)
- Modest power/speed combo: 14 HR/13 SB in 2025, 18 HR/16 SB in 2024
- 290-330 FPTS range is replacement-level for a starting OF in deep leagues
- Now with Houston, may benefit from better lineup protection
- Declining production: FPTS dropped from 330.6 (2024) to 290.8 (2025)
- Batting average trending down (.252 to .237) with poor OBP (.304 in 2025)
- High strikeout rate (110+ K's annually) limits floor
- Age 28 - no upside remaining, this is his established ceiling
- Houston OF is crowded with Alvarez, Tucker, Meyers limiting everyday role
Suggested Action
Pass on Sanchez - he's a declining 28-year-old corner outfielder producing below your current RF options, and you have no positional need.
Dylan Lee
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Lee would add depth but doesn't fill a critical need, and his role as a middle reliever limits upside compared to closers or high-leverage arms.
- Consistent workload: 74 games, 68.1 IP in 2025 shows durability and trust from Atlanta
- Strong ratios: 3.29 ERA, 0.98 WHIP are elite for a reliever
- Solid K rate: 76 K in 68.1 IP (10.0 K/9) provides counting stat value
- 19 holds indicate high-leverage usage but limited save opportunities
- Age 31 with no saves role - unlikely to gain closer job with Atlanta's bullpen depth
- Only 2 saves despite 74 appearances caps fantasy ceiling
- 289 FPTS is solid but not elite - comparable to your existing RP Strahm
- Middle reliever volatility - role could diminish with any performance dip
Suggested Action
Monitor Lee's spring training role but don't prioritize adding him unless he emerges as Atlanta's closer or your RP depth takes a hit.
Yariel Rodriguez
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and your RP depth shows 6 players. Rodriguez would add middle-relief depth but doesn't fill a critical gap given your existing bullpen coverage.
- 289.2 FPTS in 2025 represents solid RP production across 66 appearances
- 3.08 ERA and 1.15 WHIP indicate quality middle-relief performance
- 14 holds show high-leverage usage, though only 2 saves limits upside
- 66 K in 73 IP (8.1 K/9) is acceptable but not elite strikeout rate
- Significant jump from 128.1 FPTS (2024) to 289.2 FPTS (2025) shows role expansion
- 28 years old with no clear path to closer role in Toronto
- 34 walks in 73 IP (4.2 BB/9) indicates command concerns
- Only 1 start suggests he's locked into relief role with limited innings upside
- RP value is volatile year-to-year; 2025 breakout may not sustain
- No 2023 data available makes it harder to establish baseline
Suggested Action
Monitor Rodriguez's spring training role and Toronto's closer situation, but don't prioritize over higher-upside targets given your existing RP depth.
Randy Rodriguez
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a clear contributor (338.9 FPTS). Rodriguez's 288.8 FPTS in 2025 would immediately become your best reliever and fill a clear roster need.
- Elite ratios: 1.78 ERA and 0.89 WHIP in 50.2 IP demonstrate high-leverage reliability
- Strong K rate: 67 strikeouts in 50.2 IP (11.9 K/9) drives fantasy value
- Established MLB role: 50 games, 13 holds, 4 saves shows manager trust
- 288.8 FPTS in 2025 represents top-tier RP production
- Age 26 with no 2023 data - limited track record before 2024
- Only 4 saves - not a closer, value tied to holds and ratios
- Small sample size concern: 2024 was only 132.7 FPTS, need to confirm 2025 breakout is real
- Giants bullpen hierarchy could shift with acquisitions
Suggested Action
Add Rodriguez now - he's a proven high-leverage reliever with elite ratios who directly addresses your weakest roster position.
Seranthony Dominguez
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and your RP depth shows 6 players. Dominguez would add depth but isn't filling a critical gap. He's a solid middle reliever but not a closer.
- 285.1 FPTS in 2025 is solid for a non-closer reliever - shows consistent usage
- 67 games pitched indicates durability and manager trust
- 79 K in 62.2 IP (11.3 K/9) demonstrates swing-and-miss stuff
- 20 holds shows high-leverage role even without closer duties
- Steady FPTS improvement: 164.1 (2023) → 218.9 (2024) → 285.1 (2025)
- Age 31 - declining phase for relievers, limited upside trajectory
- Only 2 saves despite 67 appearances - not in line for closer role
- 36 walks in 62.2 IP (5.2 BB/9) is concerning command issue
- 3.16 ERA is decent but 1.28 WHIP suggests some regression risk
- Setup men are volatile - role could diminish with bullpen changes
Suggested Action
Monitor Toronto's closer situation in spring training - only add if he's positioned for saves or your RP depth takes a hit.
Nolan Arenado
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B ($26) who is younger and higher upside despite his down 2025. Arenado would be redundant depth at a position you don't need to address.
- Clear decline trajectory: FPTS dropped from 487.8 (2023) → 397.7 (2024) → 282.7 (2025)
- 2025 slash line of .237/.289/.377 with only 12 HR in 107 games is alarming
- OPS collapsed from .774 (2023) to .666 (2025) - a 108-point drop in two years
- Power has evaporated: 26 HR in 2023, 16 in 2024, on pace for ~18 in 2025
- Age 34 with accelerating decline - this is not a temporary slump
- Lost 100+ fantasy points year-over-year, trend shows no signs of reversing
- Uncertain playing time in 2026 - Cardinals may move on or reduce role
- No stolen base contribution (3 SB in 2025) to offset declining power/average
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Arenado is a declining veteran who doesn't fit your roster needs and offers minimal 2026 upside compared to younger options.
Jose Quintana
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already excellent with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Castillo, Greene, Leiter, and Misiorowski. Quintana would be redundant depth at best and blocks younger development options.
- Declining FPTS trajectory: 394.4 (2024) → 281.8 (2025) represents a 29% drop
- Mediocre ratios: 3.96 ERA and 1.29 WHIP are replacement-level for fantasy
- Low strikeout rate: 89 K in 131.2 IP (6.1 K/9) provides minimal fantasy upside
- Innings eater profile: 24 starts and 131.2 IP shows durability but not impact
- Age 36 entering 2026 season - significant decline risk
- K rate trending wrong direction for fantasy relevance
- No MLB ID listed suggests potential data/tracking issues
- Soft-tossing lefty profile ages poorly
- Contract status unclear - may not have guaranteed rotation spot
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - your rotation is stacked with younger, higher-upside arms, and Quintana's declining production at age 36 offers no value over your current options.
Steven Matz
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper (338.9 FPTS) plus 5 other relievers. Matz would add depth but creates redundancy at a position you're already adequately staffed.
- Strong 2025 bounce-back: 280.4 FPTS across 76.2 IP with 3.05 ERA and 1.10 WHIP
- Versatile usage: 53 games, 2 starts, 13 holds, 2 saves shows multi-inning flexibility
- Elite walk rate: Only 11 BB in 76.2 IP demonstrates excellent control
- Age 34 entering 2026 - declining velocity and durability concerns for relievers
- 2024 was a disaster (37.2 FPTS) - 2025 could be an outlier rather than a new baseline
- No clear path to saves/high-leverage role - holds-based value has a lower ceiling
- K rate underwhelming (59 K in 76.2 IP = 6.9 K/9) limits upside
Suggested Action
Pass on Matz - your RP depth is sufficient, and his age/volatility profile doesn't warrant a roster spot over younger options or position needs.
Wilmer Flores
Roster Fit
Your roster has only 1 1B listed, but Flores is a 34-year-old DH-only player in clear decline. He doesn't address your 1B need with meaningful upside and would block younger assets.
- 2025 FPTS (276.2) represents a significant drop from 2023 (407.8), indicating accelerating decline
- Power cratered: 16 HR in 2025 vs 23 HR in 2023 despite similar games played
- OPS collapsed from .863 (2023) to .686 (2025) - now well below league average
- Contact quality declining: .241 AVG in 2025, .379 SLG is career-worst for a full season
- Age 34 with clear multi-year decline trajectory - no rebound expected
- DH-only designation limits roster flexibility and playing time certainty
- 2024 injury-shortened season (.595 OPS in 71 games) suggests durability concerns
- Giants may move on from him entirely, leaving him without a clear role in 2026
- Zero speed contribution (1 SB in 2025) in an era where steals matter more
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Flores is a declining veteran with no dynasty value; use the roster spot on a younger player with upside.
Griffin Jax
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RP on roster including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Jax would add depth but not fill a critical need, and his declining production makes him a marginal upgrade at best.
- High-volume reliever: 73 games, 66 IP in 2025 shows durability and consistent usage
- Strong strikeout rate: 99 K in 66 IP (13.5 K/9) provides fantasy value
- 28 holds indicate high-leverage role, though zero saves limits upside
- 2024 was career year (467.2 FPTS) but 2025 dropped significantly to 275.4 FPTS
- Age 31 with declining production trajectory (467 FPTS → 275 FPTS year-over-year)
- 4.23 ERA and 1.29 WHIP in 2025 are mediocre ratios for a setup man
- 1-7 W/L record suggests poor run support or blown leads
- No saves path - Tampa Bay has established closers ahead of him
- Moved from Minnesota to Tampa Bay - role uncertainty in new organization
Suggested Action
Pass on Jax - his declining production, age, and lack of saves upside make him a low-priority target when you already have adequate RP depth.
Luis Severino
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already elite with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Severino would be redundant depth at best and doesn't upgrade any rotation spot.
- 274.9 FPTS in 2025 is a significant decline from 460.9 in 2024
- 4.54 ERA and 1.30 WHIP indicate back-end starter production
- 124 K in 162.2 IP (6.9 K/9) shows diminished strikeout upside
- Only 10 quality starts in 29 starts - inconsistent performance
- Age 31 with declining velocity and performance trajectory
- Extensive injury history throughout career limits durability confidence
- Moving to Oakland (ATH) suggests limited run support and win opportunities
- 2023 season shows only 1.4 FPTS - likely injury-shortened, pattern of unavailability
Suggested Action
Pass on Severino entirely - your rotation is stacked with younger, higher-upside arms and he offers no improvement over your current SP14.
Calvin Faucher
Roster Fit
You have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS), so reliever depth exists. Faucher would add saves potential but isn't a clear upgrade over your current setup.
- 15 saves in 2025 indicates closer opportunity in Miami
- 65 games pitched shows durability and manager trust
- 274.6 FPTS in 2025 is solid RP production, outpacing your Strahm
- 3.28 ERA and 1.28 WHIP are serviceable but not elite
- Age 30 with limited upside trajectory - this is likely his ceiling
- Miami's bullpen hierarchy is volatile; closer role not guaranteed for 2026
- K/9 under 9.0 (59 K in 60.1 IP) limits strikeout upside
- 1.28 WHIP suggests baserunner issues that could inflate ERA
Suggested Action
Monitor Miami's offseason moves; only add if he's confirmed as closer and your league values saves heavily.
Greg Weissert
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 total RP on roster. Weissert would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap - he's a solid middle reliever without a clear path to saves.
- 271.7 FPTS in 2025 is strong for a non-closer reliever (72 games, 67 IP)
- 2.82 ERA and 1.16 WHIP show quality performance in high-leverage situations
- 17 holds indicate trusted setup role, but only 4 saves limits upside
- Significant improvement from 199.8 FPTS in 2024 to 271.7 in 2025
- Age 30 - limited long-term dynasty value, already in decline phase for relievers
- Not the closer in Boston - saves upside capped unless role changes
- Relievers are volatile year-to-year; 2025 could be peak performance
- K/9 of 7.66 is below elite reliever threshold (57 K in 67 IP)
Suggested Action
Monitor Boston's closer situation heading into 2026 - only add if he secures the 9th inning role or your RP depth becomes depleted through trades/injuries.
Andrew Vaughn
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 player at 1B (likely Austin Riley sliding there), creating a clear positional need. Vaughn would provide 1B depth, but his declining production limits his upside.
- Consistent 15-21 HR power over 5 MLB seasons
- Career .250-.270 batting average with modest OBP (.297-.321)
- Durable: 127-152 games played in each full season
- Now with Milwaukee, potentially better lineup protection than Chicago
- Fantasy points declining sharply: 395→316→271 over last 3 seasons
- Zero speed contribution (0 SB in 2023, 2025; 2 SB in 2024)
- OPS trending down: .743 (2023) → .699 (2024) → .719 (2025)
- Limited positional flexibility (1B only)
- Age 27 suggests this is likely his ceiling, not a breakout candidate
Suggested Action
Monitor Vaughn's role in Milwaukee's lineup during spring training before committing a roster spot; only add if he secures everyday at-bats and your 1B need becomes critical.
Orion Kerkering
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 total RP slots filled. Kerkering would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap. His role is setup/middle relief, not closer, limiting upside.
- Consistent workload: 69 games, 60 IP in 2025 shows durability and trust from PHI
- Solid ratios: 3.30 ERA with 65 K in 60 IP (9.75 K/9) is respectable
- 19 holds indicate high-leverage usage but only 4 saves caps fantasy ceiling
- 303.2 FPTS in 2024 and 269.8 in 2025 shows reliable mid-tier RP production
- 1.37 WHIP is mediocre - 27 BB in 60 IP (4.05 BB/9) is concerning
- Not the closer in Philadelphia - Jeff Hoffman/others ahead for saves
- Age 24 with no clear path to closer role limits long-term upside
- RP volatility - setup men can lose roles quickly with one bad stretch
Suggested Action
Monitor Kerkering's spring training role and any closer competition in PHI, but don't prioritize over higher-impact adds given your existing RP depth.
Anthony Bender
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 RP slots filled. Bender would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap. His role as a middle reliever with occasional saves doesn't dramatically upgrade your bullpen.
- Strong 2.16 ERA and 1.06 WHIP in 50 IP shows quality ratios
- 19 holds indicate high-leverage usage but limited closer opportunity
- 268.7 FPTS in 2025 is solid RP production, outperforming your current RP keeper Strahm (338.9)
- Only 4 saves limits upside in standard formats
- Age 30 with no long-term upside - this is peak value window
- No 2023 stats available - unclear injury history or role changes
- Miami's bullpen hierarchy is volatile; closer role not guaranteed
- 42 K in 50 IP (7.56 K/9) is below elite reliever standards
- 21 walks in 50 IP (3.78 BB/9) shows command concerns
Suggested Action
Monitor Bender's spring training role and Miami's closer situation; only add if he secures the ninth inning job or your RP depth suffers injuries.
Davis Martin
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Martin would be redundant backend depth at best.
- 268 FPTS in 2025 across 25 starts shows durability and innings volume
- 4.10 ERA and 1.29 WHIP are serviceable but not fantasy-relevant
- 104 K in 142.2 IP (6.6 K/9) is below-average strikeout rate
- 9 quality starts in 25 games (36%) is mediocre
- Age 28 with limited upside - this is likely his ceiling
- Pitching for the White Sox limits win opportunities
- No 2023 stats available suggests injury or minor league time
- Below-average strikeout rate caps fantasy ceiling
- 4.10 ERA in a weak division is concerning
Suggested Action
Pass on Martin entirely - your rotation is stacked with higher-upside arms, and a 28-year-old back-end starter on a bad team offers no meaningful value to your roster.
Andrew McCutchen
Roster Fit
McCutchen is a DH-only player at age 39, and your roster lacks 1B depth but has strong OF coverage. He doesn't fill a meaningful gap and would occupy a roster spot better used on upside plays.
- Declining power: 13 HR in 2025 down from 20 in 2024 and 27 in 2021
- Fantasy points trending down: 267.1 FPTS in 2025 vs 299.1 in 2024 vs 308.5 in 2023
- OPS dropped to .700 in 2025, lowest since 2022
- Still draws walks (67 BB in 2025) but limited counting stat upside
- Age 39 entering 2026 season with clear decline trajectory
- DH-only limits roster flexibility and positional value
- Stolen base contribution essentially gone (1 SB in 2025)
- Playing time not guaranteed as Pirates may prioritize younger players
- Sub-.240 batting average limits overall fantasy utility
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - McCutchen's declining production and age make him a poor dynasty asset; use the roster spot on a younger player with upside.
Tyler Freeman
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Freeman creates complete redundancy at an already overcrowded position.
- 2025 FPTS of 265.6 shows improvement but still below-average fantasy production
- Contact-oriented profile: .281 AVG with only 51 K in 377 AB in 2025
- Modest speed contributor: 18 SB but 9 CS (67% success rate is poor)
- Zero power: Only 2 HR in 377 AB in 2025, .360 SLG is replacement level
- Severe lack of power limits fantasy ceiling - career high is 7 HR
- Now 26 years old with no projection for power development
- Colorado move could help counting stats but won't fix fundamental power deficiency
- Poor stolen base efficiency (67%) suggests SB totals may decline with age
- Listed as RF but profile suggests utility/bench role long-term
Suggested Action
Pass on Freeman - his low-power, contact-only profile produces marginal fantasy value, and you have significant RF depth with higher-upside options already rostered.
Brad Lord
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Lord's 264.8 FPTS with a 4.34 ERA and no saves offers minimal upgrade potential and creates redundancy.
- 264.8 FPTS in 2025 across 48 appearances (19 starts) - hybrid role
- 108 K in 130.2 IP (7.4 K/9) - below-average strikeout rate for fantasy relevance
- 7 holds but 0 saves - not in closer role, limiting RP upside
- 5 quality starts in 19 GS - inconsistent as a starter
- No statistical history before 2025 - unclear track record or development trajectory
- 4.34 ERA and 1.29 WHIP are replacement-level numbers
- Undefined role (swingman) typically means inconsistent fantasy production
- Washington's bullpen hierarchy unclear - no path to saves evident
- Age 25 with mediocre ratios suggests limited upside
Suggested Action
Pass on Lord - his swingman role and pedestrian ratios don't justify a roster spot when you already have adequate RP depth and stronger SP options.
