Trade Analysis Run #6 Guys I Have Coached Proposal

Trade Proposal Details

Guys I Have Coached ↔ Diamonds Aren't For Devers

38% Confidence

Guys I Have Coached Gives

Alex Bregman

$55.0
3B | CHC | Age: 32
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 424.6 pts
2024: 505.5 pts
Proj: 14.6 pts

Jacob Misiorowski

$4.0
SP | MIL | Age: 24
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 180.1 pts
Proj: 13.5 pts

Guys I Have Coached Receives (from Diamonds Aren't For Devers)

Garrett Crochet

$22.0
SP | BOS | Age: 26
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 895.3 pts
2024: 487.2 pts
Proj: 23.5 pts

Daulton Varsho

$3.0
CF | TOR | Age: 29
Contract: 0 years remaining
2025: 294.4 pts
2024: 342.5 pts
Proj: 11.1 pts

Why This Trade Works

Why This Helps Guys I Have Coached

Trade Bregman ($55) and Misiorowski ($4) for Garrett Crochet ($22, 895.3 FPTS - elite SP) and Daulton Varsho ($3, 294.4 FPTS with 11.09 projection filling CF need). Saves $34 in salary while adding the best SP in the deal and a versatile CF. Bregman's 3B role can be filled by Brady House.

Why Diamonds Aren't For Devers Would Accept

Diamonds gets Bregman, a proven 3B (424.6 FPTS, 14.56 projection) to upgrade over Eugenio Suarez. Misiorowski ($4) is a 23-year-old SP with high upside (13.53 projection). They have cap room to absorb the salary increase. Crochet is elite but they have deep SP (Fried, Bradish, Crochet) and can afford to move one. Varsho is a backup OF for them.

Salary Impact & Risks

Salary Impact

Guys I Have Coached keeper salary before: $378
Guys I Have Coached keeper salary after: $344
Net change: $-34

Risk Factors

Crochet workload concerns
Bregman declining
Varsho inconsistent
Partner may overvalue Crochet

Positional Impact

Guys I Have Coached gains: SP, CF
Guys I Have Coached loses: 3B, SP

Alternative Proposals

If the main proposal is rejected, consider these alternatives:

Alternative #1 30% confidence
Guys I Have Coached gives: Alex Bregman, Jacob Misiorowski
Guys I Have Coached receives: Max Fried, Daulton Varsho
Alternative #2 30% confidence
Guys I Have Coached gives: Alex Bregman
Guys I Have Coached receives: Garrett Crochet