Trade Proposal Details
The South Side Fuck Ups ↔ Clark's No Pants Party
The South Side Fuck Ups Gives
Devin Williams
$19.0
RP | NYM | Age: 31
333.8 pts
204.9 pts
6.2 pts
Andrew Benintendi
$5.0
LF | CHW | Age: 31
359.5 pts
302.8 pts
7.6 pts
The South Side Fuck Ups Receives
Michael Busch
$8.0
1B | CHC | Age: 28
571.4 pts
359.7 pts
11.6 pts
Spencer Arrighetti
$5.0
SP | HOU | Age: 26
25.9 pts
285.7 pts
Why This Trade Works
Why This Helps The South Side Fuck Ups
Devin Williams ($19) has been disappointing and Benintendi ($5) is aging with Achilles issues. Getting Michael Busch ($8) fills the 1B hole with a young, productive bat (571 FPTS in 2025), and Spencer Arrighetti ($5) adds cheap SP depth with upside. Saves $13.
Why Clark's No Pants Party Would Accept
Clark's has massive cap space ($304 remaining) and can absorb Williams' salary easily. Williams has elite closer upside when right. Benintendi is a safe, cheap OF option for a rebuilding roster. Both add veteran presence to a young team.
Salary Impact & Risks
Salary Impact
The South Side Fuck Ups keeper salary before:
$410
The South Side Fuck Ups keeper salary after:
$399
Net change:
$-11
Risk Factors
Williams inconsistency
Benintendi Achilles
Busch sophomore concerns
Arrighetti limited 2025 data
Positional Impact
The South Side Fuck Ups gains:
1B, SP
The South Side Fuck Ups loses:
RP, LF
Alternative Proposals
If the main proposal is rejected, consider these alternatives:
Alternative #1
The South Side Fuck Ups gives:
Devin Williams
The South Side Fuck Ups receives:
Michael Busch
Alternative #2
The South Side Fuck Ups gives:
Devin Williams, Andrew Benintendi
The South Side Fuck Ups receives:
Michael Busch, Pete Crow-Armstrong