Gavin Lux
Roster Fit
Listed as DH-only, which provides no positional flexibility. Your roster already has strong middle infield depth (Stott, Holliday, Albies at 2B; Bichette, Swanson, Tovar at SS) making Lux redundant even if he regains 2B eligibility.
- Consistent playing time (139-140 games in 2024-25) shows durability post-ACL tear
- Solid OBP (.320-.350) driven by decent walk rates (44-56 BB)
- Fantasy production plateaued around 265 FPTS - replacement-level for dynasty
- Power has completely evaporated: only 5 HR in 2025 after 10 HR in 2024
- Listed as DH-only at age 28 - suggests defensive limitations or organizational role
- OPS trending down (.745 in 2022 → .703 in 2024 → .724 in 2025) with no upside indicators
- Zero speed contribution (1 SB in 2025) eliminates category flexibility
- Now with Cincinnati - unclear path to everyday at-bats with their roster construction
Suggested Action
Pass on Lux - he's a 28-year-old DH-only player with declining power, no speed, and replacement-level fantasy production that doesn't address any roster need.
Wenceel Perez
Roster Fit
Creates significant redundancy at RF where you already have 6 players including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. No positional need exists.
- Modest power improvement in 2025: 13 HR vs 9 HR in 2024
- 262.9 FPTS in 100 games projects to ~420 FPTS over full season
- OPS improved from .683 to .738 year-over-year
- Provides some speed (8 SB) but inefficient (3 CS)
- 26 years old with limited upside ceiling - this is likely his peak
- Sub-.250 batting average in both MLB seasons (.244, .242)
- Detroit's rebuilding roster may limit consistent playing time
- Strikeout rate remains elevated (25%+ K rate)
- No clear path to everyday role with Tigers' outfield depth
Suggested Action
Pass on Perez entirely - your RF depth is already excessive and his production ceiling doesn't justify adding another corner outfielder to an already crowded position group.
Brenton Doyle
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall with Langford, Abreu, and Caglianone. Doyle would create redundancy at a position you're already covered.
- 2024 was a career year: 23 HR, 30 SB, 467.9 FPTS - legitimate 5-category contributor
- Speed remains elite with 18 SB in 2025 despite overall regression
- Coors Field provides favorable hitting environment
- Massive 2025 regression: FPTS dropped from 467.9 to 260.2 (-44%)
- OPS collapsed from .764 to .655 - concerning trend at age 27
- Strikeout rate remains problematic (27.5% in 2025) with poor walk rate (6%)
- At 27, this is likely his ceiling - not a developmental upside play
- Colorado's rebuilding status may limit lineup protection and RBI opportunities
Suggested Action
Pass on Doyle - his 2024 looks like an outlier, 2025 shows significant regression, and you have adequate CF coverage with Simpson providing similar speed upside at lower cost.
Ryan Walker
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper and 6 total relievers rostered. Walker would add depth but doesn't fill a critical need given your existing RP coverage.
- 522.7 FPTS in 2024 was elite RP production, but 2025 dropped to 259.6 FPTS - a 50% decline
- 17 saves in 2025 shows closer role access, but 4.11 ERA and 1.27 WHIP indicate declining effectiveness
- 68 games pitched demonstrates durability and high-leverage usage
- Strikeout rate dropped (60 K in 61.1 IP = 8.8 K/9) - below elite closer threshold
- Age 30 with declining performance trajectory - 2024 may have been peak value
- ERA jumped from strong 2024 to mediocre 4.11 in 2025 - concerning trend
- Giants bullpen situation volatile - closer role not guaranteed for 2026
- No draft pedigree data available - limited upside projection confidence
Suggested Action
Pass on Walker - his declining 2025 numbers and age-30 profile don't justify adding when you already have adequate RP depth with Strahm.
Grant Holmes
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Holmes would be redundant depth at best and doesn't crack your rotation.
- 257.8 FPTS in 2025 shows solid production for a back-end starter
- 123 K in 115 IP (9.6 K/9) demonstrates strikeout upside
- 9 quality starts in 21 starts indicates some reliability
- Improved from 187.2 FPTS in 2024 to 257.8 in 2025 shows positive trajectory
- Age 29 limits long-term upside in dynasty format
- 3.99 ERA and 1.34 WHIP are league average at best
- 54 walks in 115 IP (4.2 BB/9) is concerning command issue
- 4-9 record suggests limited run support or inconsistency
- No stats available for 2023 creates uncertainty about track record
Suggested Action
Pass on Holmes given your loaded SP depth; prioritize roster spots for higher-upside options or positional needs at 1B where you only have 1 player.
J.T. Realmuto
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) and Carter Jensen as catcher depth. Realmuto would be redundant and expensive given his declining production.
- 2025 FPTS (257.5) represents significant decline from 2023 peak (387.3)
- Power cratered: only 12 HR in 2025 vs 20+ in prime years
- OPS dropped to .700 in 2025, down from .820 in 2022
- Stolen bases dried up: 8 SB in 2025 vs 21 in 2022
- Still getting 130+ games at age 34, but quality of production is fading
- Age 34 catcher with clear decline trajectory across all offensive categories
- 2024 missed 35+ games (99 GP), durability concerns mounting
- Strikeout rate remains high (129 K in 2025) while power has evaporated
- Contract likely expensive for diminishing returns
- Yainer Diaz outproduced him by 88 FPTS in 2025 at a fraction of the cost
Suggested Action
Pass on Realmuto - your catcher situation is already strong with Diaz, and Realmuto's declining production at age 34 doesn't justify the roster spot or likely salary.
Felix Bautista
Roster Fit
Your RP depth is thin with only Matt Strahm as a clear high-value reliever. Bautista would immediately become your top closer option and provide elite saves upside.
- Elite closer role locked in with 19 saves in 35 games (2025)
- Strong K rate: 50 strikeouts in 34.2 IP (13.0 K/9)
- Excellent ERA (2.60) and WHIP (1.125) in return from injury
- 535.2 FPTS in 2023 shows elite ceiling when healthy
- Age 30 with significant injury history (missed all of 2024 with UCL surgery)
- Walk rate concerning: 23 BB in 34.2 IP (6.0 BB/9)
- Only 256.9 FPTS in 2025 due to limited innings post-surgery
- Relievers inherently volatile for fantasy value year-to-year
Suggested Action
Add Bautista to secure a high-upside closer; his 2023 production (535 FPTS) shows what he can deliver when fully healthy, and he's proven he can handle the closer role in Baltimore.
Janson Junk
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extensive with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Junk would be redundant depth at best and doesn't move the needle.
- 2025 breakout with 256.3 FPTS across 110 IP and 16 starts
- Excellent walk rate (13 BB in 110 IP) shows elite command
- 6 quality starts in 16 starts indicates some reliability
- 4.17 ERA and 1.14 WHIP are serviceable but not exciting
- Age 29 with no prior track record - 2024 was -49.2 FPTS disaster
- Low strikeout rate (77 K in 110 IP = 6.3 K/9) limits upside
- Miami rotation is volatile - role could evaporate quickly
- You previously let him go, suggesting you already evaluated and passed
- Contact-heavy profile (112 H in 110 IP) is risky long-term
Suggested Action
Pass on Junk - he's a back-end starter at best with limited upside, and your rotation is already stacked with higher-ceiling arms.
Patrick Corbin
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including high-upside arms like Hunter Greene, Jack Leiter, and Jacob Misiorowski. Adding a declining 36-year-old with a 4.40 ERA creates unnecessary redundancy at your deepest position.
- 255.7 FPTS in 2025 represents a bounce-back from dismal 140.6 FPTS in 2024
- 131 K in 155.1 IP shows he can still miss bats at a modest rate
- 30 starts indicates durability and rotation security with Texas
- Age 36 with declining velocity and stuff - wrong side of the aging curve
- 4.40 ERA and 1.36 WHIP are below-average ratios that hurt in roto/points formats
- Only 6 quality starts in 30 GS shows inconsistency and blow-up risk
- 161 hits allowed in 155.1 IP - contact management is a major concern
- Fantasy points have been volatile: 198→140→255 over three years
Suggested Action
Pass on Corbin entirely - your SP depth is elite and his declining profile offers no upside worth a roster spot.
Matt Wallner
Roster Fit
RF is already your deepest position with 6 players including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS). Wallner would be redundant depth at a position you don't need to address.
- Solid power: 22 HR in 104 games (2025), projects to 30+ with full playing time
- 255.3 FPTS in 2025 shows legitimate MLB production
- Decent walk rate (46 BB in 336 AB) supports OBP floor
- High strikeout rate (114 K in 336 AB = 34% K rate) caps batting average upside
- 2025 batting average dropped to .202 - concerning regression from .259 in 2024
- Age 27 limits upside trajectory - this is likely his ceiling
- Twins outfield crowded with Buxton, Julien, others competing for ABs
- You previously let him go, suggesting you've already evaluated and passed
Suggested Action
Pass on Wallner - your RF depth is excessive and his declining batting average combined with high strikeouts makes him a replacement-level fantasy asset at a position you've already addressed.
Jonathan India
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists for another second baseman.
- Consistent everyday player with 136-151 games played in recent full seasons
- Solid OBP contributor (.323-.376 range) due to walk rate
- 2021 ROY season (21 HR, 12 SB, .835 OPS) remains career peak
- Provides runs scored (63-98 annually) from leadoff/top-of-order role
- Clear decline trajectory: 2025 FPTS (253.3) down 39% from 2024 (416.4)
- Power evaporating: 9 HR in 2025 vs 15-21 HR in prior seasons
- Zero stolen bases in 2025 after 12-14 SB in 2023-24
- OPS collapsed to .669 in 2025, well below league average
- Age 28 with declining athleticism, not a buy-low candidate
Suggested Action
Pass on India entirely—your 2B depth is elite, and his 2025 collapse suggests he's a declining asset not worth a roster spot.
Gabriel Moreno
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher and Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. Moreno would be a redundant C2 with lower upside than Diaz, creating positional overlap without filling a need.
- Consistent .280-.285 batting average over 3 MLB seasons shows solid contact skills
- 2025 FPTS (253.0) trending up from 2024 (239.3) with improved power (9 HR in 83 games)
- Strong OBP improvement in 2025 (.353) driven by better walk rate
- Only 25 years old with established MLB role as Arizona's starting catcher
- Games played capped at 83-111 annually - durability/playing time concerns typical for catchers
- Limited power ceiling (5-9 HR range) caps fantasy upside at the position
- Produces roughly 100 fewer FPTS than your current C1 Yainer Diaz
- No stolen base contribution (2-6 SB annually) limits category value
Suggested Action
Pass on Moreno unless you're looking to trade Yainer Diaz or need catcher depth insurance - he's a solid MLB catcher but doesn't upgrade your roster.
Taj Bradley
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including high-end arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Greene (452 FPTS), and Imanaga (416 FPTS). Bradley would be redundant depth rather than filling a need.
- 127 K in 142.2 IP shows solid strikeout ability (8.0 K/9)
- 27 starts demonstrates durability and rotation security
- 13 quality starts indicates some ability to go deep in games
- Age 24 with MLB experience - still in development window
- 5.05 ERA is well below replacement level for fantasy SP
- 1.31 WHIP indicates poor command/hit prevention
- 56 BB in 142.2 IP (3.5 BB/9) is concerning walk rate
- FPTS declined from 343 (2024) to 253 (2025) - trending wrong direction
- Now with MIN after leaving TB system - unclear role/development path
Suggested Action
Pass on Bradley given your deep SP rotation; monitor only if he shows significant ERA/WHIP improvement in spring training or early 2026.
Ty France
Roster Fit
You have only 1 1B rostered, so there is positional need, but France's declining production makes him a poor fit to fill that gap. Better options likely exist.
- Consistent playing time (138-158 games per season)
- Contact-oriented approach with low strikeout rates relative to league
- 2025 FPTS (250.4) represents a slight uptick from 2024 (208.9)
- Clear multi-year decline: OPS dropped from .813 (2021) to .681 (2025)
- Power has evaporated: only 7 HR in 2025 after 18-20 HR seasons in 2021-22
- Age 31 with declining athleticism and no speed component
- Slugging percentage (.360) is replacement-level for a 1B-only player
- Fantasy points trending down significantly from 2023 peak (334.7)
Suggested Action
Pass on France and target a younger 1B with upside or a veteran with more power production to address your positional need.
Tim Hill
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Hill would add depth but not upgrade your relief corps significantly, and at age 35, he offers no long-term upside.
- 248.7 FPTS in 2025 is solid for a middle reliever - 70 games, 15 holds
- 3.09 ERA and 1.10 WHIP show reliable performance
- Strong rebound from 40.6 FPTS in 2023 to 248.7 in 2025
- Age 35 - declining phase likely, no dynasty upside
- Zero saves - purely a holds/middle relief guy with limited fantasy ceiling
- Low strikeout rate (37 K in 67 IP = 4.97 K/9) limits upside in most formats
- Non-closer relievers are highly replaceable year-to-year
Suggested Action
Pass on Hill - your RP depth is adequate and roster spots are better spent on younger players with upside or position needs like 1B where you only have 1 player.
Bennett Sousa
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper and 6 total relievers rostered. Sousa would add depth but doesn't fill a critical need given your existing RP coverage.
- Strong 2025 season: 248.3 FPTS across 44 games with 2.84 ERA and 1.03 WHIP
- Solid K rate: 59 strikeouts in 50.2 IP (10.5 K/9)
- Versatile usage: 4 saves, 7 holds indicates high-leverage opportunities
- Low hit rate: 37 hits allowed in 50.2 IP shows quality stuff
- Age 30 - limited upside trajectory, likely at or near peak value
- No 2024 data available - unclear what caused the gap year
- Only 28.1 FPTS in 2023 suggests 2025 may be an outlier
- Middle reliever role in Houston - saves opportunities inconsistent
- You previously let him go - suggests prior evaluation found him expendable
Suggested Action
Pass on Sousa; his 2025 breakout at age 30 is encouraging but your RP depth is adequate, and younger relievers with upside should be prioritized over a 30-year-old middle reliever.
Joseph Ortiz
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS rostered including Bo Bichette (570.8 FPTS), Dansby Swanson (421.2 FPTS), and Ezequiel Tovar. Adding another SS creates significant redundancy with no clear path to playing time on your fantasy roster.
- 2024 FPTS of 330.6 suggests some MLB utility value
- 2025 FPTS dropped to 248.3, indicating regression or reduced role
- At 27, he's entering his prime years but hasn't established himself
- No MLB ID listed suggests limited prospect pedigree or tracking
- Missing physical data and draft background indicates undrafted/international signing with less organizational investment
- Sharp decline from 2024 to 2025 (330.6 to 248.3 FPTS) is concerning
- No detailed stat history available to assess underlying skills
- Age 27 with inconsistent production suggests ceiling is limited
Suggested Action
Pass on Ortiz entirely - your SS depth is already excessive with higher-producing options, and his declining production at age 27 offers no upside worth a roster spot.
Reid Detmers
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper and 6 total relievers rostered. Detmers would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap given your existing RP coverage.
- Strong K rate: 80 K in 63.2 IP (11.3 K/9) shows swing-and-miss stuff
- 246 FPTS in 2025 is solid for a reliever, comparable to your keeper Strahm (338.9)
- 61 games pitched shows durability and manager trust in high-leverage situations
- 13 holds + 3 saves indicates multi-inning/setup role with occasional closing opportunities
- Former starter now converted to full-time relief - ceiling may be capped
- 3.96 ERA and 1.30 WHIP are serviceable but not elite for a reliever
- Walk rate concerning: 25 BB in 63.2 IP (3.5 BB/9) limits upside
- 2024 was a disaster (45.7 FPTS) - 2025 bounce-back may not be sustainable
- Angels bullpen hierarchy unclear - saves opportunities inconsistent
Suggested Action
Monitor Detmers through spring training to see if he earns a defined closer role; only add if saves become consistent or your RP depth thins out.
Clarke Schmidt
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on roster including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Schmidt would be redundant depth rather than filling a need.
- Consistent fantasy production: 245-253 FPTS across last 3 seasons
- Solid ratios: 3.32 ERA, 1.09 WHIP in 2025
- Quality start rate of 50% (7 QS in 14 starts)
- Age 29 - entering prime but limited upside ceiling
- Injury history has limited him to 14 starts/78.2 IP in 2025
- Walk rate concerning (30 BB in 78.2 IP = 3.4 BB/9)
- Yankees rotation depth could limit opportunities
- Fantasy ceiling capped around 250-300 FPTS even when healthy
- No significant improvement trajectory in stats year-over-year
Suggested Action
Pass on Schmidt given your deep SP rotation; only revisit if multiple starters get injured or if he's available very late in Rule 5 selection.
Graham Ashcraft
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and Ashcraft would add depth to a thin relief corps. However, he's a non-closer middle reliever, limiting his fantasy ceiling.
