Trade Analysis Run #5 Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Trade Options for Diamonds Aren't For Devers

8 trade proposals generated

Team
Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Team Analysis

Needs Summary

Diamonds Aren't For Devers has a strong core with Ohtani, Betts, Crochet, and Fried, but has several issues. The team is heavy on pitching with mixed results (Bradish, Cavalli, Bubic underperforming/injured). The OF is thin beyond Cruz and Varsho, with Lile unproven. The team has two 3B (Suarez, Riley) and redundancy at DH. Edwin Diaz at $29 is expensive for a reliever. Several low-value roster spots (Gipson-Long, Snelling, Detmers) could be upgraded. The team needs a reliable LF, better OF depth, and could consolidate pitching assets for elite bats.

Weak Positions

LF RF 1B OF depth

Salary Pressure

At $436/$500, the team has $64 in cap space. Edwin Diaz at $29 for a reliever is expensive. Betts at $68 is the highest non-Ohtani salary but has declined from 2023. Riley at $26 has been hurt and underperforming. Bradish at $11 has been injured and poor. Several cheap filler pieces (Gipson-Long $2, Snelling $2, Detmers $4) provide minimal value.

Proposal #1 Trade with #RallyZito 62% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Austin Riley
3B | ATL
$26.0
0 yrs
Trevor Megill
RP | MIL
$6.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Junior Caminero
3B | TB
$9.0
0 yrs
Jacob Melton
CF | TB
$2.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Junior Caminero ($9), a 22-year-old 3B with 637.5 FPTS in 2025 and elite upside at a fraction of Riley's cost. Jacob Melton ($2) adds cheap OF depth. Saves $20 in salary, freeing cap space for future moves. Caminero is younger and cheaper than Riley with better 2025 production.

Why #RallyZito Would Accept

Gets Austin Riley ($26), a proven 3B with elite ceiling (655.5 FPTS in 2023) who is returning from injury and could rebound. Trevor Megill ($6) adds bullpen depth. RallyZito already has Caminero, Lawlar, and Maikel Garcia at 3B - they can afford to move Caminero for a proven star.

Risk Flags

Riley injury history Caminero small sample size Riley abdomen injury
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $383 (-21)
Proposal #2 Trade with The Hamate's Tale 60% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Eugenio Suarez
3B | CIN
$6.0
0 yrs
Aroldis Chapman
RP | BOS
$6.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Sal Frelick
RF | MIL
$9.0
0 yrs
Dennis Santana
RP | PIT
$6.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Sal Frelick ($9), a 25-year-old RF with 480.1 FPTS and solid 9.48 projection, filling the RF/OF need. Dennis Santana ($6) is a solid RP replacement for Chapman. Suarez at 34 is declining and the team already has Riley at 3B. Frelick provides youth and positional flexibility.

Why The Hamate's Tale Would Accept

Gets Eugenio Suarez ($6), who has 591.9 FPTS in 2025 - a massive bargain at $6 for a team that could use 3B depth behind Ramirez. Aroldis Chapman ($6) adds elite strikeout RP depth. Both are cheap and productive, helping their tight salary situation.

Risk Flags

Chapman age 38 Suarez age 34 Frelick ceiling questions
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $407 (+3)
Proposal #3 Trade with Clark's No Pants Party 58% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Austin Riley
3B | ATL
$26.0
0 yrs
Reid Detmers
RP | LAA
$4.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Byron Buxton
CF | MIN
$24.0
0 yrs
Rhett Lowder
SP | CIN
$3.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Byron Buxton ($24), a CF with 627.9 FPTS and 13.94 projection - elite production that fills the OF need. Rhett Lowder ($3) is a cheap young SP with upside. Saves $3 in salary while upgrading the OF significantly. Buxton's power/speed combo is elite when healthy.

Why Clark's No Pants Party Would Accept

Gets Austin Riley ($26), a proven 3B star to anchor their lineup - they lack any high-end 3B. Reid Detmers ($4) adds SP depth to a thin rotation. Clark's has massive cap space ($289 remaining) and can easily absorb Riley's salary. Riley's upside is exactly what a rebuilding team needs.

Risk Flags

Buxton injury history Riley injury Buxton age 32
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $401 (-3)
Proposal #4 Trade with Honey Nut Chourio 55% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Edwin Diaz
RP | LAD
$29.0
0 yrs
Kyle Bradish
SP | BAL
$11.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Hunter Brown
SP | HOU
$15.0
0 yrs
Austin Wells
C | NYY
$11.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Hunter Brown ($15), a 27-year-old SP with 766.3 FPTS and 19.58 projection - elite value. Austin Wells ($11) provides a younger, cheaper catcher option or trade piece. Sheds Diaz's $29 RP salary and Bradish's underperformance. Net savings of $38 in salary while upgrading SP significantly.

