Trade Analysis Run #6 Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Trade Options for Diamonds Aren't For Devers

8 trade proposals generated

Team
Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Team Analysis

Needs Summary

Diamonds Aren't For Devers has a strong core with Ohtani ($86), Mookie Betts ($68), Crochet ($22), and Max Fried ($35) but has significant weaknesses. The team lacks a reliable 1B (Devers is DH-eligible at 1B but $46 is steep for his current production). The OF is thin beyond Betts - Varsho, Lile, and Anthony are young/unproven. The pitching staff has upside but also risk (Bradish struggling, Cavalli unproven, Bubic injured). The RP corps is decent but Edwin Diaz at $29 is expensive. The team has $94 in cap space which provides flexibility. Key needs: a productive OF bat, a reliable 1B option, and potentially upgrading pitching depth while shedding some salary from underperformers.

Weak Positions

1B LF CF RF

Salary Pressure

Devers at $46 with 0.0 AVG and 0.111 OPS early is concerning. Edwin Diaz at $29 is expensive for a reliever. Ohtani at $86 is the biggest salary but justified by elite production. Betts at $68 is aging at 33 with declining numbers. The team has $94 in cap room which is healthy but several contracts are bloated relative to production.

Proposal #1 Trade with Clark's No Pants Party 62% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Eugenio Suarez
3B | CIN
$6.0
0 yrs
Reid Detmers
RP | LAA
$4.0
0 yrs
Sawyer Gipson-Long
RP | DET
$2.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Michael Busch
1B | CHC
$8.0
0 yrs
Spencer Arrighetti
SP | HOU
$5.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Michael Busch ($8), a 28-year-old 1B with 571.4 FPTS in 2025 and strong 11.56 projection, filling the team's 1B need. Also gets Spencer Arrighetti ($5) as a cheap SP depth piece with upside. Sheds Suarez ($6) who is 34 and declining, Detmers ($4) who has been terrible, and Gipson-Long ($2) who provides minimal value.

Why Clark's No Pants Party Would Accept

Clark's has massive cap space ($304 remaining) and can absorb these contracts easily. Suarez provides immediate 3B production (591.9 FPTS in 2025) for a rebuilding team. Detmers has SP upside when healthy at just $4. Gipson-Long is a cheap flier. Clark's needs production now at 3B and SP depth.

Risk Flags

Arrighetti has only 25.9 FPTS in 2025 Busch in a rebuilding CHC lineup
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $405 (+1)
Proposal #2 Trade with Take Maholm Tonight 58% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Gleyber Torres
2B | DET
$6.0
0 yrs
Adrian Morejon
RP | SD
$6.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Trevor Rogers
SP | BAL
$7.0
0 yrs
Joey Loperfido
LF | HOU
$4.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Trevor Rogers ($7), who has 514.3 FPTS in 2025 with an elite 18.59 projection - a massive SP upgrade. Joey Loperfido ($4) is a cheap LF option. Sends Torres ($6) who is injury-prone and Morejon ($6) who has been terrible in 2025 (9.0 ERA). Nearly salary-neutral.

Why Take Maholm Tonight Would Accept

Gets Gleyber Torres ($6), a proven 2B with 450.9 FPTS in 2025 who fills their 2B need (they have Xavier Edwards at 2B/SS but could use depth). Morejon ($6) is a buy-low RP who had 426.4 FPTS in 2025 despite the rough start. They have plenty of SP depth and can afford to move Rogers.

Risk Flags

Torres has groin injury Loperfido struggling badly Rogers could regress
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $403 (-1)
Proposal #3 Trade with Deville Dandies 55% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Edwin Diaz
RP | LAD
$29.0
0 yrs
Robby Snelling
SP | MIA
$2.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Oneil Cruz
CF | PIT
$13.0
0 yrs
Hurston Waldrep
SP | ATL
$6.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Oneil Cruz ($13), a 27-year-old CF with elite tools and 314.1 FPTS who fills the OF need, plus Hurston Waldrep ($6) as a young SP with 205.7 FPTS. Sheds Diaz's $29 bloated RP contract and Snelling ($2) who has no data yet. Net savings of $10.

Why Deville Dandies Would Accept

Deville Dandies has tons of cap space ($214 remaining after trade) and gets Edwin Diaz ($29), an elite closer with 492.4 FPTS. Snelling ($2) is a cheap 22-year-old SP prospect. They need RP badly - their roster is almost entirely SP/position players with no clear closer.

Risk Flags

Cruz inconsistent historically Waldrep limited track record Diaz expensive
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $392 (-12)
Proposal #4 Trade with Honey Nut Chourio 52% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Edwin Diaz
RP | LAD
$29.0
0 yrs
Kyle Bradish
SP | BAL
$11.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Will Warren
SP | NYY
$5.0
0 yrs
Jorge Polanco
DH | NYM
$7.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Sheds Edwin Diaz's bloated $29 RP contract and the struggling Bradish ($11). Acquires Will Warren ($5), a young SP with 324.4 FPTS and 12.34 projection, and Jorge Polanco ($7), a solid 2B/DH with 499.3 FPTS providing lineup depth. Saves $28 in salary, opening up significant cap flexibility.