- 62 games and 65.1 IP in 2025 shows durable high-leverage usage
- 23 holds indicates consistent late-inning role
- 238.6 FPTS in 2025 is solid for a non-closer reliever
- Bounced back from injury-plagued 2024 (70.1 FPTS)
- 3.99 ERA and 1.42 WHIP are mediocre ratios for fantasy value
- Zero saves - no path to closer role with Alexis Diaz in Cincinnati
- K/9 under 9.0 (64 K in 65.1 IP) limits upside
- Converted from starter - role could shift again
- 2024 injury concerns (only 70.1 FPTS) suggest durability questions
Suggested Action
Monitor Ashcraft's spring role and Cincinnati's bullpen hierarchy, but don't prioritize him over higher-upside Rule 5 targets given your existing RP depth.
Nick Mears
Roster Fit
You have Matt Strahm as your only notable RP keeper, so there's room for bullpen depth. However, Mears is a middle reliever without closer upside, limiting his fantasy ceiling.
- Strong 2025 campaign: 63 G, 56.2 IP, 3.49 ERA, 0.97 WHIP
- 238.2 FPTS in 2025 shows solid production for a non-closer
- 17 holds indicate high-leverage usage but only 1 save
- Consistent year-over-year improvement: 44.3 → 124.3 → 238.2 FPTS
- Age 29 with no closer role - limited upside for saves
- Only 46 K in 56.2 IP (7.3 K/9) is below elite reliever standards
- You previously let him go, suggesting he wasn't a priority
- Middle relief is highly volatile - role could diminish with roster changes
Suggested Action
Monitor Milwaukee's closer situation; only add if Mears moves into a saves role or your league heavily rewards holds.
Michael Lorenzen
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already elite with Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, Leiter, and high-upside arms like Misiorowski and Patrick. Lorenzen would be redundant backend depth at best.
- Declining fantasy production: 350.7 FPTS (2023) → 335.9 (2024) → 238.0 (2025)
- 4.64 ERA and 1.327 WHIP in 2025 indicate below-average ratios
- 127 K in 141.2 IP (8.1 K/9) is mediocre strikeout upside
- Only 9 quality starts in 26 starts shows inconsistency
- Age 33 entering 2026 with clear performance decline trajectory
- Negative value pitcher who hurts ratios more than helps counting stats
- No saves/holds value as a starter
- KC rotation spot not guaranteed given team's rebuilding status
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - your rotation is stacked with younger, higher-upside arms, and Lorenzen's declining production offers no value over your current options.
Royce Lewis
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with a $26 salary, making Lewis redundant at his primary position. Lewis could provide injury insurance but doesn't fill a roster gap.
- Showed elite upside in 2023 (.309 AVG, .921 OPS, 15 HR in 58 games)
- Added stolen base value in 2025 (12 SB) that wasn't present in 2024
- Power potential remains (13-16 HR range when healthy)
- Only 26 years old with established MLB track record
- Significant regression in 2025: .237 AVG, .671 OPS is well below replacement level
- Chronic injury history has limited him to 58, 82, and 106 games over three seasons
- Strikeout rate increasing while walk rate declining (6.6% BB in 2025)
- Fantasy points trending down: 286.5 → 239.7 → 233.7 despite more games played
- OPS dropped 250 points from 2023 to 2025, suggesting the breakout was the outlier
Suggested Action
Monitor Lewis's spring training and early 2026 performance before committing a roster spot; his 2023 looks like the outlier, not the baseline.
Brant Hurter
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper, and 6 total RP slots filled. Hurter would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap—he's a middle reliever without a clear path to high-leverage saves.
- Strong 2.43 ERA in 63 IP shows he can handle MLB workload
- 68 K in 63 IP (9.7 K/9) is solid strikeout upside for a reliever
- 230.6 FPTS in 2025 is respectable for a non-closer RP
- Only 2 saves and 5 holds—limited high-leverage opportunity
- 1.33 WHIP is mediocre; 27 BB in 63 IP (3.9 BB/9) is a concern
- Age 27 with no clear closer path limits dynasty upside
- 4 spot starts suggest Tigers may use him as swingman, not setup
- No 2023 stats available—limited track record to evaluate consistency
Suggested Action
Monitor Hurter's role in Detroit's bullpen hierarchy; only add if he secures the closer job or your RP depth takes a hit.
Jake Burger
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 1B player, so there is positional need. However, Burger's declining production and limited fantasy ceiling make him a marginal fit at best.
- Power bat with 34 HR in 2023, but declined to 29 HR in 2024 and on pace for ~25 HR in 2025
- 2025 FPTS (229.3 through 103 games) projects to roughly 350 full-season, a significant drop from 456 in 2023
- OPS collapsed from .828 (2023) to .760 (2024) to .687 (2025) - clear downward trajectory
- 1B-only eligibility limits roster flexibility
- Severe decline in batting average (.236) and OBP (.269) in 2025 tanks counting stats
- High strikeout rate (26%+) with minimal walk rate (3.4% in 2025) creates volatile production
- Age 29 with declining metrics suggests this is who he is, not a slump
- No speed contribution (1 SB per year) limits fantasy upside in roto/points formats
Suggested Action
Pass on Burger; his declining production and 1B-only eligibility don't justify a roster spot when better Rule 5 options likely exist to address your 1B need.
Victor Scott II
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, making Scott redundant. Simpson actually produced similar FPTS (294.3) to Scott (229.2) at a lower salary, so there's no clear upgrade path here.
- Elite stolen base upside: 34 SB in 138 games (2025) shows plus speed that plays in fantasy
- Full-time role secured: 138 games and 398 ABs indicate Cardinals trust him as everyday CF
- Improved plate discipline: 42 walks in 2025 vs. 6 in 2024 shows growth
- Brutal batting average (.216) and OPS (.601) severely limit overall fantasy value
- 111 strikeouts in 398 ABs (27.9% K rate) suggests contact issues won't improve quickly
- Minimal power (5 HR, .296 SLG) means he's a one-category contributor
- 229 FPTS in 138 games is below-average production for a full-time player
Suggested Action
Pass on adding Scott unless you're desperate for steals; your existing CF options provide similar or better value without the roster cost.
Ryan McMahon
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with a $26 salary, making McMahon redundant. Adding a declining 30-year-old 3B with inferior production creates unnecessary roster bloat at a position you have covered.
- Consistent 20 HR power over 6 seasons (20-24 HR annually)
- Strong walk rate (70 BB in 2025) provides OBP floor
- Durable: 150+ games in 4 of last 5 full seasons
- Now with Yankees, leaving Coors Field will likely hurt offensive numbers
- Clear decline trajectory: FPTS dropped from 333.7 (2023) to 298.3 (2024) to 226.7 (2025)
- Batting average collapsed to .214 in 2025 with 189 strikeouts
- OPS dropped to .693 in 2025 - below league average
- Age 30 with declining skills suggests further regression likely
- Leaving Coors Field for Yankee Stadium may further suppress power numbers
Suggested Action
Pass on McMahon entirely - he's a declining veteran who doesn't fit your roster needs and offers minimal upside at age 30 with worsening contact issues.
Bryce Elder
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Elder would be redundant depth at best and doesn't improve your rotation.
- 28 starts in 2025 shows durability and rotation security with Atlanta
- 14 quality starts despite poor overall numbers indicates some floor
- 131 K in 156.1 IP (7.5 K/9) is below-average strikeout rate for fantasy
- 5.30 ERA and 1.39 WHIP in 2025 are replacement-level numbers
- 226.6 FPTS in 2025 ranks well below your current SP options
- 2024 season shows only 8.3 FPTS - likely injury or demotion, major red flag
- At 26, this is likely his ceiling - not a developmental upside play
- Volatile year-to-year production (442 FPTS in 2023, then collapse)
Suggested Action
Pass on Elder entirely - your rotation is stacked and he offers no upside over your current SP depth like Patrick, Misiorowski, or Caminiti.
Ben Casparius
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper plus 5 other relievers rostered. Casparius would add marginal depth to an already adequate bullpen situation.
- 225.6 FPTS in 2025 shows decent volume (46 G, 77.2 IP)
- 13 holds indicates middle-relief role with some leverage
- 71 K in 77.2 IP (8.2 K/9) is acceptable but not elite
- Only 2 saves limits upside in standard formats
- 4.64 ERA and 1.27 WHIP are below-average ratios for fantasy relevance
- Age 26 with no clear path to closer role in loaded LAD bullpen
- No 2023 stats available - limited track record
- Middle reliever profile caps fantasy ceiling significantly
Suggested Action
Pass on Casparius - his mediocre ratios and lack of saves upside make him replaceable waiver wire fodder rather than a keeper-worthy asset.
Blake Snell
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Snell would add veteran upside but creates redundancy rather than filling a gap.
- Elite strikeout rate: 72 K in 61.1 IP (10.6 K/9) in 2025
- Strong ERA (2.35) and solid WHIP (1.26) through 11 starts
- Two-time Cy Young winner with proven ceiling (753 FPTS in 2023)
- Quality start rate of 45% (5 QS in 11 starts) shows consistency potential
- Age 33 with significant injury history - only 61 IP in 2025, 430 FPTS in 2024 suggests durability concerns
- Walk rate remains elevated (26 BB in 61.1 IP = 3.8 BB/9) limiting upside
- Dramatic FPTS decline: 753 (2023) → 430 (2024) → 225 (2025 partial) shows volatility
- Late-career pitcher on a contending team may face workload management
Suggested Action
Monitor Snell's health and workload through the offseason; only pursue if a roster spot opens or if you can move a lower-ceiling SP prospect.
Huascar Brazoban
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Brazoban at age 36 with modest saves (2) and holds (12) doesn't upgrade your bullpen or fill a need.
- 223.2 FPTS in 2025 is solid for a middle reliever but not elite
- 3.57 ERA and 1.238 WHIP are serviceable but unspectacular
- Only 2 saves limits fantasy ceiling in most formats
- 57 K in 63 IP shows decent but not dominant strikeout ability
- Age 36 entering 2026 - significant decline risk
- Listed at 155 lbs on 6'3" frame raises durability questions
- No clear path to closer role with NYM bullpen depth
- Inconsistent year-to-year production (119.3 FPTS in 2024 vs 223.2 in 2025)
Suggested Action
Pass on Brazoban - he's a replacement-level reliever at an age where decline is imminent, and your RP depth is already adequate.
Angel Martinez
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall. Martinez would be redundant and offers less upside than your current options.
- 139 games played in 2025 shows he can hold a roster spot
- 11 HR and 8 SB provide modest power/speed combo
- 218.8 FPTS in full season is below-average starter production
- Poor plate discipline: .269 OBP with only 23 walks in 446 ABs
- High strikeout rate (110 K in 446 AB, ~25%)
- .628 OPS is well below league average, limits fantasy ceiling
- Age 23 with a full MLB season of mediocre production suggests this may be his ceiling
- Cleveland's outfield depth could limit future playing time
Suggested Action
Pass on Martinez; his 2025 production was replacement-level and your CF/OF depth is already strong with higher-upside options.
Danny Coulombe
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as a quality RP and 6 total relievers rostered. Coulombe would be redundant depth at a position that's not a priority for your roster.
- Solid 2.30 ERA and 1.16 WHIP in 2025 shows he can still pitch effectively
- Consistent workload of 43-55 IP per season as a middle reliever
- 218.6 FPTS in 2025 is respectable but not elite for RP
- Age 36 heading into 2026 - significant decline risk imminent
- Only 2 saves and 9 holds - not in a high-leverage role that drives fantasy value
- Fantasy points trending down from 290.2 (2023) to 218.6 (2025)
- Middle relievers are easily replaceable and rarely worth roster spots in dynasty
Suggested Action
Pass on Coulombe - a 36-year-old middle reliever with declining production doesn't warrant a roster spot when you already have adequate RP depth.
Bailey Falter
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Falter would be redundant depth at best and offers no upside over your current options.
- Consistent innings eater: 125.1 IP in 2025 with 24 starts
- Modest win total (7) shows he holds a rotation spot
- 256.3 FPTS in 2024 was his career peak - still below your SP5 level
- 4.45 ERA and 1.28 WHIP are below-average ratios for fantasy
- Only 81 strikeouts in 125 IP (5.8 K/9) severely limits upside
- Age 28 with no projection for improvement - this is his ceiling
- 46 walks indicate command issues that inflate ratios
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Falter is a back-end innings filler with no strikeout upside, and your rotation is already stacked with better options including high-ceiling prospects like Misiorowski and Patrick.
Reed Garrett
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper plus 5 other relievers. Garrett would add marginal depth to an already adequate bullpen situation, creating redundancy rather than filling a need.
- Solid 64 K in 55.1 IP (10.4 K/9) shows swing-and-miss stuff
- 20 holds indicate high-leverage usage and manager trust
- 214.6 FPTS in 2025 is respectable middle-reliever production
- Consistent workload with 58 appearances shows durability
- Age 32 entering 2026 - declining phase for relievers, limited upside
- 3.90 ERA and 1.32 WHIP are league-average, not elite
- Only 3 saves - not in closer role, capping fantasy ceiling
- 26 walks in 55.1 IP (4.2 BB/9) indicates command concerns
- You previously let him go - your prior evaluation was correct
Suggested Action
Pass on Garrett; his age and middling ratios don't justify a roster spot when you already have adequate RP depth and should prioritize younger upside plays or positional needs.
Tommy Kahnle
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as a quality RP and 6 total relievers on roster. Kahnle at age 36 with declining ratios adds redundancy without upside.
- Consistent workload: 63 IP across 66 games in 2025
- Mixed role value: 9 saves + 16 holds shows high-leverage usage
- Fantasy production stable around 200-225 FPTS annually
- Age 36 entering 2026 - significant decline risk for relievers
- 4.43 ERA and 1.30 WHIP in 2025 show deteriorating effectiveness
- 31 walks in 63 IP (4.4 BB/9) indicates command issues
- Strikeout rate dropped to 7.1 K/9 - below elite reliever threshold
- Not a closer - limited saves upside caps fantasy ceiling
Suggested Action
Pass on Kahnle - his age, declining ratios, and your existing RP depth make him a poor use of a roster spot for 2026.
Eduardo Rodriguez
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already excellent with Castillo, Greene, Leiter, Imanaga, and emerging arms like Misiorowski and Patrick. Adding a declining, expensive veteran with poor ratios creates redundancy without upside.
- 2025 FPTS of 213.3 is well below your current SP average (around 374 FPTS for your top 5 starters)
- 5.02 ERA and 1.54 WHIP in 2025 indicate significant regression from his 488.8 FPTS 2023 season
- 29 starts shows durability, but quality starts (9) were inconsistent
- 143 K in 154.1 IP (8.3 K/9) is acceptable but not elite
- Age 32 with declining performance trajectory - 2024 was injury-shortened (59.3 FPTS), 2025 showed poor ratios
- 5.02 ERA and 1.54 WHIP actively hurt fantasy teams in most formats
- No clear path to improvement at this stage of career
- Would likely command significant salary for minimal return
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - your rotation is already deep with higher-upside arms, and Rodriguez's declining performance makes him a liability rather than an asset.
Michael Burrows
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Burrows would be depth at best and creates redundancy rather than filling a need.
- Strong 2025 FPTS jump to 212.5 suggests breakout potential after minimal 2024 production (10.6 FPTS)
- Age 26 means he's entering prime years with MLB experience now
- Pirates rotation has opportunity for innings with their rebuilding approach
- No historical stats available beyond FPTS - cannot evaluate underlying metrics (K%, BB%, ERA, WHIP)
- Massive year-over-year variance (10.6 to 212.5 FPTS) could indicate small sample or inconsistency
- No MLB ID listed suggests limited track record or data gaps
- Pittsburgh's offense limits win potential for fantasy SP value
Suggested Action
Monitor Burrows' spring training role and early 2026 usage before committing a roster spot given your already deep SP corps.
Ryan Helsley
Roster Fit
You have Matt Strahm as your only notable RP keeper, so closer depth is a legitimate need. However, Helsley's declining performance and age (31) make him a risky add at this stage.
- 2024 was elite: 585.1 FPTS with dominant closer production
- 2025 regression severe: 207.6 FPTS, ERA ballooned to 4.50, WHIP 1.54
- Still accumulating saves (21 in 58 games) despite struggles
- K rate remains solid (63 K in 56 IP) but walks up significantly (25 BB)
- Age 31 reliever with sharp decline in 2025 - could be velocity/stuff degradation
- ERA jumped from elite to below-average (4.50), WHIP from sub-1.0 to 1.54
- Now with Baltimore - closer role not guaranteed with existing bullpen pieces
- Relievers are volatile; 2024 may have been the peak, not the floor
- 2023 was also mediocre (223.0 FPTS) - 2024 looks like the outlier
Suggested Action
Monitor Helsley's spring training and early 2026 role clarity in Baltimore before committing a roster spot; he's not a priority add given the volatility.
Willi Castro
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF players including Wilyer Abreu, Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Castro would create significant redundancy at an already crowded position with no clear path to playing time on your roster.
- 2024 was his career-best with 381.8 FPTS over 158 games - a full season starter
- Provides modest power/speed combo (12 HR, 14 SB in 2024)
- Multi-position eligibility historically (SS/2B/OF) adds flexibility
- Contact has been declining: .247 in 2024 down to .226 in 2025
- 2025 FPTS dropped significantly to 207.1 - a 46% decline from 2024
- OPS collapsed from .717 to .679 in 2025, trending toward replacement level
- At 28, this is not a development play - what you see is what you get
- Stolen base production dropped from 33 (2023) to 14 (2024) to 10 (2025)
- High strikeout rate (27.6% in 2025) limits batting average upside
Suggested Action
Pass on Castro - he's a declining 28-year-old utility player who doesn't fit your roster needs and offers no upside beyond replacement-level production.