Why Honey Nut Chourio Would Accept

Gets Edwin Diaz ($29), an elite closer with 492.4 FPTS who fills their RP need (they only have Estrada and Abreu as quality relievers). Bradish ($11) is a buy-low SP with 630.6 FPTS in 2023 who could bounce back. They have surplus SP depth and can afford to move Brown. Wells is redundant with Contreras.

Risk Flags

Bradish injury risk for partner Diaz expensive for RP Wells underperforming
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $390 (-14)
Proposal #5 Trade with Take Maholm Tonight 48% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Gleyber Torres
2B | DET
$6.0
0 yrs
Adrian Morejon
RP | SD
$6.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Jarren Duran
LF | BOS
$19.0
0 yrs
Braxton Ashcraft
RP | PIT
$3.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Jarren Duran ($19), a 29-year-old LF/CF with 531.8 FPTS and elite speed, filling the LF gap. Braxton Ashcraft ($3) is a cheap young arm. Torres at $6 is decent value but the team has Betts at SS and doesn't desperately need 2B. Duran is a significant upgrade in the OF.

Why Take Maholm Tonight Would Accept

Gets Gleyber Torres ($6), a cheap 2B upgrade over Xavier Edwards ($13) at a lower salary. Adrian Morejon ($6) adds RP depth. Torres has 450.9 FPTS and is a proven MLB bat. The partner has $133 in cap space and can absorb salary easily while getting productive players.

Risk Flags

Torres groin injury Duran regression risk from 2024 Morejon poor early stats
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $414 (+10)
Proposal #6 Trade with James Estrada and the Green World Order 45% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Max Fried
SP | NYY
$35.0
0 yrs
Daylen Lile
RF | WAS
$4.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Corbin Carroll
RF | ARI
$22.0
0 yrs
Kyle Finnegan
RP | DET
$4.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Corbin Carroll ($22), a 25-year-old RF with 709.3 FPTS and elite speed/power combo. Carroll fills the RF need with a young star. Kyle Finnegan ($4) adds cheap RP depth. Saves $13 in salary while massively upgrading the OF. Carroll's 31 HR/32 SB profile is elite.

Why James Estrada and the Green World Order Would Accept

Gets Max Fried ($35), an elite SP with 745.7 FPTS and 20.13 projection to bolster a rotation that has Ragans struggling and Gore injured. Daylen Lile ($4) is a cheap young OF prospect. Fried is a proven ace who would slot in as their SP2 behind Skubal. However, pushes them to $470 which is manageable.

Risk Flags

Carroll's value is high - partner may want more Fried injury history Partner salary increase
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $391 (-13)
Proposal #7 Trade with John Rocker All-Stars 42% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Austin Riley
3B | ATL
$26.0
0 yrs
Kris Bubic
SP | KC
$11.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Riley Greene
LF | DET
$15.0
0 yrs
Huascar Brazoban
RP | NYM
$3.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Riley Greene ($15), a 25-year-old LF/CF with 517.3 FPTS and 10.1 projection - fills the LF hole with a young, ascending player. Saves $24 in salary. Greene is younger and more versatile than Riley, and addresses the team's biggest positional weakness.

Why John Rocker All-Stars Would Accept

Gets Austin Riley ($26), a proven 3B upgrade over Josh Jung ($13, 248.9 FPTS). Riley's ceiling is much higher. Kris Bubic ($11) adds SP depth to a rotation that has Glasnow struggling and several injured arms. However, this pushes them over cap - may need to drop a cheap piece.

Risk Flags

Partner over $500 cap - would need to cut someone Riley injury Bubic shoulder injury
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $385 (-19)
Proposal #8 Trade with The Dang Kookaburra Polks 35% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Edwin Diaz
RP | LAD
$29.0
0 yrs
Cade Cavalli
SP | WAS
$11.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Paul Skenes
SP | PIT
$30.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Paul Skenes ($30), a 23-year-old ace with 831.0 FPTS and 23.71 projection - an elite SP1 who pairs with Crochet and Fried for a dominant rotation. Sheds Diaz's $29 and Cavalli's $11 for a net $10 savings. Skenes is a generational pitching talent.

Why The Dang Kookaburra Polks Would Accept

Gets Edwin Diaz ($29), an elite closer to anchor their bullpen alongside Weaver, Cade Smith, and Uribe. Cade Cavalli ($11) is a young SP with upside. The Kookaburras have deep SP (Skenes, Alcantara, Manaea, Holmes, Priester) and can afford to trade one for elite RP help.

Risk Flags

Skenes workload concerns at age 23 Diaz expensive Cavalli unproven
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $394 (-10)