Trade Proposal Details
The Hamate's Tale ↔ Diamonds Aren't For Devers
The Hamate's Tale Gives
Ketel Marte
$44.0
2B | ARI | Age: 32
580.0 pts
685.6 pts
11.9 pts
Tanner Scott
$11.0
RP | LAD | Age: 31
250.4 pts
496.4 pts
6.5 pts
The Hamate's Tale Receives
Daulton Varsho
$3.0
CF | TOR | Age: 29
294.4 pts
342.5 pts
11.1 pts
Gavin Williams
$9.0
SP | CLE | Age: 26
542.6 pts
102.8 pts
17.0 pts
Why This Trade Works
Why This Helps The Hamate's Tale
Trades expensive Marte ($44) and underperforming Tanner Scott ($11, injured) for Daulton Varsho ($3, 294.4 FPTS, elite value CF) and Gavin Williams ($9, 542.6 FPTS, strong young SP). Saves a massive $43 in salary. Varsho at $3 is incredible keeper value. Williams gives another quality arm.
Why Diamonds Aren't For Devers Would Accept
Gets Ketel Marte, a proven star 2B who fills their need (Torres is their only 2B option and is injury-prone). Tanner Scott is an elite closer on the Dodgers. They have $64 in cap space and need offensive upgrades. Marte's track record (685.6 FPTS in 2024) is worth the investment.
Salary Impact & Risks
Salary Impact
The Hamate's Tale keeper salary before:
$446
The Hamate's Tale keeper salary after:
$403
Net change:
$-43
Risk Factors
Marte age 32 decline
Tanner Scott injured
Varsho inconsistent
Williams limited track record
Positional Impact
The Hamate's Tale gains:
CF, SP
The Hamate's Tale loses:
2B, RP
Alternative Proposals
If the main proposal is rejected, consider these alternatives:
Alternative #1
The Hamate's Tale gives:
Ketel Marte
The Hamate's Tale receives:
Daulton Varsho, Gavin Williams
Alternative #2
The Hamate's Tale gives:
Ketel Marte, Tanner Scott
The Hamate's Tale receives:
Daulton Varsho, Gavin Williams, Adrian Morejon