Isiah Kiner-Falefa
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B and multiple middle infield options (Bichette, Stott, Holliday, Swanson, Tovar). IKF would be redundant depth at a position you're already stacked at.
- Consistent playing time (130+ games in 3 of last 4 full seasons)
- Modest stolen base contributor (11-22 SB annually)
- High contact rate with low strikeouts relative to league average
- Age 30 with declining power trajectory (only 2 HR in 2025, down from 8 in 2024)
- Fantasy points trending downward: 264.5 (2024) → 203.3 (2025)
- Sub-.300 OBP and sub-.350 SLG in 2025 severely limits fantasy ceiling
- No path to everyday playing time on a competitive roster given his offensive profile
- Zero upside - this is a known commodity with a low ceiling
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - IKF is a replacement-level fantasy asset at 30 years old with declining production and no fit on your roster.
Yoan Moncada
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with a $26 salary, making Moncada redundant. Your 3B depth is adequate and Moncada doesn't offer an upgrade.
- 2025 bounce-back: 12 HR, .783 OPS in 84 games after injury-plagued 2024
- Career-best walk rate in 2025 (11.4%) showing improved plate discipline
- Still flashes power potential with .448 SLG in limited action
- Age 30 with extensive injury history - played only 12 games in 2024
- Has not played a full season since 2021 (144 games)
- Strikeout rate remains elevated (30.2% in 2025)
- Peak season was 2019 (.915 OPS) - has declined significantly since
- Zero stolen bases in 2025 after being a 10+ SB player earlier in career
- On Angels roster with unclear path to everyday playing time
Suggested Action
Pass on Moncada - he's a declining, injury-prone 30-year-old who doesn't upgrade your 3B situation over Austin Riley.
Brock Stewart
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as a quality RP and 6 total relievers on roster. Stewart would be redundant depth at a position that's not a priority need.
- Solid 2.63 ERA and 1.19 WHIP in 2025 shows competent middle relief
- 16 holds indicates trusted setup role with LAD
- 44 K in 37.2 IP (10.5 K/9) is respectable strikeout rate
- 202.2 FPTS in 2025 is decent but not elite for RP
- Age 34 - declining phase of career with limited upside
- Zero saves - not in closer role, capping fantasy ceiling
- 2024 was a disaster (63.6 FPTS) showing volatility
- Middle relievers are highly replaceable and roster-inefficient
- No path to increased role - Dodgers have established bullpen hierarchy
Suggested Action
Pass on Stewart - at 34 with no saves upside and your existing RP depth, this roster spot is better used on a younger player with growth potential.
Grant Anderson
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP keeper (338.9 FPTS) and 6 total RP slots filled. Anderson would add depth but doesn't fill a critical need given your existing bullpen coverage.
- 198.2 FPTS in 2025 represents a significant bounceback from -2.8 in 2024
- 66 games/69.2 IP shows workhorse usage and manager trust
- 74 K in 69.2 IP (9.6 K/9) provides solid strikeout upside
- 3.23 ERA is respectable for a middle reliever
- Age 28 with no saves (0) and only 6 holds limits high-leverage fantasy ceiling
- 1.26 WHIP and 29 walks indicate command issues that could inflate ratios
- 2024 season was a disaster (-2.8 FPTS) - volatility is a real concern
- No clear path to closer role in Milwaukee limits upside
- 2-6 W/L record despite heavy usage suggests poor run support or blown leads
Suggested Action
Monitor Anderson's spring role in Milwaukee; only add if he secures a setup/closer role or your RP depth thins due to injury.
Tyler Stephenson
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher plus Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. Adding Stephenson creates redundancy at a shallow position where you're already adequately covered.
- 2024 was career-best: 138 games, 19 HR, .782 OPS, 384.2 FPTS
- Significant regression in 2025: only 88 games, 13 HR, .737 OPS, 195.7 FPTS
- Catcher eligibility provides positional scarcity value
- Decent walk rate (10-11%) shows plate discipline
- 2025 decline is concerning: strikeout rate spiked (38.8% K%), batting average dropped to .231
- Age 29 entering 2026 - limited upside remaining, this is likely his ceiling
- Injury history has limited him to 50-88 games in 3 of last 4 seasons before 2024
- Zero speed contribution (0 SB in 2025, 1 SB in 2024)
- Cincinnati's lineup context doesn't project for significant improvement
Suggested Action
Pass on Stephenson - Yainer Diaz outproduced him significantly in 2025 and is younger; your catcher depth is sufficient without adding a declining 29-year-old.
Michael McGreevy
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Leiter, Misiorowski, and established contributors like Castillo and Greene. McGreevy would be redundant depth at best.
- 195.3 FPTS in 2025 across 16 starts shows he can hold a rotation spot
- 7 quality starts in 16 games (44%) is respectable for a back-end starter
- Low walk rate (20 BB in 95.2 IP) indicates solid command
- 58 K in 95.2 IP (5.5 K/9) is extremely low strikeout rate - severely limits fantasy upside
- 4.42 ERA and 1.25 WHIP are replacement-level numbers
- 100 hits allowed in 95.2 IP suggests hittable stuff that won't age well
- No 2023 stats available - limited track record to evaluate
- Cardinals rotation has competition; role not guaranteed long-term
Suggested Action
Pass on McGreevy - your SP corps is stacked and his low-K profile makes him a SP5/6 ceiling with minimal fantasy upside compared to your existing options.
Griffin Canning
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Canning would be redundant depth at best and doesn't crack your rotation.
- Modest 186.9 FPTS in 2025 across 16 starts (76.1 IP) - backend starter production
- 3.77 ERA is serviceable but 1.38 WHIP indicates control issues (35 BB in 76.1 IP)
- K rate underwhelming at 8.3 K/9 - not a strikeout pitcher
- Age 29 with no upside trajectory - this is who he is
- Significant decline from 299.1 FPTS (2023) to 162-187 range in 2024-25
- High walk rate (4.1 BB/9) limits ceiling and creates volatile outings
- Moving to NYM doesn't guarantee rotation spot with their depth
- Injury history has limited innings in multiple seasons
Suggested Action
Pass on Canning - your rotation is stacked and he offers no upside over your current SP14; use roster spot on higher-ceiling options.
Evan Carter
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall with Langford, Abreu, and Caglianone. Carter would be redundant unless you're looking to upgrade over Cowser's disappointing 154.9 FPTS.
- 2025 rebound: 182.7 FPTS in 63 games projects to ~290 FPTS over full season
- Improved stolen base production (14 SB in 63 games) adds category value
- Strong plate discipline for age (19 BB, only 41 K in 194 AB in 2025)
- Electric 2023 debut (.306/.413/.645) showed legitimate upside
- 2024 was a disaster (.188 AVG, .633 OPS) with back injury limiting him to 45 games
- Power has regressed significantly (5 HR in 63 games in 2025 vs. 5 HR in 23 games in 2023)
- Still only 63 games in 2025 - health remains a question mark
- OPS of .728 in 2025 is league average, not the star production expected from his prospect pedigree
Suggested Action
Monitor Carter's second half 2025 performance and health status before committing a roster spot; he's not an upgrade over your current OF options unless he recaptures 2023 form.
Mike Soroka
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Soroka would be redundant depth at best and doesn't crack your rotation.
- 177.8 FPTS in 2025 shows modest bounce-back from injury-plagued years
- 4.52 ERA and 1.13 WHIP are serviceable but not fantasy-relevant
- 95 K in 89.2 IP (9.5 K/9) shows decent strikeout upside
- Only 4 quality starts in 17 starts indicates inconsistency
- Age 28 with extensive injury history (multiple Achilles surgeries) limits upside
- 3-8 record despite Cubs being competitive suggests run support or performance issues
- Career trajectory has been downward since elite 2019 rookie season
- Only 89.2 IP suggests workload management or injury concerns persist
Suggested Action
Pass on Soroka entirely - your rotation is stacked and his ceiling is a back-end starter with significant injury risk at age 28.
Connor Norby
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with 248.8 FPTS despite a down year, plus multiple MI options (Stott, Holliday, Albies) who can cover corner infield. Norby creates redundancy without offering an upgrade.
- 176 FPTS in 88 games (2025) projects to ~320 FPTS over full season - below average starter value
- Power regression: 9 HR in 178 AB (2024) dropped to 8 HR in 311 AB (2025)
- Modest speed contribution: 8 SB in 2025 adds some value
- Sub-.300 OBP (.300 in 2025) limits counting stat upside
- High strikeout rate (29% K rate in 2025) with poor walk rate limits batting average floor
- OPS declined from .732 (2024) to .689 (2025) - trending wrong direction
- Miami's lineup provides minimal run-scoring environment
- No 2023 stats available - limited track record to evaluate
Suggested Action
Pass on Norby; your 3B/MI depth is sufficient and his declining production profile doesn't warrant a roster spot over your current options.
Brandon Walter
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Walter would be redundant depth rather than filling a need.
- Excellent 0.93 WHIP in 53.2 IP shows elite command (only 4 BB)
- 6 quality starts in 9 starts (67% QS rate) indicates consistency
- 52 K in 53.2 IP (8.7 K/9) is solid but not elite strikeout upside
- 3.35 ERA is serviceable for a back-end starter
- Age 29 limits long-term upside in dynasty format
- Only 175.5 FPTS in 2025 - modest fantasy production even with good ratios
- No 2024 data suggests limited MLB track record or injury concerns
- Houston rotation is crowded - role security uncertain for 2026
- Small sample size (53.2 IP) makes it hard to trust peripherals
Suggested Action
Monitor Walter's spring training role and Houston's rotation decisions before committing a roster spot given your existing SP depth.
Tyler Anderson
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already excellent with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Anderson would be redundant backend depth at best.
- 2025 regression: 171 FPTS across 26 starts is well below replacement level
- 4.56 ERA and 1.41 WHIP indicate declining effectiveness
- Only 6 quality starts in 26 attempts shows inconsistency
- 104 K in 136.1 IP (6.9 K/9) lacks strikeout upside
- Age 35 entering 2026 with clear decline trajectory
- Walk rate (57 BB in 136.1 IP = 3.8 BB/9) trending wrong direction
- 2-8 record reflects poor run support and/or inability to pitch deep
- Angels rebuilding may limit wins and quality start opportunities
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Anderson offers no upside over your existing SP depth and his declining production makes him a roster clog rather than an asset.
Luis Ortiz
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Ortiz would be redundant depth at best and doesn't upgrade your rotation.
- Solid K rate with 96 strikeouts in 88.2 IP (9.7 K/9) in 2025
- Established MLB role with 16 starts in 2025
- 375.2 FPTS in 2024 shows backend starter ceiling
- Age 26 means he's entering prime years with known commodity profile
- 4.36 ERA and 1.38 WHIP indicate below-average ratios that hurt fantasy value
- 42 walks in 88.2 IP (4.3 BB/9) is a significant command concern
- 4-9 record suggests limited run support or inability to pitch deep into games
- 2025 FPTS (168.2) is a significant regression from 2024 (375.2)
- Cleveland's rotation depth may limit his opportunities going forward
Suggested Action
Pass on Ortiz - your SP depth is elite and he profiles as a back-end starter with concerning ratios; use roster spot on a position of need like 1B or RP.
Edgar Quero
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher and Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. Adding Quero creates redundancy at a position you're already covered at with a significantly better producer.
- 111 games played in 2025 shows he can handle MLB workload at age 22
- .268 BA with .333 OBP demonstrates solid contact skills for a catcher
- Only 71 strikeouts in 365 ABs (19.5% K rate) is encouraging plate discipline
- Only 5 HR and .356 SLG in 365 ABs - severely limited power output
- Zero stolen bases eliminates speed contribution
- 166.6 FPTS is less than half of Yainer Diaz's production (345.9 FPTS)
- White Sox rebuilding means limited lineup protection and run-scoring opportunities
- No historical data before 2025 to establish trend or upside trajectory
Suggested Action
Pass on Quero - your catcher position is set with Diaz, and Quero's power-deficient profile (5 HR, .689 OPS) doesn't warrant a roster spot over your existing depth.
Andres Gimenez
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists.
- 2022 All-Star season (.297 AVG, 17 HR, 20 SB, .837 OPS) now looks like an outlier
- Stolen base floor remains useful (12 SB in 101 games in 2025)
- Everyday playing time likely with Toronto in 2026
- Severe offensive decline: 2025 slash line of .210/.285/.313 is replacement-level
- Fantasy points dropped from 429.5 (2023) to 345.8 (2024) to 166.1 (2025 partial)
- OPS has declined each year since 2022 (.837 → .712 → .638 → .598)
- Age 27 with declining skills suggests this is who he is now, not a slump
- Power has evaporated: 7 HR in 329 AB in 2025 after 17 HR in 2022
Suggested Action
Pass on Gimenez entirely; your 2B depth is elite and his declining production makes him a roster clog rather than an asset.
Sean Murphy
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher plus Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. Murphy would be redundant depth at a position you've already addressed.
- Power remains present: 16 HR in 94 games (2025), 21 HR in 2023
- Solid walk rate provides some OBP floor (35 BB in 2025)
- Elite defensive catcher ensures playing time in Atlanta
- Severe batting average decline: .199 in 2025, .193 in 2024 after .251 in 2023
- Fantasy production cratered: 165.9 FPTS in 2025, 78.0 in 2024 vs 380.0 in 2023
- Age 31 catcher with two consecutive poor offensive seasons suggests decline, not slump
- Zero stolen bases across entire career limits fantasy upside
- Strikeout rate trending wrong direction (105 K in 291 AB in 2025)
Suggested Action
Pass on Murphy - his declining production and your existing catcher depth with Diaz make this a poor use of a roster spot.
Chris Paddack
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Paddack would be redundant depth at best and actively harmful to your ratios.
- 160.1 FPTS in 2025 is below replacement level for a starting pitcher
- 5.35 ERA and 1.28 WHIP are actively damaging to fantasy ratios
- Only 6 quality starts in 28 starts (21%) indicates extreme inconsistency
- 112 K in 158 IP (6.4 K/9) provides minimal strikeout upside
- Age 29 with extensive injury history (missed most of 2023 with only 13.9 FPTS)
- 5-12 record reflects poor run support AND poor performance
- Detroit's weak lineup limits win potential going forward
- No velocity or stuff improvements to suggest a bounceback
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Paddack is a back-end starter with ratio-killing potential who adds nothing to your already deep pitching staff.
Jonah Heim
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher and Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. Heim would be redundant depth at a position you've already addressed with better options.
- Significant decline from 434 FPTS (2023) to 200 FPTS (2024) to 156 FPTS (2025)
- Power has cratered: 18 HR in 2023 down to 13 in 2024 and 11 in 2025
- OPS collapsed from .755 (2023) to .602 (2024-2025) - two consecutive poor seasons
- Still gets everyday playing time (124-131 games) which provides volume
- Age 30 catcher with two consecutive seasons of declining production - likely in permanent decline phase
- Sub-.270 OBP in both 2024 and 2025 indicates severe contact/plate discipline issues
- Texas lineup context may worsen if team continues to struggle
- No stolen base upside (3 SB in 2025) to offset poor batting numbers
Suggested Action
Pass on Heim entirely - Yainer Diaz outproduced him by 190+ fantasy points in 2025, and Heim's trajectory suggests further decline at age 30-31.
Grant Taylor
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Taylor's 154.3 FPTS and 4.91 ERA don't move the needle and would create redundancy at a low-value position.
- 54 K in 36.2 IP shows solid strikeout upside (13.3 K/9)
- 6 saves and 9 holds indicate some high-leverage usage
- Only 23 years old with MLB experience already
- 4.91 ERA and 1.42 WHIP are below-average ratios that hurt fantasy value
- White Sox are a rebuilding team with unclear bullpen hierarchy
- No track record prior to 2025 - small sample size concerns
- 15 BB in 36.2 IP (3.7 BB/9) shows command issues
- RP is a volatile position with limited fantasy upside unless elite closer
Suggested Action
Pass on Taylor - his ratios are poor, the saves opportunity is uncertain on a bad team, and your RP depth is already adequate with Strahm anchoring.
Nick Gonzales
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists.
- Established MLB role with 94-96 games played in 2024-2025
- Contact-oriented profile with .260-.270 batting average
- Moderate doubles power (18-19 per season)
- Fantasy production declining: 236 FPTS in 2024 dropped to 147.5 FPTS in 2025 (37% decrease)
- Zero stolen bases in 2025 after 5 in 2024 - speed has evaporated
- Poor OBP (.299 in 2025) limits run production upside
- Only 5 HR in 96 games in 2025 - minimal power contribution
- Sub-.700 OPS in 2025 (.661) indicates below-average offensive profile
Suggested Action
Pass on Gonzales - your 2B depth is elite and his declining production makes him a roster clog rather than an asset.
Aaron Civale
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Greene, Leiter, and Misiorowski. Civale would be redundant backend depth at best.
- 2025 FPTS of 145.1 is a significant decline from 316-348 range in prior years
- 4.85 ERA and 1.26 WHIP indicate below-average production
- Only 3 quality starts in 18 starts shows inconsistency
- 88 K in 102 IP (7.8 K/9) is mediocre strikeout upside
- Age 30 with declining production trajectory - not a dynasty asset
- Lost rotation spot (23 games but only 18 starts suggests bullpen usage)
- No clear path to improvement - this is likely his ceiling
- Cubs have better rotation options, limiting his 2026 role
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - your rotation is stacked with higher-upside arms, and Civale's declining production at age 30 offers no dynasty value.
