Trade Proposal Details

The Hamate's Tale ↔ Take Maholm Tonight

40% Confidence

The Hamate's Tale Gives

Wilyer Abreu

$28.0
RF | BOS | Age: 26
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 358.8 pts
2024: 329.3 pts
Proj: 7.3 pts

Tanner Scott

$11.0
RP | LAD | Age: 31
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 250.4 pts
2024: 496.4 pts
Proj: 6.5 pts

The Hamate's Tale Receives (from Take Maholm Tonight)

Jarren Duran

$19.0
LF | BOS | Age: 29
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 531.8 pts
2024: 680.1 pts
Proj: 8.2 pts

Tony Santillan

$8.0
RP | CIN | Age: 29
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 413.4 pts
2024: 129.3 pts
Proj: 5.9 pts

Why This Trade Works

Why This Helps The Hamate's Tale

Trades struggling Abreu ($28) and Tanner Scott ($11, probable lower body injury) for Jarren Duran ($19, elite LF/CF with 531 FPTS and speed) and Tony Santillan ($8, solid RP with 413 FPTS). Saves $12 in salary. Duran is a massive upgrade in the OF with speed and power, filling both LF and CF eligibility. Santillan adds bullpen depth.

Why Take Maholm Tonight Would Accept

Take Maholm gets Abreu as an RF option and Tanner Scott as an elite closer (496 FPTS in 2024, LAD closer role). Scott's injury is listed as probable, not out. They need bullpen help and Abreu has upside. Combined salary of $39 vs $27 they give up, but they have $133 in cap room.

Salary Impact & Risks

Salary Impact

The Hamate's Tale keeper salary before: $446
The Hamate's Tale keeper salary after: $434
Net change: $-12

Risk Factors

Scott lower body injury
Abreu poor 2025
Santillan volatility

Positional Impact

The Hamate's Tale gains: LF, CF, RP
The Hamate's Tale loses: RF, RP

Alternative Proposals

If the main proposal is rejected, consider these alternatives:

Alternative #1 32% confidence
The Hamate's Tale gives: Wilyer Abreu
The Hamate's Tale receives: Jarren Duran
Alternative #2 32% confidence
The Hamate's Tale gives: Wilyer Abreu, Danny Coulombe
The Hamate's Tale receives: Jarren Duran, Jakob Marsee