Why Honey Nut Chourio Would Accept

Honey Nut Chourio gets a high-upside closer in Edwin Diaz ($29) who has 492.4 FPTS and 8.28 projection - they lack elite RP options (Estrada and Abreu are good but Diaz adds another tier). Bradish ($11) is a buy-low SP with 630.6 FPTS in 2023 who could bounce back. They have cap room to absorb ($500-$473=$27 remaining).

Risk Flags

Diaz expensive for RP Bradish struggling badly in 2025 Polanco is 32
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $376 (-28)
Proposal #5 Trade with #RallyZito 50% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Rafael Devers
DH | SF
$46.0
0 yrs
Trevor Megill
RP | MIL
$6.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Maikel Garcia
3B | KC
$11.0
0 yrs
Edward Cabrera
SP | CHC
$5.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Trades Devers ($46) and Megill ($6) for Maikel Garcia ($11), a 26-year-old multi-position infielder (2B/3B/SS) with 567.4 FPTS in 2025, and Edward Cabrera ($5), a 27-year-old SP with 372.3 FPTS. Saves $36 in salary while getting younger, more versatile players. Garcia's positional flexibility is extremely valuable.

Why #RallyZito Would Accept

RallyZito gets Devers ($46), a proven star who can slot at 1B alongside Vlad Jr or at DH. They're buying low on a player with 619.4 FPTS in 2025 despite the slow start. Megill ($6) adds RP depth. They go to $493 which is tight but manageable under $500 cap.

Risk Flags

Garcia has hamstring injury Cabrera inconsistent career RallyZito cap gets very tight at $493
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $368 (-36)
Proposal #6 Trade with The Hamate's Tale 48% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Rafael Devers
DH | SF
$46.0
0 yrs
Aroldis Chapman
RP | BOS
$6.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Jordan Westburg
3B | BAL
$9.0
0 yrs
Matthew Boyd
SP | CHC
$6.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Trades away Devers ($46) and Chapman ($6) for Jordan Westburg ($9), a 27-year-old 2B/3B with solid upside, and Matthew Boyd ($6), who has 598.1 FPTS in 2025 with a 19.37 projection - an elite SP value. Saves $37 in salary while adding a productive SP and versatile infielder.

Why The Hamate's Tale Would Accept

Gets Devers ($46), a name-brand 3B/1B/DH who has historically produced 600+ FPTS seasons and is only 29. Chapman ($6) provides cheap closing relief. The Hamate's Tale has Jose Ramirez at 3B but Devers can slot at DH. They're buying low on a proven star. Fits under their $500 cap at $499.

Risk Flags

Partner at $499 leaves almost no flexibility Devers slow start could continue Boyd is 35 years old
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $367 (-37)
Proposal #7 Trade with THE Bathing Beauties 45% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Daylen Lile
RF | WAS
$4.0
0 yrs
Caleb Durbin
3B | BOS
$8.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Royce Lewis
3B | MIN
$9.0
0 yrs
Landen Roupp
SP | SF
$3.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Acquires Royce Lewis ($9), a 26-year-old 3B with elite upside (286.5 FPTS in 2023, 233.7 in limited 2025 time) who could replace Suarez long-term at 3B. Landen Roupp ($3) is a cheap SP with 233.4 FPTS. Sends Lile ($4) and Durbin ($8) who are both unproven young players.

Why THE Bathing Beauties Would Accept

Bathing Beauties have massive cap space and get two young, cheap players. Daylen Lile ($4) is a 23-year-old OF with 331.7 FPTS and 6.07 projection. Caleb Durbin ($8) is a 26-year-old 2B/3B with 380.1 FPTS. Both fill needs on a team that could use young position player depth. They already have Lewis blocked somewhat with Marcelo Mayer at 3B.

Risk Flags

Lewis injury-prone historically Roupp has knee issue Lile and Durbin unproven
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $404 (+0)
Proposal #8 Trade with John Rocker All-Stars 25% confidence
View Details →

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Gives

Rafael Devers
DH | SF
$46.0
0 yrs
Kris Bubic
SP | KC
$11.0
0 yrs

Diamonds Aren't For Devers Receives

Vinnie Pasquantino
1B | KC
$13.0
0 yrs
Bobby Miller
SP | LAD
$8.0
0 yrs

Why This Helps Diamonds Aren't For Devers

Swaps Devers ($46) who has been terrible (0.0 AVG, 0.111 OPS) for Vinnie Pasquantino ($13), who has 601.9 FPTS in 2025 and fills the 1B/DH slot at a fraction of the cost. Bobby Miller ($8) is a high-upside SP lottery ticket. Saves $35 in salary while potentially upgrading 1B production.

Why John Rocker All-Stars Would Accept

This pushes them over cap which is a problem. Let me reconsider.

Risk Flags

Partner over cap - this trade needs adjustment
Diamonds Aren't For Devers Keeper Salary: $404 $368 (-36)