Jose Alvarado
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Alvarado would add depth but not fill a critical need, and his declining production makes him a marginal upgrade at best.
- 7 saves and 5 holds in 28 games shows he's still getting high-leverage opportunities
- 32 strikeouts in 26 IP (11.1 K/9) demonstrates continued swing-and-miss stuff
- Established MLB reliever with closing experience on a competitive Phillies team
- Significant FPTS decline: 281.7 (2023) → 257.6 (2024) → 143.4 (2025 pace) shows concerning trajectory
- Age 30 reliever with volatile performance history - limited upside remaining
- 3.81 ERA and 1.31 WHIP in 2025 are pedestrian for a fantasy-relevant reliever
- Not a guaranteed closer - splits high-leverage work, limiting save upside
Suggested Action
Pass on Alvarado - his declining production and your existing RP depth make him a low-priority target; focus roster spots on higher-upside options.
Luis Gil
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on roster including strong arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Gil would add depth but creates redundancy rather than filling a gap.
- 2024 breakout: 484.2 FPTS was elite SP production, won AL Rookie of the Year
- Strong K potential: 41 Ks in 57 IP (2025) despite struggles
- Yankees rotation spot secured for foreseeable future
- Age 27 entering prime years with established MLB role
- 2025 regression is alarming: 137.1 FPTS through 11 starts vs 484.2 full 2024
- Walk rate spiked to 33 BB in 57 IP (5.2 BB/9) - command issues
- WHIP ballooned to 1.40 from elite 2024 levels
- You previously let him go - suggests prior concerns about sustainability
- No 2023 stats available - limited track record before 2024 breakout
Suggested Action
Monitor Gil's second half to see if command issues resolve before committing a roster spot given your already deep SP corps.
Masataka Yoshida
Roster Fit
DH-only player with declining production offers minimal roster flexibility. Your roster lacks DH depth but has strong OF options who could fill utility spots more effectively.
- Elite contact skills with low strikeout rates (12.8% K% in 2025)
- Consistent batting average floor (.266-.289 range)
- Zero caught stealing in career (8 SB in 2023)
- Severe decline trajectory: FPTS dropped from 462.5 (2023) → 327.8 (2024) → 131.8 (2025 partial)
- 2025 OPS collapsed to .696 with only 4 HR in 55 games - power evaporating at age 32
- DH-only eligibility severely limits roster flexibility
- Walk rate cratered from 6.3% to 5.3% in 2025 - plate discipline declining
- No path to increased playing time - blocked in Boston's crowded lineup
Suggested Action
Pass on Yoshida - his declining power profile and DH-only status make him a roster clog rather than an asset for a contending team.
Tyler O'Neill
Roster Fit
RF is already your deepest position with 6 players including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS). O'Neill would create redundancy rather than fill a need.
- 2024 breakout: 31 HR, 374.8 FPTS in 113 games showed elite power ceiling
- Career-high .847 OPS in 2024 demonstrated what he can do when healthy
- Plus raw power (34 HR in 2021) remains his carrying tool
- 2025 collapse: .199 AVG, .684 OPS, only 130.1 FPTS through 54 games is alarming
- Age 30 with extensive injury history - missed significant time in 2020, 2022, 2023
- High strikeout rate (28%+ career) limits floor when power isn't connecting
- Extreme volatility: FPTS swings from 134 to 374 to 130 in consecutive seasons
- Currently on pace for ~250 FPTS in 2025, well below roster-worthy threshold
Suggested Action
Pass on O'Neill - his 2025 regression, age, injury history, and your RF depth make him a poor fit; monitor only if he shows sustained improvement in second half.
Christopher Morel
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford and depth at corner outfield positions. Morel would be redundant and offers a worse profile than your current options.
- Power potential: 26 HR in 2023, but declined to 21 HR in 2024 and just 11 HR in partial 2025
- Fantasy points trending sharply downward: 372.9 (2023) → 211.2 (2024) → 128.9 (2025)
- Modest speed contribution: 6-10 SB per season
- Now with Tampa Bay after being traded from Cubs, suggesting original team gave up on development
- Severe contact issues: .196 BA in 2024, .219 BA in 2025 with 30%+ K rates
- OPS collapsed from .821 (2023) to .634 (2024) to .684 (2025)
- At age 26, this is likely who he is - a high-strikeout, low-average power bat with declining production
- Playing time not guaranteed in Tampa Bay's crowded outfield situation
- 2025 partial season (105 games) suggests he may have lost playing time or been injured
Suggested Action
Pass on Morel - his declining production, poor contact skills, and your existing LF depth with Langford make him an unnecessary roster addition.
Jake Irvin
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Irvin would be redundant depth at best and offers no upside over your current options.
- 2024 was his career year with 399.2 FPTS, but 2025 showed significant regression to just 126.8 FPTS
- 5.70 ERA and 1.43 WHIP in 2025 indicate a back-end starter at best
- Only 124 strikeouts in 180 IP (6.2 K/9) limits fantasy upside
- 9 quality starts in 33 starts shows inconsistency
- Age 28 with declining performance trajectory - 2024 looks like an outlier, not a breakout
- 195 hits allowed in 180 IP suggests contact issues that won't improve
- Washington's weak lineup means limited win opportunities
- No swing-and-miss stuff to project improvement
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Irvin is a replacement-level fantasy arm with no upside, and your rotation is already deep with better options.
Cade Povich
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on your roster including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Povich would be redundant depth at best and doesn't improve your rotation.
- 118 K in 112.1 IP shows decent strikeout ability (9.5 K/9)
- Secured 20 starts in MLB, demonstrating rotation opportunity in Baltimore
- FPTS jumped from 72.6 (2024) to 126.8 (2025) showing some progression
- 5.21 ERA and 1.50 WHIP are well below replacement level for fantasy
- 125 hits allowed in 112.1 IP indicates significant contact issues
- 43 walks shows poor command that limits upside
- Only 3 quality starts in 20 starts is a major red flag
- 3-8 record reflects poor run support AND poor performance
- You previously let him go - your prior evaluation was correct
Suggested Action
Confirm your prior decision to let Povich go; he's a back-end rotation filler with limited fantasy upside and your SP depth is already strong.
Emerson Hancock
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already elite with Castillo, Greene, Leiter, Imanaga, and emerging arms like Misiorowski and Chad Patrick. Hancock would be redundant depth at best and offers no upgrade path.
- 120.4 FPTS in 2025 across 90 IP shows modest volume but low efficiency
- 4.90 ERA and 1.38 WHIP indicate below-average ratios that hurt fantasy value
- 64 K in 90 IP (6.4 K/9) is well below the threshold for fantasy-relevant starters
- Only 5 quality starts in 16 GS suggests inconsistent performance
- Poor strikeout rate limits upside even if he secures rotation spot
- 4.90 ERA in pitcher-friendly Seattle is a red flag for true talent level
- Seattle rotation is crowded with Gilbert, Kirby, Woo - Hancock may lose spot
- Age 26 with declining prospect shine - this is likely his ceiling
Suggested Action
Pass on Hancock entirely; your SP corps is stacked and his profile offers no upside worth a roster spot.
Miguel Amaya
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz as a strong starting catcher (345.9 FPTS) and Carter Jensen as a developmental backup. Adding Amaya creates redundancy at a position where you're already set.
- 2025 small sample shows improved power (.500 SLG, 4 HR in 96 AB) and batting average (.281)
- 2024 full season was underwhelming: .232 AVG, .644 OPS, only 8 HR in 328 AB
- Zero stolen bases across all three seasons - no speed contribution
- Catcher eligibility provides positional scarcity value
- 2025 hot start based on only 28 games - regression likely to 2024 levels
- Career .235 hitter with mediocre OBP (.297 career) limits fantasy upside
- Cubs have catching depth - playing time not guaranteed long-term
- Age 26 means limited developmental upside remaining
Suggested Action
Pass on Amaya - your catcher situation is solid with Diaz and Jensen, and Amaya's modest offensive profile doesn't warrant a roster spot over other Rule 5 targets.
Yu Darvish
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on your roster including strong arms like Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Adding a declining 39-year-old creates redundancy without upside.
- 2025 ERA of 5.38 represents significant decline from 2023-2024 performance
- Only 3 quality starts in 15 games started in 2025
- FPTS dropped from 288.7 (2023) to 265.3 (2024) to 112.6 (2025 partial)
- Strikeout rate remains decent (68 K in 72 IP) but not elite
- Age 39 heading into 2026 - significant injury and decline risk
- 5.38 ERA in 2025 suggests velocity/stuff degradation
- You previously let him go, indicating prior concerns about his value
- Limited upside even if healthy - ceiling is back-end starter production
Suggested Action
Pass on Darvish and use the roster spot on a younger arm with upside or a position of need like 1B.
Logan O'Hoppe
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher and Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. O'Hoppe would be redundant depth at a position you've already addressed with a superior option.
- 20 HR power in 2024 shows legitimate pop for the catcher position
- Everyday playing time secured with 119-136 games in 2024-2025
- Age 25 entering prime years with established MLB role
- Significant regression in 2025: FPTS dropped from 261.6 to 109.3 (58% decline)
- 2025 slash line collapsed to .213/.258/.371 (OPS .629) - well below replacement level
- Strikeout rate remains problematic (139 K in 423 AB = 33%)
- Walk rate declined to just 5.7% in 2025, limiting OBP floor
- Angels organization provides limited lineup protection and run-scoring environment
Suggested Action
Pass on O'Hoppe - his 2025 collapse is a major red flag, and Yainer Diaz already provides superior production at catcher with more upside.
DL Hall
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as your primary RP asset and 6 total relievers on roster. Hall would add marginal depth but doesn't address any positional need.
- 2025 FPTS of 108.0 is modest but shows improvement over 2024 (51.3)
- 3.49 ERA and 1.06 WHIP in 38.2 IP are respectable middle-relief numbers
- Only 1 hold and 0 saves indicates low-leverage role despite decent ratios
- Age 27 with no clear path to closing role limits upside
- 17 walks in 38.2 IP (3.96 BB/9) shows continued command issues
- Strikeout rate (6.28 K/9) is below average for fantasy-relevant relievers
- Milwaukee bullpen is crowded, limiting high-leverage opportunities
Suggested Action
Pass on Hall unless your league heavily rewards holds or you lose multiple relievers; his ceiling is a low-end RP3 with minimal saves upside.
David Robertson
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Robertson at age 40 with declining production offers no upgrade or meaningful depth to your bullpen.
- 22 K in 17.2 IP shows he can still miss bats (11.2 K/9)
- 10 holds indicates setup role usage in Philadelphia
- Only 2 saves - not in closer role, limiting fantasy upside
- Age 40 entering 2026 season - extreme decline risk
- 4.08 ERA and 1.47 WHIP in 2025 show significant regression from prior years
- FPTS dropped from 386.4 (2024) to 107.6 pace (2025) - alarming decline
- Walk rate concerning (8 BB in 17.2 IP = 4.1 BB/9)
- No guaranteed role or contract for 2026 at his age
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - a 40-year-old reliever with declining ratios and no saves upside has no place in a dynasty roster.
Hayden Birdsong
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RP on roster including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Birdsong's mediocre ratios and swing role don't address a need.
- Solid K rate: 68 K in 65.2 IP (9.3 K/9)
- Hybrid role with 10 starts and 3 holds shows versatility
- 125.6 FPTS in 2024 showed some promise before regression in 2025
- 4.80 ERA and 1.49 WHIP are below-average ratios that hurt fantasy value
- 37 BB in 65.2 IP (5.1 BB/9) indicates significant command issues
- Only 1 quality start in 10 GS suggests he's not a reliable starter
- Role uncertainty: not a closer, not a true starter, limited path to high-value stats
- FPTS dropped from 125.6 to 102.0 year-over-year, trending wrong direction
Suggested Action
Pass on Birdsong; his poor ratios and unclear role make him a low-priority target when you already have RP depth and stronger SP options.
Cole Young
Roster Fit
Creates significant redundancy at 2B where you already roster Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS), and Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS). No positional need exists.
- Only 100.7 FPTS in 77 games (1.31 FPTS/game) - well below replacement level
- Weak slash line: .211/.302/.305 with minimal power (4 HR) and speed (1 SB)
- Decent walk rate (28 BB in 223 AB) shows plate discipline
- Young age (22) playing in MLB is a positive developmental sign
- No historical stats from 2023-2024 to establish trajectory or growth pattern
- Sub-.610 OPS suggests he may not hold MLB roster spot in 2026
- Seattle has middle infield depth that could limit playing time
- Power/speed profile is extremely limited for fantasy relevance
Suggested Action
Pass on Cole Young - your 2B depth is elite and his 2025 production was far below fantasy-relevant thresholds.
Keibert Ruiz
Roster Fit
You already have Yainer Diaz (345.9 FPTS) as your primary catcher and Carter Jensen as a prospect stash. Adding Ruiz would create unnecessary redundancy at a position you're already set at.
- 2023 was his peak: 18 HR, .260 AVG, 381.9 FPTS - but that appears to be an outlier
- 2024 showed significant regression: 13 HR, .229 AVG, 260.4 FPTS in 127 games
- 2025 trending toward disaster: only 2 HR, .247 AVG, .595 OPS through 68 games (100.5 FPTS pace)
- Extremely low walk rate (3.1% in 2025) limits OBP upside
- Zero triples across entire career, minimal stolen base contribution
- Clear downward trajectory in power production (18 HR → 13 HR → 2 HR pace)
- OPS has declined each year: .717 → .619 → .595
- At 27, this is no longer a development story - this is who he is
- Washington's rebuilding status means no lineup protection
- Catcher aging curves are brutal; decline may accelerate
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Ruiz is a declining asset at a position where you're already well-stocked with Yainer Diaz, who outproduced Ruiz by 85+ FPTS in 2025.
Tobias Myers
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Myers offers no upgrade and would create redundancy in a position of adequate depth.
- 407.5 FPTS in 2024 was solid but came in a swingman role with more starts
- 2025 regression: only 99.4 FPTS through 22 games with 3.55 ERA
- Low strikeout rate (38 K in 50.2 IP = 6.75 K/9) limits fantasy upside
- Zero saves, only 1 hold - no path to high-leverage role
- Age 27 with declining production - not a developmental asset
- 1.36 WHIP and poor K rate suggest regression risk continues
- Milwaukee has established bullpen arms ahead of him
- Swingman role means inconsistent usage and limited counting stats
Suggested Action
Pass on Myers - he's a replacement-level swingman with no saves upside and your RP depth is already adequate with Strahm and others.
Ben Lively
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Castillo, Greene, Leiter, and Imanaga. Lively would be redundant depth at best.
- 2024 was a career year with 357.1 FPTS, but he's 33 years old with limited upside
- 2025 showing regression: 3.22 ERA but only 29 K in 44.2 IP (5.8 K/9) is concerning
- Zero quality starts through 9 starts in 2025 despite decent ERA
- WHIP of 1.19 is serviceable but not elite
- Age 33 with declining strikeout rate suggests limited future value
- Career journeyman profile - 2024 appears to be an outlier season
- Cleveland rotation has competition; role not guaranteed long-term
- Low strikeout upside caps fantasy ceiling even in good scenarios
Suggested Action
Pass on Lively - your rotation is stacked with younger, higher-upside arms, and his 2024 breakout looks like a career outlier rather than sustainable production.
A.J. Smith-Shawver
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on your roster including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Smith-Shawver would be redundant depth rather than filling a need, though he could compete for a back-end rotation spot.
- 2025 breakout: 98.2 FPTS in just 9 starts (44.1 IP) projects to ~250+ FPTS over a full season
- 3.86 ERA is respectable for a 23-year-old in his first extended MLB run
- 42 K in 44.1 IP shows solid strikeout ability (8.5 K/9)
- Atlanta rotation has openings with Sale aging and Strider injury history
- 1.42 WHIP driven by 21 walks in 44.1 IP (4.3 BB/9) - command is a major concern
- Only 2 quality starts in 9 outings suggests inconsistency
- You previously let him go, suggesting prior concerns about his ceiling
- Limited track record - 2024 was just 18.6 FPTS, indicating injury or demotion issues
- Competing for rotation spot in Atlanta, not guaranteed innings
Suggested Action
Monitor his spring training and early 2026 role clarity before committing a roster spot given your already deep SP group.
Aaron Nola
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including quality arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Greene (452 FPTS), and Imanaga (416 FPTS). Adding a declining veteran with a 6.01 ERA creates redundancy without upside.
- 2024 was strong (621.6 FPTS) but 2025 shows severe regression: 6.01 ERA, 1.35 WHIP through 17 starts
- Still generating strikeouts (97 K in 94.1 IP) but allowing far too many hits (99) and runs (63 ER)
- Age 32 with declining velocity and command concerns evident in 2025 performance
- 2025 performance suggests significant decline, not a blip - 6.01 ERA is catastrophic for fantasy
- At 32, unlikely to recapture 2023-2024 form; this may be the new baseline
- High hit rate (99 H in 94.1 IP) indicates hittable stuff or declining deception
- 5-10 record despite pitching for competitive Phillies team signals real problems
Suggested Action
Pass on Nola entirely - your SP depth is already strong and his 2025 collapse makes him a roster liability rather than an asset.
Hye Seong Kim
Roster Fit
Creates significant redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need exists.
