Trade Proposal Details

Rebels Cum ↔ The Hamate's Tale

48% Confidence

Rebels Cum Gives

Shane Bieber

$15.0
SP | TOR | Age: 31
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 128.6 pts
2024: 88.1 pts

Josh H. Smith

$11.0
SS | TEX | Age: 28
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 316.6 pts
2024: 369.0 pts
Proj: 5.5 pts

Jesus Made

$3.0
SS | MIL | Age: 19
Contract: 0 years remaining

Rebels Cum Receives (from The Hamate's Tale)

Jordan Westburg

$9.0
3B | BAL | Age: 27
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 276.5 pts
2024: 371.5 pts

Simeon Woods Richardson

$3.0
SP | MIN | Age: 25
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 250.1 pts
2024: 284.3 pts

Why This Trade Works

Why This Helps Rebels Cum

Acquires Jordan Westburg ($9), a 27-year-old 2B/3B with solid track record (371.5 FPTS in 2024) who fills the glaring 2B need. Also gets Simeon Woods Richardson ($3), a young SP with upside. Sheds Bieber's $15 injury risk and Smith's $11.

Why The Hamate's Tale Would Accept

Gets Shane Bieber ($15), a proven ace when healthy with elite peripherals (1.02 WHIP, 37 K in limited time). Josh H. Smith ($11) provides versatile infield depth at 1B/3B/SS/DH. Jesus Made ($3) is a cheap 18-year-old lottery ticket. Hamate's Tale needs SP depth with Burnes and Rodon injured.

Salary Impact & Risks

Salary Impact

Rebels Cum keeper salary before: $189
Rebels Cum keeper salary after: $172
Net change: $-17

Risk Factors

Bieber injury history
Westburg slow 2025 start
Hamate near cap

Positional Impact

Rebels Cum gains: 2B, 3B, SP
Rebels Cum loses: SP, SS, DH

Alternative Proposals

If the main proposal is rejected, consider these alternatives:

Alternative #1 38% confidence
Rebels Cum gives: Shane Bieber
Rebels Cum receives: Jordan Westburg
Alternative #2 38% confidence
Rebels Cum gives: Brady Singer, Josh H. Smith
Rebels Cum receives: Jordan Westburg, Eduardo Rodriguez