- 13 SB in 71 games shows useful speed (on pace for ~30 SB over full season)
- Part-time role in LA with only 161 AB through 71 games indicates platoon/utility usage
- 97.1 FPTS in partial season projects to roughly 200 FPTS over full year - below replacement level
- No historical data (2023-2024) to establish track record or growth trajectory
- Poor plate discipline: 7 BB vs 52 K (7.4% BB rate, 32% K rate)
- .699 OPS is below average and limits fantasy ceiling
- Blocked by Gavin Lux and other LAD infield options - unclear path to everyday role
- Age 26 limits upside - this is likely close to his ceiling
Suggested Action
Pass on Kim entirely - your 2B depth is elite and his projected 200 FPTS would be your worst middle infielder by a wide margin.
Javier Assad
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Leiter, Misiorowski, and established starters like Castillo and Greene. Assad would be redundant depth at best.
- Solid 2023-2024 production with 300+ FPTS in back-to-back seasons
- Durable innings eater: consistent starter role with Cubs
- Modest strikeout rate (23 K in 37 IP in 2025 = 5.6 K/9) limits upside
- ERA around 3.65 in 2025 is serviceable but not elite
- Age 28 with limited ceiling - this is likely his peak performance window
- Low strikeout rate caps fantasy upside in points leagues
- Cubs rotation has competition; role could fluctuate
- No elite pitch or swing-and-miss stuff to project improvement
Suggested Action
Pass on Assad - your rotation is already stacked with higher-upside arms, and his back-end starter profile doesn't move the needle for your roster.
Ha-seong Kim
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS rostered (Bichette, Swanson, Tovar, Holliday, Lombard) making Kim completely redundant. There is zero positional need here.
- Career-best 476 FPTS in 2023 with 17 HR/38 SB combo
- Solid OBP contributor (.330-.351 in peak years) with walk rates
- Multi-position eligibility potential adds flexibility
- Proven 20+ SB upside when healthy and playing full-time
- 2025 stats show significant decline: only 90.6 FPTS in 48 games, .234/.304/.345 slash line
- Now 30 years old with declining power (5 HR in 171 AB) and speed (6 SB)
- Moved from San Diego to Atlanta - unclear playing time path with Braves roster
- OPS dropped from .749 (2023) to .700 (2024) to .649 (2025) - clear downward trend
- Injury concerns evident from limited 2025 games played
Suggested Action
Pass on Kim entirely - you have elite SS depth and his declining production at age 30 doesn't warrant a roster spot even as depth.
Dylan Beavers
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford and Colton Cowser covering LF/CF, plus 6 RF-eligible players. Beavers would be redundant depth rather than filling a need, though his Baltimore connection with Cowser is notable.
- Strong plate discipline: 26 BB in 110 AB (23.6% walk rate) driving solid .375 OBP
- Decent power profile: 4 HR, .400 SLG in limited sample (35 games)
- .775 OPS in MLB debut shows he can handle big league pitching
- 6'5" frame suggests potential for more power development
- Only 35 games of MLB data - extremely small sample size
- No stats available for 2023-2024 to evaluate development trajectory
- 32.7% K-rate is concerning despite good walk rate
- Unclear path to everyday playing time in Baltimore's crowded outfield
- 88.3 FPTS in 35 games projects to roughly 250-280 over full season - marginal fantasy value
Suggested Action
Monitor Beavers' spring training and early 2026 role clarity before committing a roster spot, as your outfield depth is already strong.
Luisangel Acuna
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott, Jackson Holliday, and Ozzie Albies. No positional need exists for another middle infielder.
- 16 stolen bases in 95 games shows speed value
- Elite SB efficiency (16-for-17) indicates green light
- Young age (23) with MLB experience
- Zero home runs in 175 ABs in 2025 - severe power regression from 2024 small sample
- .234 BA / .567 OPS in 2025 is replacement-level offense
- Part-time role (175 ABs in 95 games) suggests platoon/bench player
- 2024 hot start (.966 OPS in 39 ABs) was clearly unsustainable
- 84.4 FPTS over 95 games projects to ~140 FPTS full season - below replacement
Suggested Action
Pass on Acuna - his speed-only profile and lack of playing time path make him a poor fit for a roster already stacked at 2B with three quality options.
Sean Manaea
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including quality arms like Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Manaea would be redundant depth at best and doesn't upgrade your rotation.
- 2024 was a career year with 592.3 FPTS - likely an outlier at age 32
- 2025 showing significant regression: 5.64 ERA, 0 quality starts in 12 GS
- Strikeout rate remains decent (75 K in 60.2 IP) but run prevention has collapsed
- 33 years old entering 2026 - declining phase of career
- 2025 performance (79.5 FPTS through 15 games) projects to ~350 FPTS full season - below your current SP depth
- Age 33 with declining peripherals suggests 2024 was the peak, not the baseline
- 5.64 ERA and zero quality starts indicate he may lose rotation spot or move to bullpen
- No upside - ceiling is backend starter, floor is waiver wire fodder
Suggested Action
Pass on Manaea entirely - your SP depth is already strong and his 2025 regression makes him a liability rather than an asset.
Michael Massey
Roster Fit
Creates complete redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS), and Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS). No positional need whatsoever.
- 2024 showed modest power (14 HR in 100 games) with .742 OPS
- 2025 has been a disaster: .581 OPS, only 3 HR in 77 games through partial season
- Career-low walk rate (3.4% in 2025) indicates approach issues
- No stolen base contribution (2 SB in 2025)
- Severe 2025 regression suggests 2024 was the outlier, not the baseline
- Age 27 with declining production - this is not a development story
- 78.6 FPTS in 2025 projects to ~150 full season - replacement level
- Royals may reduce his playing time if struggles continue
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Massey offers nothing your roster needs and his 2025 collapse makes him a liability even as depth.
Colby Thomas
Roster Fit
Creates significant redundancy at RF where you already have 6 players including Wilyer Abreu ($28, 358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. No positional need exists here.
- 6 HR in 120 AB shows some pop (18 HR pace over 400 AB)
- Age 24 and already at MLB level with Oakland
- 75.2 FPTS in 49 games suggests part-time role
- Extremely high strikeout rate (40.8% K rate - 49 K in 120 AB)
- Poor plate discipline with only 7 walks (.267 OBP)
- .225 AVG will hurt in most formats
- No historical data before 2025 - unclear development trajectory
- Oakland's rebuilding roster means playing time could be volatile
- Sub-.700 OPS indicates below-average offensive production
Suggested Action
Pass on Thomas - your RF depth is already excessive, and his poor contact/discipline profile makes him a fringe MLB player with limited fantasy upside.
David Festa
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Festa would be redundant depth at best and doesn't crack your rotation.
- 53 K in 53.1 IP shows adequate strikeout ability (8.9 K/9)
- Only 25 years old with MLB experience already
- Twins rotation has openings which could mean opportunity
- 5.40 ERA and 1.275 WHIP in 2025 are below-average MLB numbers
- Only 1 quality start in 10 starts indicates inconsistency
- 19 walks in 53.1 IP (3.2 BB/9) shows command issues
- 70.1 FPTS in 2025 is well below your worst keeper SP (Misiorowski at 180.1)
- Declining fantasy production from 98.3 FPTS (2024) to 70.1 FPTS (2025)
Suggested Action
Pass on Festa entirely - your SP corps is stacked and he projects as a back-end starter at best with concerning peripherals.
Max Muncy
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with a $26 salary, making Muncy redundant at the position. However, Riley's 2025 FPTS (248.8) was disappointing, so Muncy could serve as depth or trade bait.
- Elite plate discipline: 64 BB in 100 games (2025), career OBP consistently above .330
- Solid power: 19 HR in 100 games (2025), career peak of 36 HR in 2021 and 2023
- Strong OPS (.846 in 2025) despite low batting average (.243)
- Durable when healthy: 135+ games in multiple seasons historically
- Age discrepancy: Listed as 23 but career stats date back to 2018 - this appears to be veteran Max Muncy (actual age ~34), not a prospect
- Only 65.2 FPTS in 2025 over 100 games is concerning for a full-time player
- Batting average liability (.192-.250 range) hurts in categories leagues
- 2024 limited to 73 games - durability concerns at his actual age
- No fantasy points data provided for 2024 despite playing 73 games
Suggested Action
Monitor Muncy's playing time situation with Oakland; only pursue if Riley is traded or you need a cheap 3B/1B backup with power upside.
Blake Treinen
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Treinen would add minimal value as a declining veteran reliever with no clear path to high-leverage work.
- 2024 was a career resurgence (283.3 FPTS) but 2025 shows significant regression
- 5.40 ERA and 1.84 WHIP in 2025 indicate lost effectiveness
- 36 K in 26.2 IP shows strikeout ability still exists (12.1 K/9)
- 19 BB in 26.2 IP is a major red flag (6.4 BB/9)
- Age 37 entering 2026 - declining phase of career
- 2025 stats show dramatic decline from 2024 bounce-back year
- Walk rate has ballooned, suggesting command issues
- Only 2 saves in 2025 - not in closer role despite Dodgers' bullpen needs
- 7 losses as a reliever indicates high-leverage failures
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Treinen is a 37-year-old reliever in clear decline with no saves upside and your RP depth is already adequate.
Sal Stewart
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 player at 1B (likely Austin Riley sliding over), creating a clear positional need. Stewart could fill this gap if he secures regular playing time in Cincinnati.
- Strong power showing: 5 HR in just 55 AB (1 HR per 11 AB pace)
- .545 SLG and .839 OPS in small MLB sample indicates legitimate pop
- Only 22 years old with corner infield eligibility
- Cincinnati's lineup could provide favorable run-producing opportunities
- Extremely small sample size (18 games) - unsustainable HR rate likely
- Poor plate discipline: only 3 BB vs 15 K (5.2% walk rate, 27.3% K rate)
- .293 OBP is concerning for sustained fantasy value
- No stolen base upside (0 SB in sample)
- 1B-only eligibility limits roster flexibility
- Playing time not guaranteed - Reds have other options at 1B/3B
Suggested Action
Add to watchlist and monitor spring training reports; only pursue if Cincinnati commits to him as everyday starter, as part-time 1B with poor OBP offers limited fantasy upside.
Drew Gilbert
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF on your roster including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Gilbert creates pure redundancy at an already overcrowded position.
- Only 56.8 FPTS in 39 games (2025) - extremely low production
- .190 AVG with .598 OPS in 100 ABs shows significant struggles at MLB level
- 3 HR and 1 SB in limited action - minimal counting stat contribution
- 20 K in 100 AB (20% K rate) with only 7 walks shows poor plate discipline
- No stat history prior to 2025 - limited track record to evaluate
- Sub-.250 OBP indicates he may not hold an everyday role
- Age 25 with poor MLB debut suggests limited upside ceiling
- Moved from Houston to SF system - organizational instability
- You previously let him go - your prior evaluation was correct
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Gilbert's poor 2025 debut, your existing RF depth (6 players), and his lack of a clear path to playing time make him a roster clog rather than an asset.
Michael Kopech
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as a quality RP and 6 total relievers on roster. Kopech would add marginal depth at a position that's not a priority need.
- Elite strikeout potential when healthy (12 K in 11 IP in 2025)
- Strong 2024 season with 321.1 FPTS suggests upside exists
- Now with Dodgers, a contending team that could use him in high-leverage spots
- Alarming 1.73 WHIP in 2025 driven by 13 walks in just 11 innings - severe command issues
- Extensive injury history including Tommy John surgery has limited career innings
- Age 29 with only one productive fantasy season (2024) - volatile track record
- Zero saves in 2025 despite 6 holds - not in closer role, limiting fantasy ceiling
- FPTS dropped from 321 (2024) to 55.5 (2025 partial) - concerning regression
Suggested Action
Pass on Kopech - his command issues and injury history make him a risky add when you already have adequate RP depth and more pressing roster needs.
Tony Gonsolin
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already elite with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Gonsolin would be redundant depth at best and doesn't upgrade any rotation spot.
- Only 55 FPTS in 2025 through 7 starts - well below replacement level
- 5.00 ERA and 1.42 WHIP indicate significant regression from 2023 form
- 38 K in 36 IP shows strikeout ability still present (9.5 K/9)
- 18 BB in 36 IP is alarming (4.5 BB/9) - control issues post-injury
- Age 31 pitcher coming off major elbow surgery (Tommy John) - durability is a major concern
- Missing entire 2024 season - no data to assess recovery trajectory
- Walk rate has ballooned, suggesting mechanical issues or diminished stuff
- Dodgers have deep rotation - may not get consistent starts even when healthy
- Only 1 quality start in 7 attempts shows inability to go deep into games
Suggested Action
Pass on Gonsolin - your rotation is stacked and he's a 31-year-old post-TJ pitcher with poor 2025 results who doesn't move the needle for your team.
Brady House
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B producing 248.8 FPTS, and House's 53.7 FPTS with a .574 OPS offers no upgrade. This creates redundancy at a position you don't need to address.
- Only 53.7 fantasy points in 73 games (0.74 FPTS/game) - well below replacement level
- 4 HR and 5 SB in 261 AB shows minimal power/speed contribution
- 78 strikeouts vs 8 walks (9.75 K/BB ratio) indicates severe plate discipline issues
- .252 OBP is catastrophic - limits run production and lineup placement
- .322 SLG with only 4 HR suggests power hasn't translated to MLB
- No statistical history before 2025 makes trend analysis impossible
- At 22, still young but 2025 performance shows he's not ready for everyday role
Suggested Action
Pass on House - you previously let him go for good reason, and his 2025 MLB debut confirmed he needs significant development before providing fantasy value.
Ronny Mauricio
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with 248.8 FPTS despite a down year, plus multiple SS-eligible players who could slide over. Mauricio creates redundancy at a position you're already covered.
- Only 52.4 FPTS in 61 games (2025) - projects to ~140 FPTS over full season, well below replacement level
- .226 AVG with .663 OPS in 2025 shows significant offensive struggles at MLB level
- 6 HR and 4 SB in 168 AB provides minimal category contribution
- 32% K-rate is concerning for a contact-dependent profile
- Missing 2024 data entirely - likely injury or demotion, significant red flag
- At 24, he's no longer a high-upside prospect; this is closer to his ceiling
- Mets have Brett Baty and Mark Vientos blocking 3B path, unclear playing time
- Power hasn't developed as expected for his 6'4" frame (166 lbs is very light)
Suggested Action
Pass on Mauricio - his 2025 performance shows a below-average bat with no clear path to everyday playing time, and you have no positional need at 3B.
Heston Kjerstad
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford and Colton Cowser covering LF/CF, plus 6 RF-eligible players. Kjerstad would be redundant depth at a position you're already stacked at.
- Former #2 overall pick (2020) with pedigree, but has not translated to MLB success
- 2025 slash line of .192/.240/.327 (54 games) is well below replacement level
- OPS dropped from .745 in 2024 to .566 in 2025 - trending wrong direction
- Limited power output (4 HR in 156 AB in 2025) despite corner OF profile
- Only 42.6 FPTS in 2025 across 54 games - minimal fantasy contribution
- 28.8% K-rate with only 3.8% walk rate in 2025 shows poor plate discipline
- Lost significant playing time in Baltimore despite team need - organizational red flag
- History of myocarditis (2021) delayed development; now 26 with limited track record
- Blocked in Baltimore by Santander, Cowser, Mullins, O'Hearn - unclear path to everyday role
- Three years of MLB data all show sub-.750 OPS - this may be who he is
Suggested Action
Pass on Kjerstad - the pedigree is enticing but three years of poor MLB production, declining trends, and your existing OF depth make him an easy skip.
Michael Toglia
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 1B player, indicating a positional need. However, Toglia's severe regression in 2025 and contact issues make him a poor solution to that gap.
- 25 HR power in 2024 (309 FPTS) showed upside in Coors Field
- Added 10 SB in 2024, rare for 1B-only player
- Coors Field home park provides batting average and counting stat floor
- Catastrophic 2025 regression: .189 AVG, .258 OBP, .611 OPS through 88 games
- 132 strikeouts in 306 AB (43% K rate) is unsustainable for fantasy value
- 2025 FPTS of 42.1 is replacement-level production
- At age 27, this is not a development issue - this is who he is
- Colorado may seek alternatives at 1B given his struggles
Suggested Action
Pass on Toglia and target a more reliable 1B option; his 2024 looks like a Coors-fueled outlier rather than a baseline.
Matthew Lugo
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall with 6 RF and 2 LF. Lugo would be redundant depth at a position you're already covered.
- Flashed some power with 4 HR in 69 AB (10.4% HR/FB proxy)
- OPS of .707 shows some offensive upside
- Age 24 means he's entering prime years
- Zero walks in 69 AB is a massive red flag - .243 OBP is unplayable
- 34.8% K-rate (24 K in 69 AB) suggests major contact issues
- Only 34.8 FPTS in 31 games projects to ~112 FPTS over a full season - well below replacement level
- No stolen bases despite CF profile limits fantasy ceiling
- Limited track record - no 2023/2024 data available to establish baseline
- Part-time role (31 games) suggests Angels don't view him as everyday player
Suggested Action
Pass on Lugo - his poor plate discipline and part-time role make him a fringe MLB player, and you have no CF need with Simpson and Cowser already rostered.
Anthony Santander
Roster Fit
Your roster lacks a true DH-only slot filler, but Santander's 2025 collapse (.175 AVG, .565 OPS through 54 games) makes him a liability rather than an asset. You have adequate OF depth with Langford, Cowser, Abreu, and Caglianone.
- 2024 career year: 44 HR, 640.9 FPTS was elite production
- Consistent 28-44 HR power from 2022-2024 (33, 28, 44)
- Signed 5-year/$92.5M deal with Toronto, guaranteed playing time
- 2025 catastrophic decline: .175 AVG, 6 HR in 54 games, 32.3 FPTS pace is replacement level
- Age 31 with DH-only eligibility limits roster flexibility
- 61 K in 194 AB (31.4% K rate) suggests mechanical or health issues
- OPS dropped from .814 to .565 - not a small sample fluke at 54 games
- No stolen base contribution (0 SB in 2025)
Suggested Action
Pass on Santander entirely; his 2025 collapse at age 31 signals a potential permanent decline, and DH-only players need to mash to justify roster spots.
Yanquiel Fernandez
Roster Fit
DH-only designation severely limits roster flexibility, and your roster already has 6 RF-eligible players plus multiple corner outfielders who could fill DH slots. No positional need exists.
- Only 30.2 FPTS in 52 games (0.58 FPTS/game) - well below replacement level
- 4 HR in 138 AB shows some raw power potential
- .613 OPS is significantly below MLB average
- Age 22 with MLB experience is a positive developmental marker
- 31.9% strikeout rate (44 K in 138 AB) indicates major contact issues
- DH-only limits fantasy utility and real-life roster flexibility
- Colorado organization context: Coors Field helps, but team may not commit to development
- No stolen base upside (0 SB) in a speed-valued fantasy environment
- Missing 2023-2024 stats make trajectory assessment difficult
Suggested Action
Pass on Fernandez - the DH-only profile combined with poor 2025 production and your existing outfield depth makes this an easy skip.
Logan Allen
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo (533 FPTS), Greene (452 FPTS), and Imanaga (416 FPTS). Allen would be redundant depth at best.
- 260.3 FPTS in 2025 ranks well below your top 5 starters
- 29 starts shows durability and rotation security
- 4.25 ERA and 1.40 WHIP are below-average ratios
- 122 K in 156.2 IP (7.0 K/9) is uninspiring strikeout rate
- No historical data before 2025 - unclear if this is a breakout or career year
- 62 walks (3.6 BB/9) indicates command issues
- 8-11 record despite 29 starts suggests poor run support or inability to pitch deep
- 157 hits allowed in 156.2 IP - gets hit hard
- Age unknown - cannot assess developmental trajectory
Suggested Action
Pass on Allen - he's a back-end starter who doesn't crack your rotation and offers no upside over your existing SP depth.
Spencer Arrighetti
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on roster including strong arms like Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Arrighetti would be depth at best and creates redundancy rather than filling a need.
- 285.7 FPTS in 2024 shows legitimate MLB production as a rookie starter
- Secured rotation spot in Houston with 7 starts in early 2025
- 31 K in 35.1 IP (7.9 K/9) demonstrates strikeout upside
- 2025 regression is alarming: 5.35 ERA, 1.415 WHIP through 7 starts
- Walk rate spiked significantly (20 BB in 35.1 IP = 5.1 BB/9)
- 1-5 record suggests quality start consistency issues
- Houston rotation is competitive - role not guaranteed long-term
- No draft pedigree data available to assess ceiling
Suggested Action
Monitor Arrighetti's command improvements through mid-season; only pursue if a SP injury creates roster need or his peripherals stabilize significantly.
Garrett Mitchell
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall with Abreu, Langford, and Caissie. Mitchell would be redundant depth at a position you're already covered.
- 2024 showed upside: .255/.342/.469 with 8 HR and 11 SB in just 69 games
- Plus speed tool with 23 career SB and 8-for-8 in 2022
- Solid power/speed combo when healthy (0.811 OPS in 2024)
- Severe 2025 regression: .206/.286/.294 through 25 games with ZERO home runs
- Chronic injury history - has never played more than 69 games in a season
- High strikeout rate (36.8% K% in 2025, 36.2% in 2024) limits floor
- Already 27 years old with only 141 career MLB games - limited track record
- Brewers have crowded OF situation limiting his path to everyday at-bats
Suggested Action
Pass on Mitchell - his injury history, 2025 collapse, and your existing CF depth make him an unnecessary gamble for a roster spot.
Carson Williams
Roster Fit
You already have 5 shortstops including Bo Bichette (570.8 FPTS), Dansby Swanson (421.2 FPTS), Ezequiel Tovar, Jackson Holliday, and George Lombard. Carson Williams would create significant redundancy at a position where you're already overloaded.
- 5 HR in 99 AB shows some raw power potential for a 22-year-old SS
- Already reached MLB level with Tampa Bay, suggesting organizational belief
- Young age (22) provides long-term upside if he develops
- Brutal .172 AVG and .219 OBP in 32 MLB games - severe contact issues
- 44 strikeouts in 99 AB (44.4% K rate) is unsustainable and alarming
- Only 17.9 FPTS in 2025 - minimal fantasy production
- No historical stat data (2023-2024) to establish development trajectory
- Tampa Bay's crowded infield may limit playing time in 2026
Suggested Action
Pass on Williams given your SS depth and his poor 2025 performance; monitor if he shows significant improvement in spring training or early 2026.
Alexis Diaz
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm as a quality RP and 6 total relievers on roster. Diaz would add redundancy at a position of relative strength while offering minimal upside given his 2025 collapse.
- 2023 was elite (478.4 FPTS) as Reds closer with dominant ratios
- 2024 showed significant decline (284.5 FPTS) with reduced saves
- 2025 has been disastrous: 8.15 ERA, 1.53 WHIP in 17.2 IP
- Lost closer role, now in middle relief with only 4 holds
- K rate still decent (17 K in 17.2 IP) but walks (12 BB) are alarming
- Age 29 reliever with clear velocity/stuff decline trajectory
- Traded from CIN to ATL mid-season, suggesting Reds gave up on him
- Walk rate explosion (6.1 BB/9) indicates command issues
- No path to saves in Atlanta with Raisel Iglesias entrenched
- Fantasy points dropped from 478 → 284 → 16 over three years
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Diaz is a 29-year-old reliever in freefall with no saves path and deteriorating ratios; your RP depth is adequate without taking on this risk.
Jordan Wicks
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Wicks would add marginal depth at best to an already adequate bullpen situation.
- 2023 showed promise with 82.9 FPTS, but that was likely as a starter with more innings
- Moved to bullpen role in 2024-2025 with drastically reduced value (22.8 and 11.1 FPTS)
- Low walk rate (1 BB in 14.1 IP in 2025) shows some control
- Only 1 save and 1 hold in 8 appearances - not in high-leverage role
- 6.28 ERA and 1.74 WHIP in 2025 indicate poor performance
- 24 hits allowed in 14.1 IP is alarming contact rate
- Transition from starter to reliever has not gone well
- No clear path to saves or high-leverage innings in Cubs bullpen
- You previously let him go - your prior evaluation was correct
Suggested Action
Pass on Wicks entirely; his declining production and lack of a defined role make him a roster clog rather than an asset.
Ben Joyce
Roster Fit
You have 6 RPs currently rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Joyce would add depth but doesn't fill a critical gap, and his role uncertainty limits immediate value.
- Elite velocity (throws 100+ mph consistently) creates strikeout upside
- 189.3 FPTS in 2024 shows legitimate fantasy production when healthy and in a defined role
- High-leverage usage (holds) indicates manager trust in key situations
- 2025 sample is tiny (4.1 IP) with concerning 6.23 ERA and only 1 K - possible injury or mechanical issues
- Angels bullpen hierarchy is unclear; no clear path to saves
- Relievers are inherently volatile - one bad stretch can tank value
- Missing 2025 data context - unclear if injured or demoted
Suggested Action
Monitor Joyce's health and role through May; if he regains setup/closer role with Angels, consider adding as RP depth.
Sawyer Gipson-Long
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Gipson-Long would be redundant depth with minimal upside given his poor 2025 performance.
- Showed promise in 2023 with 72.4 FPTS in limited action
- Decent K rate (26 K in 31.1 IP) suggests some swing-and-miss ability
- Low walk rate (6 BB in 31.1 IP) indicates solid command
- Brutal 7.18 ERA in 2025 across 31.1 IP - getting hit hard
- Age 27 with no clear path to high-leverage role in Detroit
- 0-2 record with 0 saves despite 8 appearances - not trusted in key spots
- Missing 2024 data entirely - unclear what happened that season
- 34 hits allowed in 31.1 IP shows hittable stuff at MLB level
Suggested Action
Pass on Gipson-Long - he's a 27-year-old reliever with poor results and no clear role; your RP depth is already adequate with Strahm and others.
Jacob Melton
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall. Melton would be redundant and offers less upside than your current options.
- 7 stolen bases in 32 games shows speed tool is real
- 25 years old with MLB experience, not a raw prospect
- CF eligibility provides defensive value in real baseball
- Brutal .157 AVG and .419 OPS in 70 MLB at-bats is alarming
- 29 strikeouts vs 6 walks (41% K rate) suggests major contact issues
- Zero home runs and zero doubles - no power production whatsoever
- Only 1.2 fantasy points in 2025 - essentially replacement level
- No historical stat data available to assess development trajectory
- Crowded Houston outfield limits path to everyday playing time
Suggested Action
Pass on Melton entirely - his 2025 MLB performance was dismal and your CF/OF depth is already strong with higher-upside options.
Liam Hendriks
Roster Fit
You already have Matt Strahm and 5 other RPs on roster. Hendriks at 36 with a 6.59 ERA and no saves/holds offers no upgrade to your bullpen depth.
- Only 1.1 FPTS in 2025 across 14 games - minimal fantasy contribution
- 6.59 ERA and 1.39 WHIP indicate significant decline from elite closer days
- Zero saves and zero holds despite 13.2 IP - no high-leverage role secured
- 12 K in 13.2 IP shows some strikeout ability remains (7.9 K/9)
- Age 36 with recent Tommy John surgery recovery - durability is major concern
- Lost closer role in Boston, unclear path back to saves
- Missing 2024 data entirely suggests extended absence/limited action
- Velocity and stuff likely diminished post-surgery at this age
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Hendriks is a declining veteran reliever with no clear path to fantasy-relevant production in 2026.
Nestor Cortes
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already strong with 14 pitchers including Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Cortes would be redundant depth at best and doesn't upgrade any rotation spot.
- 2024 was his best season with 470.6 FPTS, but that appears to be an outlier
- 2023 showed only 138.5 FPTS indicating inconsistency
- 2025 has been disastrous: 6.29 ERA, 1.63 WHIP through 8 starts
- Strikeout rate declining (29 K in 34.1 IP = 7.6 K/9)
- Age 31 with declining stuff - not a dynasty asset
- 2025 peripherals (1.63 WHIP, 20 BB in 34.1 IP) suggest real regression, not bad luck
- Moved to San Diego but hasn't benefited from pitcher-friendly park
- Command issues emerging with 5.2 BB/9 in 2025
- Only 1.0 FPTS in 2025 column suggests he may have been dropped mid-season or data is incomplete
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Cortes is a declining 31-year-old with poor 2025 results who doesn't fit your already deep rotation.
Christian Scott
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on roster including strong arms like Castillo, Greene, Imanaga, and Leiter. Scott would add depth but creates redundancy rather than filling a need.
- 80.4 FPTS in 2024 suggests limited MLB innings (likely ~60-70 IP based on typical SP scoring)
- Age 26 means he's entering prime years with limited development runway remaining
- Mets rotation has competition but also opportunity if he performs
- 0.0 FPTS in 2025 indicates injury, demotion, or no MLB action - major red flag
- No 2023 stats available makes trend analysis impossible
- No physical/draft data suggests limited scouting profile visibility
- Crowded Mets rotation with Severino, Manaea, Megill competing for spots
Suggested Action
Monitor Scott's health status and spring training performance before committing a roster spot given your already deep SP corps.
Austin Overn
Roster Fit
You already have Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser at CF, plus strong OF depth overall. Overn would be redundant and offers no upgrade path.
- 22-year-old CF in the Orioles system with MLB roster status
- Zero fantasy points in 2025 suggests minimal or no MLB playing time
- No historical stats available to evaluate offensive or defensive profile
- Complete lack of statistical track record makes evaluation nearly impossible
- No draft background information suggests undrafted free agent with lower pedigree
- Blocked in Baltimore behind established OF options (Cowser, Mullins, Santander)
- 0.0 FPTS in 2025 indicates he's not getting meaningful opportunities
Suggested Action
Pass on Overn entirely; there's no evidence he'll contribute in 2026 and your CF/OF depth is already strong.
Theo Gillen
Roster Fit
You already have CF covered with Chandler Simpson and Colton Cowser, plus multiple OF-eligible players. Gillen would create redundancy at a position you don't need to address.
- 20-year-old CF prospect in Tampa Bay system
- Listed at MLB level but 0.0 FPTS in 2025 suggests minimal/no actual MLB playing time
- No historical stats available to evaluate performance trajectory
- Zero statistical history available - complete unknown on offensive or defensive profile
- No MLB ID suggests he may not be on the 40-man roster or have meaningful MLB experience
- Tampa Bay's OF depth (Lowe, Arozarena successors, etc.) creates unclear path to playing time
- Age 20 with no stats indicates he's likely years away from consistent MLB contribution
- Missing draft information and physical details (bats/throws unknown) are red flags for evaluation
Suggested Action
Pass on Gillen entirely - the complete lack of statistical data combined with your existing CF depth makes this a non-starter for 2026 roster consideration.
Termarr Johnson
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott, Jackson Holliday, and Ozzie Albies locked in. No positional need exists for another middle infielder.
- Former 4th overall pick (2022) with elite bat-to-ball skills and advanced plate discipline
- Only 21 years old with significant upside as a contact-oriented hitter
- Reached MLB level in 2025 but posted 0.0 FPTS indicating minimal playing time
- Zero fantasy production in 2025 despite MLB call-up suggests limited role
- No historical stat data available to evaluate development trajectory
- 5'8" frame and 2B-only profile limits positional flexibility
- Pittsburgh's crowded infield (Hayes, Cruz, Newman) may block consistent playing time in 2026
- Complete lack of stats makes projection highly speculative
Suggested Action
Monitor Johnson's spring training performance and opening day roster status before committing a roster spot, as your 2B depth is already elite.
Tink Hence
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extensive with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Leiter and Misiorowski. Hence would be redundant depth rather than filling a need.
- Top Cardinals pitching prospect with elite strikeout potential (mid-90s fastball, plus slider)
- Made MLB debut in 2025 but logged 0.0 FPTS suggesting minimal/no innings
- Age 23 is reasonable for SP development timeline
- Zero fantasy production in 2025 despite MLB call-up indicates limited opportunity or injury
- No historical stat data available makes evaluation highly speculative
- Cardinals rotation is crowded (Sonny Gray, Miles Mikolas, Kyle Gibson) limiting 2026 path
- Injury history has been a concern throughout minors (elbow issues)
Suggested Action
Monitor Hence's spring training performance and Cardinals rotation moves, but don't prioritize given your deep SP corps and his uncertain 2026 role.
Deyvison De Los Santos
Roster Fit
Your roster shows only 1 1B player (likely Austin Riley or another player with 1B eligibility), so there is a positional need. However, De Los Santos has shown zero fantasy production (0.0 FPTS in 2025) and lacks any meaningful stat history to project value.
- 22 years old with MLB experience - youth is an asset
- Currently on MLB roster with Miami, suggesting some organizational belief
- 1B-only profile limits positional flexibility
- Zero fantasy points in 2025 despite being at MLB level - major red flag
- No historical stats available to project future performance
- Miami is a rebuilding team with unclear path to everyday at-bats
- 1B is a premium offensive position - needs to hit to have value
- Complete lack of data makes any projection speculative
Suggested Action
Pass on De Los Santos due to zero production evidence and lack of stat history; monitor if he earns consistent playing time in Miami, but there are likely better Rule 5 options to address your 1B need.
Henry Baez
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extensive with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Adding another unproven arm creates redundancy without addressing roster needs.
- 23-year-old SP currently at MLB level with Oakland
- Listed on 40-man roster (Rule 5 eligible status)
- Young arm with theoretical upside given age/level combination
- Zero fantasy points in 2025 despite MLB roster status - indicates no meaningful playing time
- No historical stats available across any season - complete unknown
- No draft background data suggests undrafted free agent with limited pedigree
- Oakland's rebuilding status means opportunity exists, yet he hasn't capitalized
- 175 lbs at 6'3" is a slight frame for SP durability concerns
Suggested Action
Pass on Baez entirely - with zero production data and a roster already loaded with SP depth including multiple high-upside young arms (Leiter, Misiorowski, Patrick, Caminiti), there's no justification to add another complete unknown.
Cam Collier
Roster Fit
You already have Austin Riley at 3B with 248.8 FPTS in 2025, plus multiple MI options. Collier would be redundant depth at a position you're covered at, though Riley's down year creates some uncertainty.
- Former top prospect (1st round 2022, 18th overall)
- Called up to MLB in 2025 but 0.0 FPTS suggests extremely limited playing time or late-season cup of coffee
- 21 years old with plus raw power potential
- Reds have shown willingness to promote young talent aggressively
- Zero fantasy production in 2025 despite MLB call-up is a major red flag
- No historical stat data available makes evaluation highly speculative
- Blocked by established MLB players in Cincinnati's infield
- Swing-and-miss concerns have followed him through minors
- May need another full year of AAA development before consistent MLB role
Suggested Action
Monitor Collier's spring training and early 2026 role clarity before committing a roster spot; your 3B situation with Riley is adequate for now.
Quinn Mathews
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Adding another speculative arm creates redundancy rather than filling a need.
- 25-year-old lefty with MLB organization (STL)
- 6'5" frame suggests projection for durability
- Made MLB roster in 2025 but recorded 0.0 fantasy points - indicates minimal/no playing time
- Zero fantasy points in 2025 despite being on MLB roster - suggests injury, demotion, or extremely limited role
- No historical stat data available - impossible to evaluate performance trajectory
- No draft background information - unclear pedigree or development path
- Age 25 with no meaningful MLB production is a red flag for upside
- Cardinals have established rotation - path to consistent innings unclear
Suggested Action
Pass on Mathews - your SP depth is elite and this player shows no evidence of 2026 impact; use roster spot on a position of need like 1B or a higher-upside prospect.
Juaron Watts-Brown
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extensive with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Misiorowski and Leiter. Adding another speculative arm with zero track record creates unnecessary redundancy.
- 23-year-old SP in Baltimore organization
- Listed at MLB level but 0.0 FPTS in 2025 suggests minimal/no actual MLB action
- No historical stats available to evaluate performance trajectory
- Zero statistical history makes evaluation nearly impossible
- No MLB ID suggests limited prospect profile visibility
- 0.0 FPTS in 2025 despite being 'MLB level' indicates no meaningful contribution
- Unknown physical attributes and draft background provide no context for projection
- Baltimore has pitching depth that may block development opportunities
Suggested Action
Pass on Watts-Brown entirely; your SP depth is already strong and there's no evidence this player will contribute in 2026 or beyond.
Roderick Arias
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS rostered including Bo Bichette (570.8 FPTS), Dansby Swanson (421.2 FPTS), and Ezequiel Tovar. Adding another SS prospect creates significant redundancy at an already overcrowded position.
- 21-year-old SS in Yankees system with high prospect pedigree
- Listed at MLB level but 0.0 FPTS in 2025 suggests minimal/no playing time
- No historical stat data available to evaluate development trajectory
- Zero fantasy production in 2025 despite being on MLB roster
- No stats from 2023-2024 to assess offensive development
- Yankees have Anthony Volpe entrenched at SS, blocking path to everyday role
- Complete lack of data makes evaluation highly speculative
- Rule 5 eligible status suggests other teams have also passed
Suggested Action
Pass on Arias given your SS depth and his unclear path to playing time; monitor if he gets traded to an organization with a clearer runway.
Yoniel Curet
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end assets like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Adding another speculative arm creates redundancy without addressing roster needs.
- Currently listed at MLB level with Tampa Bay organization
- Age 23 is reasonable developmental timeline for SP
- No draft pedigree information available (undrafted international signing likely)
- Zero fantasy points in 2025 despite MLB designation - suggests no meaningful innings
- No historical stats available across any season - complete unknown
- No draft background or signing bonus data to gauge organizational investment
- Missing batting/throwing hand information indicates thin scouting profile
- Tampa Bay's pitching depth makes path to rotation extremely difficult
Suggested Action
Pass on Curet - with no statistical track record, zero 2025 production, and your roster already carrying 14 SP including multiple high-upside young arms like Leiter and Misiorowski, this is not a worthwhile roster spot investment.
Brusdar Graterol
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs rostered including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Graterol would add marginal depth at a position you're adequately covered.
- Elite velocity and ground ball rate when healthy
- 2023 showed strong production (405.7 FPTS) in high-leverage Dodgers role
- Dodgers bullpen typically offers save/hold opportunities
- Massive red flag: 2024 FPTS collapsed to 30.8, 2025 shows 0.0 FPTS - indicates significant injury or role loss
- No detailed stat history available to diagnose the decline
- At 27 with chronic shoulder issues, durability is a major concern
- Even in best-case scenario, middle relievers have limited fantasy ceiling
Suggested Action
Pass on Graterol - the 2024-2025 production collapse signals serious injury concerns, and your RP depth is already sufficient with Strahm anchoring.
Alejandro Rosario
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end arms like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Adding another speculative arm creates redundancy without addressing roster needs.
- Zero fantasy points recorded in 2025 despite being listed at MLB level
- No historical stats available to evaluate performance trajectory
- Age listed as 0 indicates incomplete/unreliable player data
- Complete absence of statistical history makes evaluation impossible
- Missing basic biographical data (age, height, weight, draft info) suggests minimal prospect profile
- No MLB ID indicates player may not be on 40-man roster or have significant organizational standing
- 2025 FPTS of 0.0 suggests no meaningful MLB or MiLB contribution tracked
Suggested Action
Pass on Rosario entirely - insufficient data to justify a roster spot, and your pitching depth is already a strength that doesn't require speculative additions.
Marco Luciano
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS rostered (Bichette, Swanson, Tovar, Holliday, Lombard) making this position extremely deep. Luciano would create significant redundancy with no clear path to your starting lineup.
- Former top prospect pedigree - was consensus top-50 prospect before injuries
- Only 24 years old with raw power potential
- Traded to Pittsburgh, may get more opportunity than in SF's crowded infield
- Dismal MLB production: .211/.259/.303 slash in 27 games (2024), 0 HR in 76 AB
- Alarming 36.8% K-rate in limited MLB action
- Fantasy points nearly non-existent: 1.6 FPTS in 2024, 1.3 FPTS in 2023
- Prospect shine has faded significantly - no longer a top-100 prospect
- Contact issues suggest he may need extended AAA time in 2026
Suggested Action
Pass on Luciano - your SS depth is already elite, and his production doesn't justify a roster spot over your current options or other Rule 5 targets.
Miguel Ullola
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-upside arms like Misiorowski, Leiter, and established contributors like Castillo and Greene. Ullola would be redundant depth at best.
- 23-year-old arm who reached MLB level with Houston in 2025
- Posted 0.0 FPTS in 2025, indicating minimal MLB exposure or poor performance
- No historical stat data available to evaluate trajectory or skills
- Zero fantasy production in 2025 despite reaching MLB - major red flag
- Complete lack of statistical history makes evaluation nearly impossible
- Houston's pitching depth limits path to meaningful innings
- Unknown handedness and batting profile adds uncertainty
- No draft pedigree information suggests international signing with less scouting consensus
Suggested Action
Pass on Ullola entirely - your SP depth is elite and there's no evidence he provides any 2026 value over your current options.
Kaelen Culpepper
Roster Fit
You already have 5 SS on your roster (Bichette, Swanson, Tovar, Holliday, Lombard), making Culpepper completely redundant. There is zero positional need here.
- 22-year-old SS prospect in Twins organization
- Listed at MLB level but 0.0 FPTS in 2025 suggests minimal/no playing time
- No historical stats available to evaluate offensive profile
- Zero statistical track record provided - complete unknown
- 0.0 FPTS in 2025 indicates no meaningful MLB exposure
- Twins have Carlos Correa and Brooks Lee ahead on depth chart
- No draft background data suggests undrafted or international signing with less pedigree
- You previously let this player go - your prior evaluation was correct
Suggested Action
Pass on Culpepper - you have elite SS depth already and this player has no demonstrated value or clear path to playing time in 2026.
Brandon Clarke
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end assets like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Adding an unknown quantity like Clarke creates unnecessary redundancy.
- Zero fantasy points in 2025 suggests minimal or no MLB action
- No historical stats available to evaluate performance trajectory
- Listed at MLB level but no production data to support value
- Complete lack of statistical history makes evaluation nearly impossible
- Age listed as 0 indicates data quality issues - cannot assess development curve
- No draft background or physical information available
- 0.0 FPTS in 2025 suggests either injury, demotion, or extremely limited role
Suggested Action
Pass on Clarke entirely - with zero verifiable production data and your roster already loaded with 14 SP including multiple high-upside arms, there's no justification to add this player.
Tekoah Roby
Roster Fit
Your SP depth is already extremely deep with 14 pitchers including high-end assets like Castillo, Greene, and Imanaga. Adding another speculative arm creates redundancy without addressing roster needs.
- 24-year-old SP in Cardinals organization at MLB level
- Zero fantasy points recorded in 2025 despite being at MLB level
- No historical stat data available to evaluate performance trajectory
- Complete absence of statistical history is a major red flag
- 0.0 FPTS in 2025 suggests either no playing time or extremely limited role
- No MLB ID listed indicates potential data/tracking issues or very limited exposure
- Unknown handedness and draft background limit projection confidence
- Cardinals rotation is competitive, unclear path to meaningful innings
Suggested Action
Pass on Roby entirely - with zero verifiable production, no stat history, and your already loaded SP corps, this is not a player worth a roster spot.
Jhostynxon Garcia
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RF-eligible players including Wilyer Abreu (358.8 FPTS), Jac Caglianone, Owen Caissie, and C.J. Kayfus. Garcia would create significant redundancy at an already overcrowded position.
- Only 5 MLB games in 2025 with minimal sample size (7 AB)
- Negative fantasy points (-3.4 FPTS) in limited action
- 71% strikeout rate (5 K in 7 AB) is alarming even in small sample
- No power or speed production demonstrated at MLB level
- No statistical history prior to 2025 - complete unknown commodity
- Extremely limited MLB exposure suggests he's organizational depth, not a prospect
- At 23 with only 5 MLB games, path to regular playing time in Pittsburgh is unclear
- 163 lbs at 6'0" suggests limited power projection
- Missing draft information indicates international signing with less pedigree tracking
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Garcia is a fringe MLB player with no fantasy upside who would only clog your already deep RF depth.
Zack Gelof
Roster Fit
Creates redundancy at 2B where you already have Bryson Stott (423.7 FPTS), Jackson Holliday (333.7 FPTS), and Ozzie Albies (425.4 FPTS). No positional need exists.
- 2023 debut showed promise: .267 AVG, 14 HR, 14 SB in 69 games (247.6 FPTS)
- Speed/power combo with 25 SB in 2024 despite struggles
- Still only 26 with everyday playing time in Oakland
- Severe 2025 regression: .174 AVG, 50% K-rate (46 K in 92 AB), -3.5 FPTS through 30 games
- 2024 full season showed concerning .211 AVG with 188 strikeouts in 497 AB
- OPS collapsed from .840 (2023) to .632 (2024) to .502 (2025)
- Contact issues appear to be worsening, not improving with experience
- Oakland's rebuilding status limits lineup protection and development support
Suggested Action
Pass on Gelof entirely - your 2B depth is elite, and his 2025 collapse suggests the 2023 debut was the outlier, not the baseline.
Jordan Hicks
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RP on roster including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Hicks would add redundancy at a position of strength while providing minimal value given his 2025 collapse.
- 2024 was solid (184.5 FPTS) as a starter/swingman role
- 2023 peak (286.9 FPTS) came as Cardinals closer with elite velocity
- Still possesses elite fastball velocity (100+ mph) when healthy
- 2025 catastrophic: -5.6 FPTS with 6.95 ERA and 1.66 WHIP in 67.1 IP
- Lost starting role mid-season, demoted to bullpen with poor results
- Age 29 with extensive injury history (Tommy John surgery, forearm issues)
- 58 K in 67.1 IP (7.75 K/9) shows diminished swing-and-miss
- 32 walks in 67.1 IP indicates persistent command issues
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Hicks is a declining reliever with a destroyed 2025 season, injury history, and no clear path to high-leverage role; your RP depth is already adequate.
Zac Veen
Roster Fit
You already have Wyatt Langford at LF plus significant OF depth with Cowser, Abreu, Caissie, and Kayfus. Veen would create redundancy at a position you're already stacked.
- Former top prospect (9th overall pick 2020) with elite tools and speed upside
- Coors Field home park provides offensive boost potential
- Only 23 years old with room for development
- Brutal MLB debut: .118 AVG, .424 OPS, 41% K-rate in 34 ABs producing -8.8 FPTS
- No historical fantasy data available from 2023-2024 to establish baseline
- Rockies have crowded OF situation limiting clear path to everyday ABs
- Swing-and-miss concerns are major red flag for immediate fantasy value
- Colorado's player development track record is questionable
Suggested Action
Pass on Veen given your existing LF/OF depth and his disastrous early MLB performance; monitor if he gets consistent playing time and improves contact rates in 2026.
Chase Dollander
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on your roster including quality arms like Castillo, Greene, Leiter, and Imanaga. Adding a struggling Coors Field pitcher creates redundancy without addressing any roster need.
- Negative fantasy points (-15.1 FPTS) in 2025 despite 21 starts and 98 IP
- 6.52 ERA and 1.55 WHIP are replacement-level numbers
- 2-12 W/L record reflects poor run support AND poor performance
- 82 K in 98 IP (7.5 K/9) is below-average strikeout rate for fantasy relevance
- Pitching in Coors Field is a massive fantasy liability - inflates ERA/WHIP significantly
- 49 BB in 98 IP (4.5 BB/9) shows concerning command issues
- 103 hits allowed in 98 IP indicates hittable stuff at MLB level
- Colorado has no track record of developing quality starting pitchers
- Only 4 quality starts in 21 attempts shows inability to go deep in games effectively
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Dollander's 2025 performance was disastrous, and pitching for Colorado makes any improvement extremely difficult to translate into fantasy value.
Jared Shuster
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RP on roster including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Shuster would add no meaningful value and creates redundancy at a position you're already covered.
- 2024 showed some promise with 97.5 FPTS, suggesting a useful middle reliever role
- 27 years old, so this is likely close to his ceiling
- On White Sox roster, which may provide opportunity due to rebuilding team
- 2025 stats are disastrous: 8.04 ERA, 2.04 WHIP, -15.4 FPTS in 15.2 IP
- Negative fantasy points indicate he's actively hurting your team when used
- K/9 rate of 6.9 is below average for a reliever
- No saves or holds in 12 appearances suggests low-leverage role
- Inconsistent year-to-year performance (27.2 → 97.5 → -15.4 FPTS)
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - Shuster's 2025 collapse and lack of high-leverage role make him a roster clogger with no path to meaningful fantasy value.
Bobby Miller
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP rostered including high-upside arms like Misiorowski and Leiter. Miller would add depth but creates redundancy rather than filling a need.
- Elite 2023 debut: 376.9 FPTS across rookie season showed frontline potential
- Dodgers organization provides path to high-leverage innings and wins
- Power arm with strikeout upside when healthy (7 K in 5 IP in limited 2025 sample)
- Massive regression: -68.0 FPTS in 2024, -17.9 FPTS in 2025 shows sustained struggles
- Alarming 2025 ratios: 12.6 ERA, 2.6 WHIP in small sample indicates mechanical or health issues
- Shoulder injury history has derailed development trajectory
- Only 5 IP in 2025 suggests ongoing availability concerns
- Missing bat/throw data and draft info limits full evaluation
Suggested Action
Monitor Miller's health and performance through spring training before committing a roster spot; your SP depth allows patience here.
Triston McKenzie
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs and 14 SPs on roster. McKenzie would add redundancy to an already deep pitching staff with no clear path to high-leverage innings.
- 2024 showed modest value (76.6 FPTS) but that was likely in a starting role
- Currently listed as RP suggesting demotion from rotation
- Historical strikeout upside exists from his prospect pedigree
- 2025 stats are disastrous: 11.12 ERA, 2.47 WHIP in 5.2 IP with negative fantasy points (-21.8)
- More walks (7) than strikeouts (4) in 2025 sample indicates severe command issues
- Durability concerns at 6'5", 165 lbs - extremely thin frame has led to past injuries
- Lost starting role and now in bullpen with unclear path back to rotation
- 2023 was also poor (3.9 FPTS) suggesting 2024 may have been the outlier
Suggested Action
Pass on McKenzie entirely - his 2025 performance shows significant regression, and your pitching depth makes him unnecessary even if he rebounds.
Blade Tidwell
Roster Fit
You already have 14 SP on your roster including quality arms like Castillo, Greene, Leiter, and Imanaga. Adding a struggling pitcher with a 9.00 ERA creates unnecessary redundancy at your deepest position.
- Only 15 IP in 2025 with extremely poor results (9.00 ERA, 2.20 WHIP)
- 10 K in 15 IP shows some strikeout ability but 10 BB indicates severe command issues
- 23 hits allowed in 15 IP suggests hittable stuff at MLB level
- Former first-round pedigree (2021, Mets) provides some upside floor
- Disastrous 2025 MLB debut with -34.5 FPTS in limited action
- No historical fantasy data from 2023-2024 to establish baseline
- 2.20 WHIP and 1:1 K/BB ratio are catastrophic for fantasy value
- Now with SF after being traded - unclear path to rotation spot
- You previously let him go, suggesting you already evaluated and passed
Suggested Action
Pass entirely - your SP depth is elite and Tidwell's 2025 performance gives no reason to reconsider your prior decision to let him go.
Thomas Harrington
Roster Fit
You already have 6 RPs on roster including Matt Strahm (338.9 FPTS). Harrington would add no value and create redundancy at a position you're already adequately staffed.
- Only 3 games of MLB experience in 2025 with disastrous results
- 15.58 ERA and 2.88 WHIP across 8.2 innings is replacement-level or worse
- 7 K in 8.2 IP (7.3 K/9) is underwhelming for a reliever
- 1 save suggests some high-leverage opportunity but failed to capitalize
- Extremely small sample but results are catastrophic (-55.5 FPTS in just 3 games)
- 18 hits allowed in 8.2 IP indicates severe contact management issues
- 7 walks in 8.2 IP (7.3 BB/9) shows poor command
- No prior season data available - complete unknown track record
- Pittsburgh's bullpen situation is volatile; role is not secure
Suggested Action
Hard pass - Harrington's 2025 MLB debut was a disaster with negative fantasy value, and your RP depth is already sufficient with Strahm anchoring.